WXVs Trade Confabulation 2017

Started by Nige, August 18, 2017, 02:34:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Purple 77

Rio on a rampage!




Another vote in, meaning this trade (that has so far received 1 vote) will auto-pass

Trade 56
Toronto trade: Jaeger O'Meara, Joel Hamling + Marco Paparone
Rio de Janeiro trade: Gary Ablett, Josh Walker + Pick 11

meow meow

Redden + #6 potentially on the move.

meow meow

Rookie 1 available. PSD 7 available.

Ricochet

Quote from: Ricochet on September 29, 2017, 07:38:05 PM
Looking to move Adam Oxley, Travis Cloke and maybe Nick Robbo

Interested in picks


Remember...


Quote from: Ricochet on September 18, 2017, 08:16:17 PM
Mark Stevens‏ @Stevo7AFL 
More
Been some confusion/debate about  Travis Cloke. His camp 100 per cent certain he will play next year, see out contract. @7NewsMelbourne

Travis "Stringer of 2015 except will average more" Cloke 8.0

May also consider trading Marc Murphy.

Has been seen to have questionable durability but in the last 5 years he has gone
2013: 21 games
2014: 20 games
2015: 19 games
2016: 10 games
2017: 22 games

2016 ruined by that big ankle injury which saw him miss the last half of the year

Scoring has never been an issue...
He's gone 100+ in 7 out of the past 10 years, and 90+ in 9 out of the 10.


Looking for a slightly younger, decent scoring mid. Can add more if needed

Purple 77

All votes in!

Trade 50
Mexico City trade: Pick 8 + Pick 18
Christchurch trade: Pick 7 + Pick 20
Votes: 0
Coaches comments: Nil
Admin comments: Nil
Verdict: PASS

Trade 51
Pacific trade: Declan Mountford + Pick 34
Mexico trade: Nathan Hrovat + Pick 57
Votes: 0
Coaches comments: Nil
Admin comments: Nil
Verdict: PASS

Trade 52
Toronto trade: Brodie Smith + Sam Wright
Mexico City trade: Pick 20 + Pick 26
Votes: 0
Coaches comments: Nil
Admin comments: Nil
Verdict: PASS

Trade 53
Toronto trade: Brad Ebert, Scott Selwood + Pick 26
Toronto receive: Lachie Hunter, Peter Wright + Harley Balic

New Delhi trade: Aaron Mullett + Harley Balic
New Delhi receive: Scott Selwood + Pick 26

Cape Town trade: Lachie Hunter + Peter Wright
Cape Town receive: Brad Ebert + Aaron Mullett
Votes: 3
Coaches comments: Felt New Delhi was winning by too much because of concerns over Mullett's value.
Admin comments: See Ricky Henderson, I reckon Mullett will be fine. It's an autopass anyway.
Verdict: PASS

Trade 54
Dublin trade: Jacob Weitering, Hugh Greenwood + Mason Wood
Mexico trade: Tom Rockliff, Elliot Himmelberg + Pre-Season Draft Pick 8
Votes: 7
Coaches comments: Felt Rockliff was worth something more substantial than 3 players with questionable scoring capabilities.
Admin comments: Personally, I would have let this pass. However, I certainly agree that Weitering shouldn't be assumed to become a fantasy gun in the future and I think this trade relies on that to some extent. Greenwood will be a handy player for sure, but a reasonable chance to lose fwd status and coupled with Wood's scoring uncertainty, I don't disagree with the coaches enough that these three players are not worth one of the best SCers of this decade when fit. I won't overturn this decision from a  REJECT to a PASS.
Verdict: REJECTED

Trade 55
Seoul trade: Tom Langdon
Christchurch trade: Pick 8 + Pick 18
Votes: 4
Coaches comments: Felt Pick 18 was paying too much.
Admin comments: Whilst I agree that Pick 18 might be a little much, I respect meow's logic/reasoning for the trade here. Langdon seems a safe 80+ bet and at 23, as shown enough evidence of improving to warrant Pick 18 on top of 8.
Verdict: PASS

Trade 56
Toronto trade: Jaeger O'Meara, Joel Hamling + Marco Paparone
Rio de Janeiro trade: Gary Ablett, Josh Walker + Pick 11
Votes: 1
Coaches comments: Felt this was too much for the unreliable GAJ.
Admin comments: It's a risk, and I love it. PAPAGUN!
Verdict: PASS

Purple 77


JBs-Hawks

Kurt Tippett is once again the number ruck at NY :P

Ricochet

Quote from: JBs-Hawks on October 01, 2017, 08:04:10 PM
Kurt Tippett is once again the number ruck at NY :P
Lol yep Paddy's in a bit of trouble

meow meow

Should have chased solid citizen Roughead instead.

Purple 77

Spencer to Port Adelaide?

If Tippett comes to melb (Demonland has discussed it), then we won't have a problem RD  ;)

meow meow

Two of #19, Fiorini, Griffen, Higgins, Scully, Redden for a better mid anyone? Could even part with SPS or #6 if the deal requires it.

Anyone want rookie pick 1? upgrade nat 48 and it's all yours

Purple 77

LeCras for mid depth? For a similar age, but north of a 70 average?

RaisyDaisy

Hah, Ryder will be there Round 1 which is all I care about ;)

Holz

Im looking for a top 30 forward, must be 27 or under.

I can probably offer a top 20 pick.


RaisyDaisy

Quote from: Holz on October 02, 2017, 10:25:40 AM
Im looking for a top 30 forward, must be 27 or under.

I can probably offer a top 20 pick.

Serious question, are there actually any forwards who are under 27 and Top 30 that would be available for a pick?

Slim pickings I'd think