WXVs Trade Confabulation 2017

[Purple 77]

In the interests of time, I'm just gonna make the verdicts on the final two trades:

PNL & Pacific still have to vote

Trade 102
Dublin trade: Hugh Greenwood, Jacob Weitering + Mason Wood 
Dublin recieve: Joel Selwood, Harley Balic, Mitchell Lewis + Pick 61

New York trade: Joel Selwood + Harley Balic 
New York receive: Luke Dunstan + Hugh Greenwood

Mexico trade: Luke Dunstan, Mitchell Lewis + Pick 61
Mexico receive: Jacob Weitering + Mason Wood 
Votes: 3
Coaches Comments: Felt Dublin was winning by too much, by trading unproven talent for a genuine captain option. Pointed to the failed Rocky deal as precedence.
Admin Comments: I personally didn't have a huge problem with the failed Rocky deal. For every argument saying Weitering is just as good as his current average, I think there is another argument saying he will be better. Mexico City obviously rates him, and yes, although Greenwood is a breakout player, the reality is that he was a 85 forward this year, and is a chance to retain it. I think he has shown enough to suggest he won't go the way of other 'mature age one hit wonders'. I think a relevant comparison here is Dunstan + 12 FOR JPK. You could argue Weitering is approximately Pick 12, and that Greenwood is approximately Dunstan. Ultimately, even if this trade got 5 votes, I don't think I disagree with the coaches enough to overturn it, if it came to it. Likewise if it got 6 votes, though. It's a fine position to sit on this fence of mine.
Verdict: PASS


Trade 112
Toronto trade: Dom Tyson, Angus Brayshaw, Matt Rosa, Cam Pedersen, Zac Clarke, Josh Walker, Nick Smith, Pick 32, Pick 34 + Pick 80
Toronto receive: Kade Kolodjashnij, Brayden Fiorini, Allen Christensen, Matthew Leuenberger, Ben McKay, Robbie Fox, Matthew Allen, Pick 37 + PSD Pick 31

Rio de Janeiro trade: Kade Kolodjashnij, Brayden Fiorini, Tom Cutler, Daniel Rioli, Matthew Leuenberger + Pick 37
Rio de Janeiro receive: Dom Tyson, Angus Brayshaw, Matt Rosa, Cam Pedersen, Zac Clarke, Luke Brown, Josh Walker, Nick Smith, Pick 32, Pick 34 + Pick 80

Beijing trade: Allen Christensen + Luke Brown
Beijing receive: Tom Cutler + Daniel Rioli

... some confusion here sorry guys, it got some votes that were attributed to the original error in the post, so I think I'll re-send it to be sure. Sorry for the delay in this, but I was waiting to see if Trade 102 was going to be negged, so I could send that trade in the same PM.

I won't be re-sending the revised trade to those that explicitly said they took the revision into account.

[RaisyDaisy]

Sad to see Jelwood go, but we're building a youthful midfield where we will develop our own players to be Revs for life, just like Jelly is a Dubliner

Fantasy Freako‏ @FantasyFreako
Always look at the way a player finishes the season. Luke Dunstan led the Saints for both #SuperCoach and #AFLFantasy points from Rnd 18 this year. #2018AFLProspectus

8)

[Ricochet]

There certainly might be a few long posts coming up.

any minute now

[Holz]

There certainly might be a few long posts coming up.

any minute now

No need.

Happy i picked up a guy who looks like he will be as good as these guys combined.

[Ricochet]

There certainly might be a few long posts coming up.

any minute now

No need.

Happy i picked up a guy who looks like he will be as good as these guys combined.

Dunno about that. Hale and Pops were guns

[Nige]

There certainly might be a few long posts coming up.

any minute now

No need.

Happy i picked up a guy who looks like he will be as good as these guys combined.

Dunno about that. Hale and Pops were guns

Excuse me, Pops still is.

[Purple 77]

There's 3 coaches to go (London, Pacific and Seoul), but I'm calling it.

Trade 112 has so far received 2 votes, with coaches feeling Toronto win by too much, and Beijing losing. Basically came down to a valuation of Christensen's worth.

Say if it did receive 5 votes though, I don't think it's unfair enough to overturn a PASS to a REJECT. So I'm gonna pass it.

[Purple 77]

Thread and spreadsheet have been updated :) in the spreadsheet, I have highlighted the names of the currently 'forced delisted' in yellow. This is subject to change.

[meow meow]

Great work Purps.

[Purple 77]

So who has defenders?

I have mids all of a sudden.

Fyfe, JPK, Jones, Viney, Goddard, ZJones, Armitage and Bastinac will get centuries this year.

flowering champion data

[Toga]

I have defenders ;)

[Nige]

You can shop at the Cairo Sands.

[meow meow]

Why help him out? Make Berlin have to play quality in the reserves and duds down back in the seniors. Unless you're determined to have them beat you when you play them, then go right ahead.

[Purple 77]

Why help him out? Make Berlin have to play quality in the reserves and duds down back in the seniors. Unless you're determined to have them beat you when you play them, then go right ahead.

Ha, brutal. I love it.

[Nige]

Why help him out? Make Berlin have to play quality in the reserves and duds down back in the seniors. Unless you're determined to have them beat you when you play them, then go right ahead.

Ha, brutal. I love it.

No defender for you.