WXVs Trade Confabulation 2017

[Torpedo10]

Timmy Taranto could be gone by tonight, so if you're still interested get your offers in!

[Jay]

Buenos Aires trade: Picks 19 + 20
Christchurch trade: Picks 21 + 23 + 25

Not sure if this one or the Jed Anderson trade is dumber, meow :P

[Purple 77]

Just 3 more coaches to go...

but no trades have received a neg, so all pass!

Those coaches are still required to vote though.

Trade 31
Cape Town trade: Kayne Turner + Pick 59
Tokyo trade: Dylan Clarke + Pick 39

Trade 32
Mexico City trade: Kade Simpson, Brandon White, Pick 63, + Pick 81 
Toronto trade: Nathan Hrovat, Pick 24 + Pick 38 

Trade 33
New York trade: James Harmes, Mitch Hannan, Kayle Kirby, Pick 26 + Pick 33
Mexico trade: Heath Shaw, Eddie Betts + Pick 45

Trade 34
Cairo trade: Rupert Wills
Christchurch trade: Daniel McKenzie + Pick 44

Trade 35
New York trade: Hayden Ballantyne + Mitch W Brown
Buenos Aires trade: Pick 74

Trade 36
Christchurch trade: Nathan Vardy, Pick 41 + Rookie Pick 43 
Tokyo trade: Pick 21

[meow meow]

Buenos Aires trade: Picks 19 + 20
Christchurch trade: Picks 21 + 23 + 25

Not sure if this one or the Jed Anderson trade is dumber, meow :P

Please. What would Pacific know about trading?!

Last year, almost an identical trade...

Buenos Aires trade: Picks 12 + 13
Christchurch trade: Picks 14 + 16 + 18

Enabled me to get GUNS English and Cumming while BA got nobodies Perryman, Simpkin and Berry.

[Jay]

Buenos Aires trade: Picks 19 + 20
Christchurch trade: Picks 21 + 23 + 25

Not sure if this one or the Jed Anderson trade is dumber, meow :P

Please. What would Pacific know about trading?!

Last year, almost an identical trade...

Buenos Aires trade: Picks 12 + 13
Christchurch trade: Picks 14 + 16 + 18

Enabled me to get GUNS English and Cumming while BA got nobodies Perryman, Simpkin and Berry.

Maybe a bit more of our trading restraint and you might've made finals in one of the last two seasons! ;)

Or you could have probably got those same GUNS at your original picks and got another GUN at pick 18. In the AFL, anything above a 200 point difference in draft points is unlikely to be accepted by the league. This trade here is a 556 point loss for you, effectively giving the equivalent of pick 33 away for nothing - its not quite as bad as last years but will absolutely be negging again.

[Torpedo10]

Buenos Aires trade: Picks 19 + 20
Christchurch trade: Picks 21 + 23 + 25

Not sure if this one or the Jed Anderson trade is dumber, meow :P

Please. What would Pacific know about trading?!

Last year, almost an identical trade...

Buenos Aires trade: Picks 12 + 13
Christchurch trade: Picks 14 + 16 + 18

Enabled me to get GUNS English and Cumming while BA got nobodies Perryman, Simpkin and Berry.

Maybe a bit more of our trading restraint and you might've made finals in one of the last two seasons! ;)

Or you could have probably got those same GUNS at your original picks and got another GUN at pick 18. In the AFL, anything above a 200 point difference in draft points is unlikely to be accepted by the league. This trade here is a 556 point loss for you, effectively giving the equivalent of pick 33 away for nothing - its not quite as bad as last years but will absolutely be negging again.

No chance they would've gotten English, but possibly Cumming. They used English to grab 6 though, so not too bad.

[meow meow]

So not receiving pick 33 is going to throw the competition out of whack and therefore has to be blocked? Righto.

[Purple 77]

All coaches have now voted and officially, the most recent lot of trades received no votes.

The WXV Draft Order & Player Lists thread has been updated, including the spreadsheet that is permanently available in the OP of that thread :)

[Purple 77]

I'll send another vote out once we get another 3 or 4 trades.

[Holz]

So not receiving pick 33 is going to throw the competition out of whack and therefore has to be blocked? Righto.

its that type of thinking that is making bad trades pass and good trades struggle to get through.

Each trade should be looked at on its merit if it a small deal but one side is beating the other by a fair margin it should be rejected. Likewise is its a monster trade and one side if slightly winning then it should pass even though the wider impact is the big trade has a bigger implication then the small trade.

[RaisyDaisy]

I'll send another vote out once we get another 3 or 4 trades.

So I'll expect this in about 2 weeks time then ;)

[RaisyDaisy]

I had faith in this guy after watching the season of The Recruit, and after a slow start his recent form has been very good

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-09-12/mcgovernlike-performance-could-save-the-recruit

NDT might want him for the Brisbane set, but I reckon we might hold him and elevate him to our senior list :)

[Ricochet]

I had faith in this guy after watching the season of The Recruit, and after a slow start his recent form has been very good

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-09-12/mcgovernlike-performance-could-save-the-recruit

NDT might want him for the Brisbane set, but I reckon we might hold him and elevate him to our senior list :)

Brisbane with 5 next #1 rucks next year

[Holz]

I had faith in this guy after watching the season of The Recruit, and after a slow start his recent form has been very good

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-09-12/mcgovernlike-performance-could-save-the-recruit

NDT might want him for the Brisbane set, but I reckon we might hold him and elevate him to our senior list :)

Brisbane with 5 next #1 rucks next year

Eagles has been playing in defense thats why he might stay on the list.

He got pushed out of the ruck as McInnerny is just soo good.

Making a big call that could look foolish. In a few years McInnerny will be more valuable then Menegola.

[Ringo]

I had faith in this guy after watching the season of The Recruit, and after a slow start his recent form has been very good

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-09-12/mcgovernlike-performance-could-save-the-recruit

NDT might want him for the Brisbane set, but I reckon we might hold him and elevate him to our senior list :)

Brisbane with 5 next #1 rucks next year

Eagles has been playing in defense thats why he might stay on the list.

He got pushed out of the ruck as McInnerny is just soo good.

Making a big call that could look foolish. In a few years McInnerny will be more valuable then Menegola.

Eagles in some peoples eyes was best on ground in NEAFL Final.  He had 4 intercept marks in final quarter which helped Lions to the premiership.

Re-invented himself as a defender mid season and has really turned corner.  Midway through season was doubtful if he would make it but has put in the work and shone in the last 2 games. He captained the NEAFL side in the Prelim final as well.

He has fitted in well at the club and we await to see whether Lions will give him another contract. Should be rookie listed again as a minimum if not to senior list. Could be the strong body we need to assist Andrews and co.