Round 9 Trades

[RaisyDaisy]

Balic to Myers
Touk to Heeney

[plumdog millionaire]

Butler, Otten for Myers, Jelwood

[tor01doc]

Balic to Myers
Touk to Heeney

I have too many missing Heeney's but to do this - Buddy McCrae Dahl

[tor01doc]

Would anyone object to this for donut aversion plan?

SPP -> Myers
Butler -> JJK

Good for my bye balancing too

[The Woodman]

If it works for bye balancing that's fine. Otherwise don't trade SPP!

[js19]

Butler to Myers, Williamson to Adams

[petefisker]

Need help - Which one to trade out of:
Otten, Marchbank or B.Vince

Otten will loose cash, but with jenkins out he could get a nice score.
Marchbank still has cash to make.
Vince is crazy up and down, 100% tag role, 41 on the wknd.. 98 week before. Has lost me $100k, started with him. Do I bite the bullet? He has a great record against north..
Edging toward Vince, but, after I do it I like seeing him on the field rather than otten and marchbank! Haha

Cheers

[monga77]

Was going to go on just the 1 trade of just Balic > Myers

And now to avoid a mid donut GHS > JPK

[Money Shot]

Need help - Which one to trade out of:
Otten, Marchbank or B.Vince

Otten will loose cash, but with jenkins out he could get a nice score.
Marchbank still has cash to make.
Vince is crazy up and down, 100% tag role, 41 on the wknd.. 98 week before. Has lost me $100k, started with him. Do I bite the bullet? He has a great record against north..
Edging toward Vince, but, after I do it I like seeing him on the field rather than otten and marchbank! Haha

Cheers

Gee that's a tough one (I'm in the same boat with Caddy as I prefer seeing his name rather than Hoskin-Elliot even though he is averaging 10 points more)

Personally keep Vince as he could come good and be a keeper from here on out (unlikely but possible) whereas Otten/Marchbank won't be.

If you look at Otten and Marchbanks scoring it has been very similar with both of them having high ceilings but also some very low scores. Personally think keeping Marchbank is the way to go because he will make more cash whereas otten will probably start to loose some even if it isn't much. Jenkins being out is the only thing that makes it a tough decision but he will probably be back next week anyways.

Long story short ... trade out Otten.

[Money Shot]

Who should I trade out of:

Butler/Housten
Barrett/Fisher

[Judd Magic]

Need help - Which one to trade out of:
Otten, Marchbank or B.Vince

Otten will loose cash, but with jenkins out he could get a nice score.
Marchbank still has cash to make.
Vince is crazy up and down, 100% tag role, 41 on the wknd.. 98 week before. Has lost me $100k, started with him. Do I bite the bullet? He has a great record against north..
Edging toward Vince, but, after I do it I like seeing him on the field rather than otten and marchbank! Haha

Cheers

Gee that's a tough one (I'm in the same boat with Caddy as I prefer seeing his name rather than Hoskin-Elliot even though he is averaging 10 points more)

Personally keep Vince as he could come good and be a keeper from here on out (unlikely but possible) whereas Otten/Marchbank won't be.

If you look at Otten and Marchbanks scoring it has been very similar with both of them having high ceilings but also some very low scores. Personally think keeping Marchbank is the way to go because he will make more cash whereas otten will probably start to loose some even if it isn't much. Jenkins being out is the only thing that makes it a tough decision but he will probably be back next week anyways.

Long story short ... trade out Otten.

I reckon Marchbank should be traded out instead of Otten.

Marchbank only has one more game after this one before his bye.

Otten has till round 13 for his bye.

Plus I don't think Jenkins will be back for at least a few weeks as he is horribly out of form atm.

Otten should score well again playing the forward/ruck role which he was playing while Jenkins was out.

I am keeping Otten over Marchbank and trading Marchbank to Selwood. Rocky is going for JPK.  8)

[plumdog millionaire]

Need help - Which one to trade out of:
Otten, Marchbank or B.Vince

Otten will loose cash, but with jenkins out he could get a nice score.
Marchbank still has cash to make.
Vince is crazy up and down, 100% tag role, 41 on the wknd.. 98 week before. Has lost me $100k, started with him. Do I bite the bullet? He has a great record against north..
Edging toward Vince, but, after I do it I like seeing him on the field rather than otten and marchbank! Haha

Cheers

Gee that's a tough one (I'm in the same boat with Caddy as I prefer seeing his name rather than Hoskin-Elliot even though he is averaging 10 points more)

Personally keep Vince as he could come good and be a keeper from here on out (unlikely but possible) whereas Otten/Marchbank won't be.

If you look at Otten and Marchbanks scoring it has been very similar with both of them having high ceilings but also some very low scores. Personally think keeping Marchbank is the way to go because he will make more cash whereas otten will probably start to loose some even if it isn't much. Jenkins being out is the only thing that makes it a tough decision but he will probably be back next week anyways.

Long story short ... trade out Otten.

I reckon Marchbank should be traded out instead of Otten.

Marchbank only has one more game after this one before his bye.

Otten has till round 13 for his bye.

Plus I don't think Jenkins will be back for at least a few weeks as he is horribly out of form atm.

Otten should score well again playing the forward/ruck role which he was playing while Jenkins was out.

I am keeping Otten over Marchbank and trading Marchbank to Selwood. Rocky is going for JPK.  8)

Yeah I've come around to keeping Otten. Jenkins being out has correlated very strongly to Otten scoring well.

[Samsturmfels]

Who is the best player under 440k (excluding rookies and hibberd)  for any position? any ideas welcome

[Gigantor]

Who is the best player under 440k (excluding rookies and hibberd)  for any position? any ideas welcome

Burton, Petracca, Tex, Tommahawk is roughie, only scored shower when Black was playing

[Hippo]

Who is the best player under 440k (excluding rookies and hibberd)  for any position? any ideas welcome

Hard to recommend anyone in that price range for a valuable mid spot, Sidebottom is the one that stands out but isn't in great form so wouldn't use this budget buy in the mids.

Everyone is a risk in this price range but with his shift to the midfield and Dockers playing well, Walters looks like the best budget gamble for mine