Is it time to get rid of Rocky?

[StuL]

He doesn't look anywhere near it.Even if he comes good by SC Grand Final day you probably won't make it that far carrying him for much longer. He's playing bruise free footy and so far off his best I can't see him coming good in a hurry. So I'm voting yes. However..

[ivolve]

For what its worth, i'd hold. this time of year trades are slim, Zorko is getting the tag, beams will get some focus, lions aren't terrible, Rocky is sore but will only get stronger and we all know he can pull out huge numbers. I personally don't have him but hate playing people who do because he is such an x factor. look at Fyfes turn around,

[dylanclements]

Depends a little bit, I reckon. Like many, I have Rocky and Sloane. If Fyfe had not come good I'd be a bit worried running all three. Fyfe looks good for 115ish on current evidence, and I reckon Sloane and Rocky will do enough to go over 100 even though they're in a bit of a rut. That should be enough to justify holding for M7 and M8.

My guess is Rocky is M7-8 is okay. If you have the cash and trades to easily go straight Merret or someone looking set on 115+ there's possibly value, but yeah, I would've thought hold

[Bully]

The only guy I can afford is Beams so I'll just hold and hope for the best.

[LordSneeze]

I want too, but the injuries to Danger, Pendles, Yeo, have me considering holding.

[enzedder]

With everyone looking at dumping him, I'm looking at the possibility of jumping on for SSelwood at M9 in a straight swap.
Spewing I'm 5k short of Jelwood... curious to know their BEs, if anyone could post them,  I'd appreciate it.

[Ringo]

Scooter B/e 105
Jelwood B/E 55

Rockliff B/e 114

His shoulder though really effecting hi,
Av Tackles rd 1 - 8 8.25
Av Tackles Rd 12 - 17 3.8

[enzedder]

Scooter B/e 105
Jelwood B/E 55

Rockliff B/e 114

His shoulder though really effecting hi,
Av Tackles rd 1 - 8 8.25
Av Tackles Rd 12 - 17 3.8

Cheers Ringo...will probably hold but really wanna see Scooter back in.
Looks like Jelwood wasn't meant to be for me this year.

[Bluesalltheway]

Scooter B/e 105
Jelwood B/E 55

Rockliff B/e 114

His shoulder though really effecting hi,
Av Tackles rd 1 - 8 8.25
Av Tackles Rd 12 - 17 3.8

He's also just not getting much of the footy. 14 disposals on the weekend and has averaged 22 since coming back.

[RaisyDaisy]

I just have to keep him and put up with his scores. Just hope he gets better

I've got Pendles who is looking like he might need to go

[StuL]

I want too, but the injuries to Danger, Pendles, Yeo, have me considering holding.

I now have this to deal with. If it was only Yeo and Danger I'd chance it and flog him but now probably have to hold. Also have Scooter so can't trade a 'fit' player when I have injuries.

[bkimm32]

What's wrong with pendles??

[quinny88]

What's wrong with pendles??

Broken finger. Apparently only missing 2 weeks though

[StuL]

What's wrong with pendles??

Broken finger. Apparently only missing 2 weeks though

But do you believe that? Do you hold him and then find in two weeks he's done? These aren't easy questions.

[tommy10]

What's wrong with pendles??

Broken finger. Apparently only missing 2 weeks though

But do you believe that? Do you hold him and then find in two weeks he's done? These aren't easy questions.

I think he'll miss at least 3 so he's gone for me. Merrett in.