UTG Season 2: Round 12 Team Submissions

[Nige]

D: Hibberd, T. McDonald, Harbrow (Mayes)
M: Crouch, Mundy, Atkins (Dumont)
R: McEvoy
F: Heeney, Lynch, Wright (SE) (Gunston)
U: Tippett (Breust)

::)

D: Hibberd, T. McDonald, Harbrow Jones (54)(Mayes)
M: Crouch (83), Mundy (90), Atkins (99) (DumontSPP)
R: McEvoy (90)
F: Heeney (113), Lynch (100), Wright (SE+20%) (96) (Gunston)
U: Tippett (BreustGunston (138))

863/9

I'd like to ask a question about this. Typically, in other comps like this, emergencies are listed in preferential order on a separate line whereas in this method best demonstrated by JV, it's a little too convenient for him to kinda just pull Gunno's score even though he was forward emg before Tippett wasn't selected and Breust was a late out. Obviously, there's not a lot that can be done in the sense that it's JV's word that he'd have named Gunno first but surely we enforce one way or the other of naming emergencies.

Wasn't much I could do as I only knew about the Breust out before games on sat morning which is when I had to reshuffle with what players I had playing.  I don't see the point in just listing emergencies down the bottom as you need an emergency for each line, can't have 3 defender emergencies and slip one into the forward spot (I'm sure thats not what you're saying).  I feel I've adjusted my team fairly based on OUTS, if you look at my team I basically had noone that could fit into that utility spot except for Gunston as Jenkins had already played, it also left me with no forward emergency which could've worked out the opposite for me if Wight or Lynch were late out's.  So it works both ways, but happy to take whatever ruling is given.

Yeah, I understand what you did and why you did it. I just really wanted a clear, official ruling on how it should be done because it gets a bit messy if half the coaches are doing things one way and half are doing it the other.

For the other comps, when we list emergencies down the bottom, we put them in preferential order and list their positions. My own team submission is an example of this, Coop's has it too (and we've basically done it through habit)

The way you've done it is fine in standard UTG as we don't actually have a utility/interchange spot but it's a factor now because we're trialling this during the byes.

What typically happens in the other comps (which all have utility/interchange spots) with late outs is that the interchange covers the late out in a particular position and the emergencies just move up and replace the player who moved out of the interchange.

So for example, if you'd name emergencies in the format I do and Gunston was your first emg ahead of Breust, then he'd have come on. Or, if you'd named Breust first emg, Gunston second, then because Tippett didn't play and Breust was a late out, you'd have still got Gunston.

But yeah, Ryno's clarified how it works now and it's only really worth worrying/thinking about for next round given we revert back to no interchange in Round 14 anyway.

Edit (kinda, just saw Dav's new reply :P): Dav also explain it fairly well.

[fanTCfool]

The rules of UTG state "one emergency per position" so my interpretation is that JV receives 0 for his utility spot.

Breust was the emergency for the utility position, and scored 0 as did Tippett.

Harsh, but I believe that it is how it should be, it gets a little complicated with the involvement of the utility where any player can theoretically cover it though.

Fair enough, I guess this would change if I had named Tippett and Breust and they both were omitted when teams were first announced, then I'd assume I could put in another emergency in place of Breust?

Absolutely, if you had removed Tippett on Thursday, moved Breust to U1 and added Player X, whether it be Gunston or someone un-named to the Utility emergency then you would receive Player X's score.

[TomK]

DEF: M.Hurley (86), B.Smith (90), M.Baguley (23)
MID: M.Murphy (104), M.Crouch (83), E.Curnow (77)
RUC: J.Witts (115)
FOR: B.Hill (111), C.Petracca (93), B.Acres (49)
UTIL: J.Lyons (118)

949

If only Baguley and Acres weren't potatoes.

[TomK]

Michael Hurley (86), Josh Smith (35), Caleb Marchbank (87) (Josh Gibson)
Dan Hannebery (105), Jack Viney (96), Clayton Oliver (96)
Tom Boyd (0)
Chad Wingard (71), Isaac Smith (93), Michael Walters (111) (Cam Pedersen)
Brad Crouch (95)

648/8

875

[TomK]

PakAttak

Jake Lloyd (122), Luke Hodge (DNP - Berry 73), Jayden Hunt (SE) (93)
Liam Shiels (92) , Pearce Hanley (72), Rory Atkins (99)
Matthew Kreuzer (149)
Christian Petracca (93) , George Hewett (53), Alex Neal-Bullen (78)
Tom Scully. (75)

Jake Barrett (M) (102), Levi Casboult (F) (61), Jarrod Berry (D) (73)

735/8

Barrett  :'(

999

[TomK]

Pucker Up Boiz

Josh Smith 35, Jake Lloyd 122, Brodie Smith 90
Bryce Gibbs 108, Lachie Whitfield 125, Dylan Shiel 122
:(
Jeremy Cameron 57, Christian Petracca 93, Ryan Burton 62
Liam Picken 78

Liam Shiels (m), WHE (f), Marcus Adams (d)

764/8

892

[TomK]

Go Pack Yourself

Matthew Boyd (86), Jeremy Howe (95), Caleb Marchbank Michael Hurley (86)
Ollie Wines (107), David Mundy, Dom Tyson (82), Jared Polec (80)
rip
Chad Wingard (71), Blake Acres (49), Sir Daniel of Caleb (87)
Lachie Hunter (66)

David Mundy, Caleb Marchbank, Brendon Ah Chee, Jack Hombsch Tom Bell

Hurley in for Marchbank

239/3 :-\

flower i named an extra mid as well aha

Mundy to the bench then, annoying cause I would have played him over Hunter haha

809

[TomK]

DEF: Easton Wood, Dylan Roberton, ???
MID: Nathan Fyfe, Brad Crouch, Dayne Beams, Jack Newnes (Tom Bugg)
RUC: Matthew Kreuzer
FWD: Jack Watts, Caleb Daniel, George Hewett
UTI: Jack Crisp

1 too many mids there ;)

Right you are!

DEF: Easton Wood (68), Dylan Roberton (78), ???
MID: Nathan Fyfe (82), Brad Crouch (95), Dayne Beams (145) (Jack Crisp)
RUC: Matthew Kreuzer (149)
FWD: Jack Watts (84), Caleb Daniel (87), George Hewett (53)
UTI: Jack Newnes (113)

954

[TomK]

Def:  Brodie Smith (90), Dylan Roberton (78), Christian Salem (95) (Jacob Weitering)
Mid: David Zaharakis (113), Nathan Jones (118), Issac Smith (93) (Travis Boak)
Ruc: Matthew Leuenberger
Fwd: Jarryd Roughead (84), Jeremy Cameron (57), Richard Douglas (91) (Cam McCarthy)
Utu: Brendan Goddard (88)

907

[TomK]

D: Hibberd, T. McDonald, Harbrow (Mayes)
M: Crouch, Mundy, Atkins (Dumont)
R: McEvoy
F: Heeney, Lynch, Wright (SE) (Gunston)
U: Tippett (Breust)

::)

D: Hibberd (57), T. McDonald (66), Harbrow Jones (54)(Mayes)
M: Crouch (83), Mundy (90), Atkins (99) (Dumont)
R: McEvoy (90)
F: Heeney (113), Lynch (100), Wright (SE) (96) (Gunston)
U: Tippett (Breust)

848

Which Crouch? Which Lynch? ::)

[TomK]

Def: Michael Hibberd (57), Jack Martin (60), Zak Jones (54) (Nic Newman
Mid: Dan Hannebery (105), Matt Crouch (83), Seb Ross (113) (Jarryd Lyons)
Ruc: Matthew Kreuzer (149)
Fwd: Richard Douglas (91), Mitch Wallis (73), Jarryd Roughead (84) (Nathan Hrovat)
Util: Jack Newnes (113) (Robbie Gray)

982

[TomK]

Rapid Pack Movement

Def - Kolodjashnij, Kade (82) / Suckling, Matt (71) / Burgoyne, Shaun (89)
Mid - Hunter, Lachie (66) / Scully, Tom (75) / Tyson, Dom (82)
Ruck - McEvoy, Ben (90)
Fwd - Douglas, Richard (91) / Walker, Taylor (92)/ Hill, Bradley (111)
Utility - Vince, Bernie (59)

Interchange
Miller, Touk / Wellingham, Sharrod / Atley, Shaun / Hawkins, Tom

908

[TomK]

Jack Martin (60), Daniel Talia (52), Alex Silvagni (4)
Bryce Gibbs (108), Lin Jong (46), Hugh Greenwood (49) (Tom Liberatore )
Jarrod Witts (SE) (138)
Lance Franklin (101), Jarryd Roughead (84), Jack Gunston (138)
Christian Petracca (93)

873

[TomK]

Koop - 999 - 100G
Big Mac - 982 - 80G
BB - 954 - 70G
Tom - 949 - 60G
LS - 908 - 50G
Hawka - 907 - 50G
Nige - 892 - 50G
Wato - 875 - 50G
Holz - 873 - 40G
Jvalles - 848 - 40G
GL - 809 - 40G
ele - rip - 40G

[GoLions]

Yeah no ruck definitely hurt this week. Reckon I'll be looking ok for next week though.