Round 12 Trades

[crowls]

option 1.
mcgrath>bont
evw>ryan
otten>hibberd.


20 starters with 16 prems.    harbrow and Sandi on the park but not playing.
3 rookies down back,  ryan, newman, scharenberg
next week - newman>lloyd  only rookie starting will be stewart d6,      fwds/mids are already finished with steele at f7/m9

[js19]

SPP to Cousins
Fyfe to Rocky
Shaw to Roberton

Need some rd13 playing premos, and Fyfe and Shaw might need a run in my seconds ::)

[batt]

Fisher to Cousins
Fyfe to Docherty (via Hibberd to mids)

Luxury trade? Stupid trade?

Luxuriously stupid and stupidly luxurious

Docherty BE 127

Rocky BE 55

Disagree Doc.  Maneuvering around the byes is a big tick.  Docherty is an absolute must - certainly not at $600k but the sooner you bring him in the better.  Fyfe's going to be at least 10ppg under a top 10 midfielder.  Don't think there's anything luxurious about moving on from Fyfe- but certainly Rocky should be the first trade in target.

[tor01doc]

Fisher to Cousins
Fyfe to Docherty (via Hibberd to mids)

Luxury trade? Stupid trade?

Luxuriously stupid and stupidly luxurious

Docherty BE 127

Rocky BE 55

Disagree Doc.  Maneuvering around the byes is a big tick.  Docherty is an absolute must - certainly not at $600k but the sooner you bring him in the better.  Fyfe's going to be at least 10ppg under a top 10 midfielder.  Don't think there's anything luxurious about moving on from Fyfe- but certainly Rocky should be the first trade in target.

I too disagree....with me

I thought he meant Rocky not Fyfe

My bad

Just ignore me

[quinny88]

Scharenberg or wait for Ryan? Don't know if either are worth it but don't have much of a choice  :-\

[Bully]

Scharenberg or wait for Ryan? Don't know if either are worth it but don't have much of a choice  :-\

I'm just grabbing Ryan, the extra cash will be gold at this stage. With trades so low it would pay to make every one count. Hoping Freeman gets a game soon as he will probably be my last rookie.

[Hawka]

Im messing around atm
Myers or Pickett to Cousins
Marchbank or Newman( 99% marchy) to Hibberd
and maybeee just maybe
Preuss to Strindica for cash and use nank for dpp

[Judd Magic]

Not happy with Treloar last 3 weeks? I'd be wanting to bring him in! The week off did him wonders

I'm quite worried about the effects of a Vince tag x2, PA x2, Adelaide, Geelong, and WCE (away).
Dons, GC, Hawks and North are the only games I am quite confident he will score well in. Whilst he's scored well the last 3 weeks he's effectively not done what I needed him to do and that was eat up the easier first half of the year draw.

Fyfe has a much better record against his opponents on the way home and finishes with GC, Sydney, Richmond and Essendon. Also has Hawks, NM and Brisbane so much larger scope of teams to improve against than Treloar.

Plus also the $70k difference in price is a big selling point. Fyfe against Brisbane this week could see him score anything. Then hopefully the week off freshens him up, Sandi back too and then bam kills the second half of the year.

Treloar did fine yesterday when Blakely was tagging him in the 2nd half. I'm not against the trade to Rocky but on form would trade Fyfe over him if you were going to make that move.

No way Treloar is a trade option after his past 3 weeks lol (125, 141, 128) - imo that's just trolling
They still play hawthorn, essendon, GC, eagles (H) and north who are all giving away massive midfield points
I get it if he was priced $650k and you were trading to someone under priced ie a JPK to make money to invest elsewhere but no way he's leaving my side

Well TROLLoar is a the biggest troll there is so it kinda makes sense.  ;D

[RaisyDaisy]

Treloar is not a troll. Couldn't be further from it

I get the running gag and people love getting stuck into you about it but Treloar was simply going through a form slump and nothing more. Trading him helped you short term but let's see at the end of the year before making calls

He's a jet either way

[Ringo]

Thinking this atm. Pending Team announcements.

Otten to Docherty
Parsons/Myers to Cousins
D Swallow to Rocky

[Huttabito]

Just the two for me I think, looking at a big fat 0 next week otherwise.
Sandi->Lynch (via Nank)
Myers->Rockliff

Plan to sideways Greenwood to Gawn when he's dropped in price right in time for the finals and will swing Nank back down to float through F6/7 with Lynch/Steele and loopholing with Eddy when I can.

[tor01doc]

Treloar is not a troll. Couldn't be further from it

I get the running gag and people love getting stuck into you about it but Treloar was simply going through a form slump and nothing more. Trading him helped you short term but let's see at the end of the year before making calls

He's a jet either way

RD

What scores has Treloar had since he was traded out when he missed that one game?

[RaisyDaisy]

He's gone alright Doc ;)

What are peoples thoughts on which combo to get?

Rocky + Lynch (GC) or Bont/JPK + Wallis

[batt]

He's gone alright Doc ;)

What are peoples thoughts on which combo to get?

Rocky + Lynch (GC) or Bont/JPK + Wallis

[TomK]

He's gone alright Doc ;)

What are peoples thoughts on which combo to get?

Rocky + Lynch (GC) or Bont/JPK + Wallis