WXV Rules Discussion 2017

[meow meow]

Adding more coaches in would be the goal. The more the merrier. I get sick of talking to myself sometimes, even though it's the only intelligent conversation I get around here.

[Levi434]

Honestly though.

How much is 1 Paddy dow worth?

I thought he should be priced at 113. But then on discord we decided that 1 mil cap was fair. But then we thought that 2 top ten picks was fair. Like you have to use pick 1 + 2 for Paddy dow.

But then we thought about the possibility of expanding to 36 teams. Imagine having 2 Paddy dow's? Would that mean you'd have to give the top 4 picks?

Honestly I'm kind of lost.

Dove is the only one I love, but dow is making me ask questions... you know the questions all teenagers ask about their orientation...

[Adamant]

I thought we decided that picks 1 and 2 were a reasonable base. But then you'd have to add another two top 20 picks (let's say 8 + 18) for the 'premium' factor that is Paddy dow. Even then he'd still probably be undervalued.

If we expand to 36 teams then that's a whole new ball game. I'd be tempted to just assign the entire first round of the draft to secure the services of two Paddy dow's.

[Levi434]

Thank you for your reply Adamant. That is what we decided but I was just a little flustered but I guess here is the big question:

Is that fair to the rest of the comp?

We can assume a team with Paddy dow is locked in to win the premiership for as long as he plays. Say 23 years. Is that really fair?

[meow meow]

Let's get one thing straight. You don't love them. I love them.

[Purple 77]

1. Salary Cap v Points Cap (with no age discount)

Which cap would you like?

A) Salary Cap; the way it is now.
B) Points Cap; as explained by Holz here
A: 11
B: 7

2. Age discount

Would you like to see an age discount, where all players born in 1987 or earlier receive a 3% discount for every year earlier they were born? That is, if born in 1987, you would receive a 3% discount. 1986 --> 6%, 1985 --> 9% etc. This base year will be 1988 in 2018, 1989 in 2019 etc.

A) Yes, I would like to see an age discount on player cap values.
B) No, I would not like to see an age discount on player cap values.

A: 10
B: 8



I'll open up some threads

[Holz]

Well thats surprising, the one i thought was nothing but logical to auto pass failed and the one i thought was highly subjective passed.

ohh well move on to trade Period.

got to see if I can pick up Josh Kelly from Seoul. Only a 90 average mid, shouldnt cost too much  :P Might see if i can pick up Heath Shaw as a 95 defender and chuck a little extra on.

[JBs-Hawks]

Well thats surprising, the one i thought was nothing but logical to auto pass failed and the one i thought was highly subjective passed.

ohh well move on to trade Period.

got to see if I can pick up Josh Kelly from Seoul. Only a 90 average mid, shouldnt cost too much  :P Might see if i can pick up Heath Shaw as a 95 defender and chuck a little extra on.

Yes because there cap value is exactly the same as trade value.

So I'll give you 8 of my spuds for Dusty hopefully it passes and I'm not giving too much overs!

[Holz]

Well thats surprising, the one i thought was nothing but logical to auto pass failed and the one i thought was highly subjective passed.

ohh well move on to trade Period.

got to see if I can pick up Josh Kelly from Seoul. Only a 90 average mid, shouldnt cost too much  :P Might see if i can pick up Heath Shaw as a 95 defender and chuck a little extra on.

Yes because there cap value is exactly the same as trade value.

So I'll give you 8 of my spuds for Dusty hopefully it passes and I'm not giving too much overs!

It was a joke at the cap and im talking straight trade not 8 for 1.

I'm not sure what the cap is to be honest. Not a reflection of scoring power either with the 83 average player costing 100k more then then the 114 average player.

You know thats not right.

[meow meow]

Is the cap going to be revised later? Or are the min/max set? Currently it includes all the retirees prices, which will inflate the average immensely.

[Purple 77]

Is the cap going to be revised later? Or are the min/max set? Currently it includes all the retirees prices, which will inflate the average immensely.

It's consistent with all previous years, so it's set.

[meow meow]

Can you remind me of this next year? It's quite stupid to include the values of Sam Mitchell, Joey, Nroo for next years cap.

[Levi434]

Please Watch:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6njnBSMGqA

I'd appreciate if people paused to read relevant information because I think this would definitely take WXV to the next level. 

[RaisyDaisy]

Please Watch:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6njnBSMGqA

I'd appreciate if people paused to read relevant information because I think this would definitely take WXV to the next level.

Heads up for everyone else, be sure to mute the video :P

[Levi434]

Please Watch:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6njnBSMGqA

I'd appreciate if people paused to read relevant information because I think this would definitely take WXV to the next level.

I should also mention that the spreadsheet changes according to the player you are negotiating with. This is purely an example which I used.