WXV Round 12: The Frantic Fight for Finals

[AaronKirk]

Running a bit thin in defense. No Ruck. No HGA. No worries with no Libba.

[Purple 77]

Alex Rance, Grant Birchall, Tom McDonald, Oscar McDonald
Dustin Martin (C) Adam Treloar, Rory Sloane (VC), Stephen Hill
Todd Goldstien,
Justin Westhoff, Jack Gunston, Jack Reiwoldt, Todd Marshall
Brad Crouch, Tom Hawkins

Emg:  Paddy Brophy,  Ed Vickers willis ,Hugh Greenwood

Just making sure Holz' opponent knows that this has been approved by me, as Holz has accepted a strike, allowing me to name his team based off preferences, where only the Adel/Haw players were locked in. This means Crouch was named as U1, and he was lucky Greenwood snuck in as the 18th man, but he was able to still name the players from other teams around him and other Adel/Haw games.

[Purple 77]

Also, god damn Fyfe. And me for not being able to replace him in time.

[RaisyDaisy]

Also, god damn Fyfe. And me for not being able to replace him in time.

Harmes + Hannan for Fyfe

Post it up and I'll confirm

[Jay]

Alex Rance, Grant Birchall, Tom McDonald, Oscar McDonald
Dustin Martin (C) Adam Treloar, Rory Sloane (VC), Stephen Hill
Todd Goldstien,
Justin Westhoff, Jack Gunston, Jack Reiwoldt, Todd Marshall
Brad Crouch, Tom Hawkins

Emg:  Paddy Brophy,  Ed Vickers willis ,Hugh Greenwood

Just making sure Holz' opponent knows that this has been approved by me, as Holz has accepted a strike, allowing me to name his team based off preferences, where only the Adel/Haw players were locked in. This means Crouch was named as U1, and he was lucky Greenwood snuck in as the 18th man, but he was able to still name the players from other teams around him and other Adel/Haw games.

Surely if Crows and Hawks players were already locked out he can't have them?

[Purple 77]

Alex Rance, Grant Birchall, Tom McDonald, Oscar McDonald
Dustin Martin (C) Adam Treloar, Rory Sloane (VC), Stephen Hill
Todd Goldstien,
Justin Westhoff, Jack Gunston, Jack Reiwoldt, Todd Marshall
Brad Crouch, Tom Hawkins

Emg:  Paddy Brophy,  Ed Vickers willis ,Hugh Greenwood

Just making sure Holz' opponent knows that this has been approved by me, as Holz has accepted a strike, allowing me to name his team based off preferences, where only the Adel/Haw players were locked in. This means Crouch was named as U1, and he was lucky Greenwood snuck in as the 18th man, but he was able to still name the players from other teams around him and other Adel/Haw games.

Surely if Crows and Hawks players were already locked out he can't have them?

He's taking a strike, which effectively means he didn't name a team. In those circumstances, I would name a team for him, which would include all available players. He accepted the strike in-between the partial and full lockouts, meaning he could still move around the other players.

The risk is that if he gets another strike later in the year, he loses a premiership point.

[Purple 77]

Will do a score update a bit later today sorry guys, been a bit unavailable over the past 48-72 hours

[Nige]

That's a pretty clever way to go about it.

[Ricochet]

But Holz named a team??

[Ricochet]

Def
Mid: Sloane (VC)
Ruck
Fwd
Util

Emg: Jack Gunston, Hugh Greenwood, Grant Birchall

[GoLions]

But Holz named a team??

Yeah, I'm not a huge fan of this seeing as he had already named a team.

[meow meow]

Surely those players are locked, then the rest of the team gets filled on preferences once the full lockout is in effect if he didn't name the rest of the team.

[Ringo]

But Holz named a team??

Yeah, I'm not a huge fan of this seeing as he had already named a team.

Agree as he had named that team and taking a strike the Crows/Hawks players listed should be the only players from those 2 clubs allowed and then team filled with priority list then.

[Nige]

Def
Mid: Sloane (VC)
Ruck
Fwd
Util

Emg: Jack Gunston, Hugh Greenwood, Grant Birchall

But Holz named a team??

Yeah, I'm not a huge fan of this seeing as he had already named a team.

Not only that, but Holz went on to name a full team Friday morning.

Def A.Rance, T.Mcdonald, O.Mcdonald, B.Probhy
Mid: R.Sloane (VC), D.Martin (C), A.Treloar, S.Hill
Ruck T.Goldstien
Fwd: J.Westhoff, Jack Reiwoldt, T.Hawkins, T.Marshall
Util: N.Jones, J.Weitering

Emg: Jack Gunston, Hugh Greenwood, Grant Birchall

Couple that with Holz saying:

I forgot crouch.

I hate thursday night football

It's pretty obvious what happened here.

Holz knew exactly what would happen if he took the strike, if you look at the Friday team and the team Purps has put up for him, it's pretty obvious that the one Purps has suits him a lot better because it includes Crouch and still gets Greenwood.

Surely that can't happen.

[RaisyDaisy]

What am I missing here?

He named Thurs players to loop, and then named the rest of his side Friday morning

He forgot Crouch, so he's not in the side this week, as per the Friday listed team

What's the problem?