Are you Double Downgrading, or Going One Up, One Down?

Started by Mongoose528, April 28, 2017, 06:40:17 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

LordSneeze

Gone the DD
Pickett to Hardwick & WHE to Balic.
WHE as happy to take Hardwicks 77 on field.

Didnt rate Fisher and happy with my choice.

RaisyDaisy

Grabbed Balic and passed on Fisher too

Grabbed Zorko which hasn't worked well today but long term I'm happy. Not like JPK or Wines (my other choices) did any better

tommy10

Grabbed Buddy and Balic and passed on Fisher too. Wish I had Yeo instead as they don't play in mcg again, and Sydneybare hopeless.

Who would have thought at the start of the year that Sydney are winless and Hawks are 1-5. Oh and Tiges are 5-0, most likely 5-1  :-\

PowerBug

Quote from: tommy10 on April 30, 2017, 12:04:32 AM
Grabbed Buddy and Balic and passed on Fisher too. Wish I had Yeo instead as they don't play in mcg again, and Sydneybare hopeless.

Who would have thought at the start of the year that Sydney are winless and Hawks are 1-5. Oh and Tiges are 5-0, most likely 5-1  :-\
Here's what I've read this season in this section regarding certain games:

Rd 3: Roughy, JOM will have field days as they thump Gold Coast.
Rd 5: WC players to score well against Hawthorn
Rd 6: Buddy will destroy Carlton in the big win they have

And the amount of comments about benching Butler because they play the Crows and will lose... well I think some people may be jumping the gun a little bit. (fyi I have benched Butler in SC fully expecting a low score :P)
Leader of the King Karl Amon fan club
Coach of WXV side Rio De Janeiro Jaguars
2023 SC: Rank 126

Bully

Personally happy with the decision to bring in one keeper as it's looking like a double downgrade next week with EVW & Black.

LordSneeze

EVW doesnt look like a must to me.
15 poss in game 1 for only 51 points
He had 2 kicks and 12 handballs in game 2 for 58 points.

Might be a 55 average, but i think more likely 50.

Judd Magic

Quote from: LordSneeze on April 30, 2017, 12:37:19 AM
EVW doesnt look like a must to me.
15 poss in game 1 for only 51 points
He had 2 kicks and 12 handballs in game 2 for 58 points.

Might be a 55 average, but i think more likely 50.

Yeah not impressed with EVW either.

Certainly wouldn't play him on the field.  :-X

sammy123

Quote from: LordSneeze on April 30, 2017, 12:37:19 AM
EVW doesnt look like a must to me.
15 poss in game 1 for only 51 points
He had 2 kicks and 12 handballs in game 2 for 58 points.

Might be a 55 average, but i think more likely 50.

im passing. only rookie price player is black atm for me if he backs up his ton

shaker

Don't see the point of double downgrading unless the rookies are worth getting I grabbed Balic this week plus Buddy and not Fisher so far so good it is only round 6 plenty of rookies to come I hope

tor01doc

Yep. The old one up one down worked a treat.

Upgrade target Balic netted me a great 78

Meanwhile, downgrade target Rockliff (VC to boot) scored me 53 massive points.

Could have been worse I guess.

no eye deer

Quote from: tor01doc on April 30, 2017, 11:11:12 AM
Yep. The old one up one down worked a treat.

Upgrade target Balic netted me a great 78

Meanwhile, downgrade target Rockliff (VC to boot) scored me 53 massive points.

Could have been worse I guess.

Ha! Same for me. By far my worst week of the season. The only good point was grabbing Balic instead of Fisher. Pity him and SPP are languishing in my bench.

tommy10

Quote from: no eye deer on April 30, 2017, 11:15:37 AM
Quote from: tor01doc on April 30, 2017, 11:11:12 AM
Yep. The old one up one down worked a treat.

Upgrade target Balic netted me a great 78

Meanwhile, downgrade target Rockliff (VC to boot) scored me 53 massive points.

Could have been worse I guess.

Ha! Same for me. By far my worst week of the season. The only good point was grabbing Balic instead of Fisher. Pity him and SPP are languishing in my bench.
Exactly the same, a shocking week. At least I started SPP so go that right. I'm hoping Butler gets around 70 now.

Gavdroid

Quote from: no eye deer on April 30, 2017, 11:15:37 AM
Quote from: tor01doc on April 30, 2017, 11:11:12 AM
Yep. The old one up one down worked a treat.

Upgrade target Balic netted me a great 78

Meanwhile, downgrade target Rockliff (VC to boot) scored me 53 massive points.

Could have been worse I guess.

Ha! Same for me. By far my worst week of the season. The only good point was grabbing Balic instead of Fisher. Pity him and SPP are languishing in my bench.

My worst week of the year too. Swallow to Balic was ok, WHE to Buddy was not ok, neither was benching Sandi to get Bonts VC score as captain and forgetting to put the emergency on. Cost myself a good 150 points and a fair amount of cash generation this week

Bully

Sold WHE too early, that's a blunder for sure. Picked up Adams who at least filled the points gap. Not the worst scenario.

batt

Now thinking about double downing this week as Hampton has to go next week and there aren't any downgrade options for next week.... yet.