WXV Trade Confabulation 2018

[Purple 77]

Teams still to vote:
- Mexico City
- Pacific
- Toronto

These trade have received 0 votes so far, so will auto-pass:

Trade 24
Berlin trade: Ryan Bastinac + PSD Pick 11
Buenos Aires trade: PSD Pick 5

Trade 25
Berlin trade: Harry McKay + Pick 41
Christchurch trade: Pick 24 + Pick 29

Trade 30
Toronto trade: Kade Kolodjashnij + Ryan Clarke
Moscow trade: Rowan Marshall + Pick 26

[GoLions]

Even with all the pleads.

Majak Daw is not available for trade.

flower, i really need another defender as well. Back to the drawing board.

[RaisyDaisy]

The 3 approved trades have been updated in the Lists By Position thread

As for the remaining trades..

[Nige]

[Purple 77]

One more team left to vote.

The following trades (in addition to the above) have received 2 or less votes, so will auto-pass

Trade 26
New York trade: Reece Conca, Jordan Lewis, Robbie Tarrant + Pick 47
Cape Town trade: Pick 19 + Pick 20

Trade 31
Toronto trade: Tom Bellchambers, Matthew Leuenberger + Alex Pearce
Moscow trade: Matthew Kreuzer, Andrew Phillips + Shai Bolton

[Purple 77]

Oh whoops, this one is fine too:

Trade 28
Berlin trade: Pick 11 + Pick 48
New York trade: Justin Westhoff + Jarryd Roughead

[Purple 77]

Of the two remaining trades:

Trade 27
New York trade: Josh J Kennedy + Pick 19
New York receive: Pick 9 + Pick 41

Dublin trade: Braydon Preuss. Pick 9 + Pick 18
Dublin receive: Toby Greene + Pick 19

Christchurch trade: Toby Greene + Pick 41
Christchurch receive: Josh J Kennedy, Braydon Preuss + Pick 18

Votes: 4
Coaches comments: Questioned the value of Preuss, and that he was not worth the difference between Toby Green & Pick 9.
Admin comments:  I choose to look at it like Preuss for 19 (which you could justify), and Pick 9 + 18 for Greene. We've seen in the past that defenders/forwards about Greene's age has gone for that price in the past... so not unreasonable enough for me to overturn the decision.
Verdict: PASS

Trade 29
Buenos Aires trade: Sam Draper
Moscow trade: Sam Jacobs + Luke Partington
Votes: 8
Coaches comments: Did not at all think Draper has the currency to demand a starting ruck in Sam Jacobs, pointed to the fact Draper has not played beyond VFL level yet and that there was still Bellchambers to contend with.
Admin comments: Well yeah. I can understand how this trade came about, but agree with the coaches.
Verdict: REJECTED


All other trades have passed.

[Holz]

Time to Kick the competition into submission.

Very happy to pick up my F3/F4. Putting alot of faith in Xerri/Pittonent some hopefully one of them comes good. Saints loading up in the rucks.

[Jroo]

That's payback for Nic Newman coming in as a late change and scoring 151 against you last year  :P

[Purple 77]

WXV Draft Order & Player Lists and spreadsheet have been updated with the confirmed trades

[Boomz]

Looking to move these guys on for a pick or mid depth. Can package with picks.
Alex Morgan, Ryan Burrows, Timothy Smith, Luke Strnadica, Derek Smith, Ben McNiece, Kayne Turner

[Purple 77]

Ha, wow. I got 8 votes last night between 8.30 and 10.30

*noted for future reference*

[GoLions]

For those who have expressed interest in pick 1 already, could be gone by tonight.

[JBs-Hawks]

For those who have expressed interest in pick 1 already, could be gone by tonight.

What are you trading 1 for?

Any more thoughts on the Caleb proposal?

[meow meow]

Shane Edwards 87 average forward
Shaun Grigg 80 average mid (previously 88, 93, 91)
Tom Scully 19 average mid (previously 88, 97, 84)
David Swallow 89 average mid (previously 85, 86, 103)
Stephen Hill 72 average def (previously 80, 90, 96, 96)

Willing to package up two or possibly even 3 of these guys if a suitable deal presents itself.