Otten Vs Marchbank

[Bully]

Time to resurrect this thread. All week I've been set on trading Otten to Adams. High BE for Otten and scores have been suffering the last few weeks.

Does Jenkins out change things? Otten has averaged 101 with Jenkins out of the team (including the game Jenkins got injured in). Trading Marchbank out instead would be a lot better for my byes.

Is it an obvious decision?

Marchbank goes first for me, next week he's out for one of the rookies. Need to beef up my round 11 squad.

[Judd Magic]

I was gonna trade Otten too but am now thinking Marchbank as he has the round 11 bye coming up and Otten doesn't.

Plus Otten has his forward/ruck role back and I don't think Jenkins will be back for a few weeks as he is horribly out of form atm.

[Ringo]

With Otten moving back forward and Brisbane defence leaking goals Otten may have a field day so I would trade Marchbank of the 2. Otten does not have his bye till Rd 13 also so that is also in his favour.
Marchbank has a bye in 2 weeks as well and is nearing ceiling so makes sense to trade him.

[TurtlesTerriers]

So let's face it there is a direct link of ottens and Jenkins. Rounds 2 to 5 when Jenkins didn't play Andy scored an average of 101. Adelaide played 2 home and 2 away games. Over the next 4 games they have 2 away and 2 home. I'm going to hold off on trading otten and see if history repeats