Trade out Beams or Treloar? Poll.

[no eye deer]

 Ok, thought this might be worth a poll, instead of leaving it in the vs thread. Might be a few out there with the same choice.

This is what I posted over there.

Trade out Treloar or Beams?
Treloar- $525k
              96 average
              163 BE

Beams- $477k
              96 average.
              113 BE.

Looking at the stats, you would say Treloar has to go.
I suppose it comes down to how long Beams will be out and do we trust Treloar to improve?

[Goosey]

Where's the trade both button?

[no eye deer]

Where's the trade both button?

Fixed that for ya!

[Bully]

Trade Beams, more of an injury risk.

[crowls]

Trade Beams, more of an injury risk.

not if treloar has OP.      traded treloar as i needed the extra cash to get dusty.     fixing my byes at he same time

[Goosey]

Where's the trade both button?

Fixed that for ya!

Traded Beams last week and Treloar this week, but if I had both this week I would probably pull the trigger on both at once!

[tommy10]

Where's the trade both button?

Fixed that for ya!

Cool voted both which is what I'll be doing. In comes Dusty and Yeo!! Both round 12 bye too...win win!!

[no eye deer]

Trade Beams, more of an injury risk.

not if treloar has OP.      traded treloar as i needed the extra cash to get dusty.     fixing my byes at he same time

Just saw the OP issue mentioned. Makes the poll more relevant now. Would like a bit more solid conformation though.

[Bully]

Trade Beams, more of an injury risk.

not if treloar has OP.      traded treloar as i needed the extra cash to get dusty.     fixing my byes at he same time

Haven't heard anything along those lines so it's hearsay at the moment. Treloar obviously hasn't been right the last couple of weeks but did knock up a 140 not too long ago.

[SilverLion]

Hold both. Expect them both to be back next week scoring 100+

[tommy10]

Trade Beams, more of an injury risk.

not if treloar has OP.      traded treloar as i needed the extra cash to get dusty.     fixing my byes at he same time

Haven't heard anything along those lines so it's hearsay at the moment. Treloar obviously hasn't been right the last couple of weeks but did knock up a 140 not too long ago.

Yeah and then got two 70s after that. I can hold him but will need to play Barrett instead. Can get Beams for Yeo, and then see how Barrett goes before doing my 2nd trade.

So for me its:

1. Beams > Yeo, Treloar > Dusty with little $$

2. Beams > Dusty, Hampton > EVW & $160k

3. Beams > Bont, Hampton > EVW & $72k

4. Beams  > Murphy, Treloar > Dusty with little $$

[shaker]

Trade Beams, more of an injury risk.

not if treloar has OP.      traded treloar as i needed the extra cash to get dusty.     fixing my byes at he same time

Haven't heard anything along those lines so it's hearsay at the moment. Treloar obviously hasn't been right the last couple of weeks but did knock up a 140 not too long ago.

Go onto AFL site and sift back through the old stories (not the one Buckley is commenting on ) of the week this is from Treloar's own mouth saying he had groin and hip soreness and had a history of it at GWS then the club comes out and says it's an ankle  ::)
P.S the heading is sore Pie Adam Treloar still expects to face Giants