WXV Rules Discussion 2017

[Nige]

 8)

[Purple 77]

24ish hours left of Rule Discussion! I'll be sending out the last vote about this time tomorrow.

Trade period review aside, this will be your LAST opportunity to modify a rule of the game for another year. I'm very stubborn about this.

I might tomorrow morning post a correctly discounted old players list tomorrow, that takes into account of those players that are 30 and above, not just above 30.

That's right, I don't want it, but I'll still do it for you lot :P

If you have any requests for me to draw up anything, now is the time.

[GoLions]

New idea for the 'price' of each player in the cap:

Whatever their average is, double it.

Take that new value, and multiply it by 5.

Now, divide that by their original average.

Finally, subtract 10 from this new value.

That is the new price of the player in question. Use this for all players, and then work out the new average, min, and max caps.

Ez.

[Ricochet]

Nah even better idea

We use whateva the media speculates the player is getting paid in real life

Unfortunate for whoever has Chris Mayne but seems the most logical solution

[GoLions]

Nah even better idea

We use whateva the media speculates the player is getting paid in real life

Unfortunate for whoever has Chris Mayne but seems the most logical solution

Could actually help London stay above the min cap while trading.

[Ricochet]

Nah even better idea

We use whateva the media speculates the player is getting paid in real life

Unfortunate for whoever has Chris Mayne but seems the most logical solution

Could actually help London stay above the min cap while trading.

See, it's perfect

[Purple 77]

Ok, so I've done a discount on ALL players born 30 years before the current year.

So if you were born in 1987, you get a 3% discount.

If born in 1986, you get 6%, 1985, 9% etc.

If we do this, the 'base year' will increase by 1 every year, so next year it'll be 1988

Below, are all the effected players

Player	Year born	Old Price	Discounted Price
M Priddis	1985	$669,000	$609,000
H Shaw	1985	$593,000	$540,000
S Mitchell	1982	$588,000	$482,000
D Mundy	1985	$576,000	$524,000
G Ablett	1984	$565,000	$497,000
B Goddard	1985	$555,000	$505,000
S Martin	1986	$531,000	$499,000
L Montagna	1983	$550,000	$468,000
S Mumford	1986	$549,000	$516,000
K Simpson	1984	$549,000	$483,000
J Lewis	1986	$544,000	$511,000
M Murphy	1987	$518,000	$502,000
L Franklin	1987	$488,000	$473,000
JJ Kennedy	1987	$486,000	$471,000
M Boyd	1982	$481,000	$394,000
N Riewoldt	1982	$476,000	$390,000
B Deledio	1987	$446,000	$433,000
S Burgoyne	1982	$476,000	$390,000
A Sandilands	1982	$469,000	$385,000
K Jack	1987	$457,000	$443,000
J Westhoff	1986	$431,000	$405,000
B Vince	1985	$460,000	$419,000
M Barlow	1987	$434,000	$421,000
L Hodge	1984	$452,000	$398,000
L Picken	1986	$431,000	$405,000
J McVeigh	1985	$438,000	$399,000
A Swallow	1987	$403,000	$391,000
S Thompson	1983	$410,000	$349,000
E Betts	1986	$388,000	$365,000
R Griffen	1986	$385,000	$362,000
J Gibson	1984	$382,000	$336,000
J Waite	1983	$380,000	$323,000
S Hurn	1987	$383,000	$372,000
B Stanton	1986	$377,000	$354,000
R Douglas	1987	$369,000	$358,000
M Rischitelli	1986	$366,000	$344,000
K Tippett	1987	$363,000	$352,000
Ja Roughead	1987	$361,000	$350,000
S Johnson	1983	$358,000	$304,000
D Wells	1985	$351,000	$319,000
H Taylor	1986	$362,000	$340,000
M LeCras	1986	$333,000	$313,000
R Murphy	1982	$360,000	$295,000
H Grundy	1986	$349,000	$328,000
D Petrie	1982	$344,000	$282,000
J Watson	1985	$321,000	$292,000
I Maric	1986	$329,000	$309,000
Dany Pearce	1986	$321,000	$302,000
A Mackie	1984	$328,000	$289,000
L Spurr	1987	$308,000	$299,000
P Puopolo	1987	$298,000	$289,000
M Johnson	1984	$300,000	$264,000
SD Thompson	1986	$292,000	$274,000
M Baguley	1987	$289,000	$280,000
M Rosa	1986	$267,000	$251,000
S Gilbert	1986	$254,000	$239,000
S Dempster	1984	$264,000	$232,000
C Pedersen	1987	$280,000	$272,000
T Dickson	1987	$245,000	$238,000
L Dunn	1987	$255,000	$247,000
T Lonergan	1984	$241,000	$212,000
T Cloke	1987	$239,000	$232,000
D Thomas	1987	$230,000	$223,000
T Goldsack	1987	$222,000	$215,000
S Butler	1986	$217,000	$204,000
D Morris	1982	$209,000	$171,000
S Rowe	1987	$201,000	$195,000
Ja Kelly	1983	$204,000	$173,000
A Monfries	1987	$185,000	$179,000
D Armfield	1986	$182,000	$171,000
H Ballantyne	1987	$185,000	$179,000
J Griffin	1986	$185,000	$174,000
H Lumumba	1986	$167,000	$157,000
Ma White	1987	$166,000	$161,000
J Patfull	1984	$161,000	$142,000
A Silvagni	1987	$142,000	$138,000
T Mzungu	1986	$141,000	$133,000
Z Dawson	1986	$124,000	$117,000
H Hocking	1987	$105,000	$102,000

Team	Current	Age Discounted
Beijing Thunder	$11,125,000	11,093,000
Berlin Brewers	$11,238,000	10,959,000
Buenos Aires Armadillos	$9,444,000	9,420,000
Cairo Sands	$9,856,000	9,773,000
Cape Town Cobras	$10,082,000	10,037,000
Christchurch Saints	$11,208,000	10,614,000
Dublin Destroyers	$11,248,000	11,222,000
London Royals	$10,225,000	10,204,000
Mexico City Suns	$10,918,000	10,595,000
Moscow Spetsnaz	$10,548,000	10,524,000
New Delhi Tigers	$11,368,000	11,313,000
New York Revolution	$11,147,000	10,936,000
Pacific Islanders	$11,928,000	11,872,000
PNL Reindeers	$9,951,000	9,837,000
Rio de Janeiro Jaguars	$11,512,000	11,199,000
Seoul Magpies	$10,802,000	10,777,000
Tokyo Samurai	$9,938,000	9,931,000
Toronto Wolves	$10,574,000	10,522,000
AVERAGE	$10,728,444	$10,601,556
AVERAGE + 5%	$11,264,867	$11,131,633
AVERAGE - 15%	$9,119,178	$9,011,322

[GoLions]

New idea for the 'price' of each player in the cap:

Whatever their average is, double it.

Take that new value, and multiply it by 5.

Now, divide that by their original average.

Finally, subtract 10 from this new value.

That is the new price of the player in question. Use this for all players, and then work out the new average, min, and max caps.

Ez.

You left this out of your vote Purps, so i can't respond properly yet until you send another vote out.

[GoLions]

Nah even better idea

We use whateva the media speculates the player is getting paid in real life

Unfortunate for whoever has Chris Mayne but seems the most logical solution

Also this one. It's like you don't even want the comp to be even smh.

[Ricochet]

Nah even better idea

We use whateva the media speculates the player is getting paid in real life

Unfortunate for whoever has Chris Mayne but seems the most logical solution

Also this one. It's like you don't even want the comp to be even smh.

Our voices always fall on deaf ears

[Holz]

So on reflection I have looked at modifying the 18+ game on some of the comments about Kelly Oliver etc...

18+ games: 100% of the current season is their average
11-17 games: 50% of the current average 30% of last years and 20% of the year before
6-10 games: 35% of the current average 40% of last years and 25% of the year before
5 or under: 20% of the current average 50% of last years and 30% of the year before.
0 games: 60% of last year and 40% of the year before.


I think the 18+ games: should be 90% of current season and 5% of the previous seasons.

SO just doing the top NDT players.

Marc Murphy: Ossie 101, Holz original 109, Holz New 107
Sidey: O: 102, H1 97 H2 98
Stef Martin: 100 under all 3
Gray: O:104, H1 93 H2 95
Howe O:87 H1:96 H2:95
Llyod O:81 H1:88 H2:87
M.Crouch: O:92 H1:110 H2:107

The Holz 2.0 puts bolters a little down and sliders a little up.

The biggest difference can be seen in Robbie Gray v Matt Crouch. Now Gray has slipped down to a 93 average but under the current system is priced at a 104, where as my new system has him at 95. Matt Crouch has been improving each year 68 92 now 100, the current system has him at a low 92 a massive 18 points under his current average, i have him at 107.

Not sure about you but

110 average Mid should cost more then a 93 mid in my books. i have Matt Crouch 12 points more then Gray and in real life he averaged 17 points more. Under the current system Gray costs 12 points more despite averaging 17 points less.

[Purple 77]

Nah even better idea

We use whateva the media speculates the player is getting paid in real life

Unfortunate for whoever has Chris Mayne but seems the most logical solution

Also this one. It's like you don't even want the comp to be even smh.

GL kinda just goes out the other ear, with all of his #scrapthecap garbage  :P

It's the price to pay I guess for having that agenda  :-X

[GoLions]

Nah even better idea

We use whateva the media speculates the player is getting paid in real life

Unfortunate for whoever has Chris Mayne but seems the most logical solution

Also this one. It's like you don't even want the comp to be even smh.

GL kinda just goes out the other ear, with all of his #scrapthecap garbage  :P

It's the price to pay I guess for having that agenda  :-X

I made a genuine cap suggestion tyvm. Give me a spreadsheet with all players and I'll do the new cap for every single one.

[Purple 77]

Nah even better idea

We use whateva the media speculates the player is getting paid in real life

Unfortunate for whoever has Chris Mayne but seems the most logical solution

Also this one. It's like you don't even want the comp to be even smh.

GL kinda just goes out the other ear, with all of his #scrapthecap garbage  :P

It's the price to pay I guess for having that agenda  :-X

I made a genuine cap suggestion tyvm. Give me a spreadsheet with all players and I'll do the new cap for every single one.

Game on

https://jumpshare.com/v/54PSfRc7GOwbG3FJ3iHT

[GoLions]

New idea for the 'price' of each player in the cap:

Whatever their average is, double it.

Take that new value, and multiply it by 5.

Now, divide that by their original average.

Finally, subtract 10 from this new value.

That is the new price of the player in question. Use this for all players, and then work out the new average, min, and max caps.

Ez.

Had to make a slight adjustment in case they don't play a game and thus avg is 0