JPK/TRELOAR

[Judd Magic]

Will give Treloar prob 1-2 weeks or traded when his bye comes.

Same here.

Dusty is a direct swap for us Treloar owners in the next 1-2 weeks should he continue to spud it up!

[quinny88]

Will give Treloar prob 1-2 weeks or traded when his bye comes.

Same here.

Dusty is a direct swap for us Treloar owners in the next 1-2 weeks should he continue to spud it up!

Is that even worth doing? If Dusty continues to spud it up then it will be more of a pattern than it already is. I would only trade to a super Premo if you're trading him

[Judd Magic]

Will give Treloar prob 1-2 weeks or traded when his bye comes.

Same here.

Dusty is a direct swap for us Treloar owners in the next 1-2 weeks should he continue to spud it up!

Is that even worth doing? If Dusty continues to spud it up then it will be more of a pattern than it already is. I would only trade to a super Premo if you're trading him

I'd trust Dusty to turn it around over Treloar atm.

[Hazza09]

I have both and I lost all 4 league games this week.

IMO Treloar has to go!

Am looking at trading him this week but the only decent option is Z Merret and I agree with others that if your going to trade him, he has to go for a Super Premo.

Going to probably wait for his bye or if I can turn him into Pendles.

As for JPK I'm a little more confident he can come good, but today's score was terrible.

Treloars BE is huge so every chance he might be low 500s by next week, he's become a liability!

[Cannon]

Started with them both! Although i'm disappointed with their output i'm more confident JPK can come good. He usually finishes the season pretty strong. Treloar however, i'm very doubtful. Think if i have a couple of luxury trades after completing my team and he still hasn't improved he will be goneski!

[Ringo]

Just remember today Robbo tagged JPK till he went off injured.

Dare I say it are we seeing the return of the tagger.

[Rusty00]

Just remember today Robbo tagged JPK till he went off injured.

Dare I say it are we seeing the return of the tagger.

When did Robbo go off injured? JPK was on 60 early in the 3rd quarter and then only 67 half through the last quarter.

Wondering if the captaincy of a team that is (was) struggling is weighing him down?

[Ringo]

Just remember today Robbo tagged JPK till he went off injured.

Dare I say it are we seeing the return of the tagger.

When did Robbo go off injured? JPK was on 60 early in the 3rd quarter and then only 67 half through the last quarter.

Wondering if the captaincy of a team that is (was) struggling is weighing him down?

Had to go out but before I went in 3rd quarter seen him sitting on bench with ice on. So fair comment then as I did not see scores.

[Grufflez]

Will give Treloar prob 1-2 weeks or traded when his bye comes.

Same here.

Dusty is a direct swap for us Treloar owners in the next 1-2 weeks should he continue to spud it up!

One dud to another.

[tor01doc]

Will give Treloar prob 1-2 weeks or traded when his bye comes.

Same here.

Dusty is a direct swap for us Treloar owners in the next 1-2 weeks should he continue to spud it up!

One dud to another.

:o

[Colliwobblers]

i have treloar from the start, even as a bonafied one eyed pies supporter he has to go in SC

he makes swan look like pendles

[RaisyDaisy]

Strong chance I bring in JPK after his bye - just hope he doesn't go up too much after bottoming out after this round

Is a proven slow starter. Reckon he goes bang as soon as this week

Dusty and Treloar don't interest me - JPK is the pick of the bottomed out bunch

[Judd Magic]

Think I'm going to use this week to flower off Treloar.  ;D

Was going to keep him till the byes but just can't stand the sight of seeing the useless flog in my team so out he goes.  8)

Hampton > Berry
Treloar > Rocky
$100,000 in the bank

Next week -

Newman > Myers via Hibberd DPP
Otten > Selwood via Adams DPP

[Holz]

Still playing on bringing in treloar at some stage,

averaging 112 dream team so the SC will come at some point.

this is his career SC to DT ratio

1.01
0.98
1.03
1.02
1

and now 0.85

I just dont believe someone has 5 years of 0.98 - 1.03 and then drops to 0.85 and stays there.

he hasnt gone under 70 so hasnt had a shocker or sadly he would be cheaper to bring in.

see how he goes against GWS i reckon he might struggle again.

then i like his draw

hawks, lions, freo, dees, port, hawks, essendon, gc

[dmac07]

Have these two killing me, but they arent injured and will stick with them.

Last week I fielded Parsons (19), Hamptom (47), Butler (57), SPP (60). Once they are all off field I can worry about a few mids averaging 90+