Round 20 Trades

[North Melbournes Finest]

Finished 1st in cash league.

6 trade lefts, $300 in bank.

Option 1 -
JPK - Any midfielder
Nankervis/Scharenberg/Greenwood - rookie

or

Option 2 -
Dangerfield - Lachie Neale
Nank/Scharenberg/Greenwood - Zach Merrett

Anyone have any suggestions?

Keep danger
JPK to Premo mid around the same price, a few to choose from
Nank/ schaz to premo?

I would trade JPK to Beams but that would give me 4 Brisbane players playing this week. Schaz is only 270k and Nank is 400k, with no funds in the bank tough to turn them into premos.

[Marstar]

Witts to Nroo or Billings (via DPP)?

I can't decide ...  :'(

[North Melbournes Finest]

Witts to Nroo or Billings (via DPP)?

I can't decide ...  :'(

Definitely not Billing. But wouldn't be thrilled about Riewoldt either.

[TomK]

Witts to Nroo or Billings (via DPP)?

I can't decide ...  :'(

Can't get a good ruck? Gawn?

[SilverLion]

Witts to Nroo or Billings (via DPP)?

I can't decide ...  :'(

Neither IMO. Find the coin to get a Ryder/Gawn type.

[monga77]

Finished 1st in cash league.

6 trade lefts, $300 in bank.

Option 1 -
JPK - Any midfielder
Nankervis/Scharenberg/Greenwood - rookie

or

Option 2 -
Dangerfield - Lachie Neale
Nank/Scharenberg/Greenwood - Zach Merrett

Anyone have any suggestions?

Keep danger
JPK to Premo mid around the same price, a few to choose from
Nank/ schaz to premo?

I would trade JPK to Beams but that would give me 4 Brisbane players playing this week. Schaz is only 270k and Nank is 400k, with no funds in the bank tough to turn them into premos.

Apologies, read it as 300k, still would keep danger, trade jpk

[North Melbournes Finest]

Finished 1st in cash league.

6 trade lefts, $300 in bank.

Option 1 -
JPK - Any midfielder
Nankervis/Scharenberg/Greenwood - rookie

or

Option 2 -
Dangerfield - Lachie Neale
Nank/Scharenberg/Greenwood - Zach Merrett

Anyone have any suggestions?

Keep danger
JPK to Premo mid around the same price, a few to choose from
Nank/ schaz to premo?

I would trade JPK to Beams but that would give me 4 Brisbane players playing this week. Schaz is only 270k and Nank is 400k, with no funds in the bank tough to turn them into premos.

Apologies, read it as 300k, still would keep danger, trade jpk

It's looking like Shaz > Connor Glass and JPK > Neale

Leaves me for 120k with 4 trades left, and get to bring Dangerfield back onto the field next week potentially as a POD in my finals campaign.

Or do I go Shaz > Connor Glass and Nank to Neale, hoping JPK comes back next week and that strengthens up my side for the rest of the finals?

[Ringo]

With 2 trades looking at holding but bench threadbare as fielding Witherden, Greenwood and Parsons  - JPK and Danger on mid bench and Ryder covering Darcy. Looked at trades but everything I looked at may be problematic over next 3 weeks so hoping not to bite.

[North Melbournes Finest]

I've flipped everything here. I was going to do

JPK > Lachie Neale
Schaz > Glass

but I think I'm now going to do

Nank > Gawn
Shaz > Glass

Nank was going to be an emergency on my bench this week anyway, and this means that if JPK comes back in next week I'll have one more premium in than if I do option 1 here. If JPK doesn't come in next week I'll still have the cash to use 1 trade and trade him up to Neale, or if he does play I can double trade again and get another premium.

Would appreciate anyone weighing in on this situation, am I silly to trade Nank over JPK?

[Jesty]

With 2 trades looking at holding but bench threadbare as fielding Witherden, Greenwood and Parsons  - JPK and Danger on mid bench and Ryder covering Darcy. Looked at trades but everything I looked at may be problematic over next 3 weeks so hoping not to bite.

Thats pretty much my dilemma.
Holding my 2 trades and getting both back next week and basically giving away a chance straight to prelim. Or trade JPK to Oliver to have a chance this week.
If JPK misses again then I will kick myself.
Hmmmm hard lol

[GoSaints3]

Have witts and Wingard injured and sloane.

Original plan was Wingard to Ryder and Sloane to titchell.

Now that witts is injured idk if I should trade both witts and Wingard or just one and still trade sloane.

Have greenwood as cover and opponent has greenwood on the field so happy to just sub him for one.

My question is who will come back first? Wingard or witts?

Thanks in advance

[GoSaints3]

Have witts and Wingard injured and sloane.

Original plan was Wingard to Ryder and Sloane to titchell.

Now that witts is injured idk if I should trade both witts and Wingard or just one and still trade sloane.

Have greenwood as cover and opponent has greenwood on the field so happy to just sub him for one.

My question is who will come back first? Wingard or witts?

Thanks in advance

Anyone?

[SilverLion]

Have witts and Wingard injured and sloane.

Original plan was Wingard to Ryder and Sloane to titchell.

Now that witts is injured idk if I should trade both witts and Wingard or just one and still trade sloane.

Have greenwood as cover and opponent has greenwood on the field so happy to just sub him for one.

My question is who will come back first? Wingard or witts?

Thanks in advance

Witts would be risky to keep, but then again Wingard even if he does is no certainty to score well. Tough one. Depends on trades left and cash available. But would go Witts --> Gawn/Ryder trades and cash allowing.

[GoSaints3]

Have witts and Wingard injured and sloane.

Original plan was Wingard to Ryder and Sloane to titchell.

Now that witts is injured idk if I should trade both witts and Wingard or just one and still trade sloane.

Have greenwood as cover and opponent has greenwood on the field so happy to just sub him for one.

My question is who will come back first? Wingard or witts?

Thanks in advance

Witts would be risky to keep, but then again Wingard even if he does is no certainty to score well. Tough one. Depends on trades left and cash available. But would go Witts --> Gawn/Ryder trades and cash allowing.

Thanks mate

[Ringo]

I would stick to your original plan if cash and trades allow. Witts shoulder was listed as 1/2 weeks so he could be back next week. Assume you have DPP to move Ryder to Rucks this week.