Adams or Treloar

[Goosey]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both

[Rusty00]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both

Note sure this really helps the OP :P

[GoLions]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both

Note sure this really helps the OP :P

FWIW I started with neither

[sammy123]

adams is a must have in defence.

treloar im not backing him to be top 10

[Ringo]

I have neither and probably will not be getting Treloar but will be trying to get Adams.

[enzedder]

I have neither and probably will not be getting Treloar but will be trying to get Adams.

I have Treloar and will get Adams after he has lost 100k and is back in form, playing in the mids as one of my last upgrades. ;)

[Sabretooth Tigers]

adams is a must have in defence.

treloar im not backing him to be top 10

Don't have either.  Treloar's disposal puts me off for a top dollar mid and weary of Adam's longevity. Adams later is my go ATM. 

:)

[tor01doc]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both

Note sure this really helps the OP :P

Quoting the first opinion helps the OP  :P

The comment qualifies the second opinion

Edit:

Defenders Adams 2nd in total points / 3rd in average pig (Hibberd only one game so far though)

Mids Treloar 29th total and 32nd by average

No comparison IMO FWIW

[HoleMeal]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both

Note sure this really helps the OP :P

Quoting the first opinion helps the OP  :P

The comment qualifies the second opinion

Edit:

Defenders Adams 2nd in total points / 3rd in average pig (Hibberd only one game so far though)

Mids Treloar 29th total and 32nd by average

No comparison IMO FWIW

FWIW IMHO Adams is up against a midfield that will have Wells AND De Goey in it.
Anyone who thinks he will score the same or better than what he has scored in the last 5 rounds may be in for a rude shock.
My 2 cents worth but I would be looking at Shaw, Simmo, Hibberd before Adams.
Lets just see where he settles.

[tor01doc]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both

Note sure this really helps the OP :P

Quoting the first opinion helps the OP  :P

The comment qualifies the second opinion

Edit:

Defenders Adams 2nd in total points / 3rd in average pig (Hibberd only one game so far though)

Mids Treloar 29th total and 32nd by average

No comparison IMO FWIW

FWIW IMHO Adams is up against a midfield that will have Wells AND De Goey in it.
Anyone who thinks he will score the same or better than what he has scored in the last 5 rounds may be in for a rude shock.
My 2 cents worth but I would be looking at Shaw, Simmo, Hibberd before Adams.
Lets just see where he settles.

But that doesn't answer the question goddammit

[Rusty00]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both

Note sure this really helps the OP :P

Quoting the first opinion helps the OP  :P

The comment qualifies the second opinion

Edit:

Defenders Adams 2nd in total points / 3rd in average pig (Hibberd only one game so far though)

Mids Treloar 29th total and 32nd by average

No comparison IMO FWIW

I was more talking about the "FWIW I started with both" quoting :P

[tor01doc]

So would anyone still get Treloar over Adams?

Rusty00 - love your picture thingy

[_wato]

Lol Adams up against De Goey and Wells in the midfield. I laughed hard at that.

Adams is undoubtedly our best inside mid. He'd be first picked at the centre bounce before Treloar and Pendles. No doubt he's carrying a niggle and hence why he didn't play as much inside on the weekend.

Wells will line up on a wing, Adams Treloar Pendles on ball, Sidebottom/Crisp on a wing and De Goey off the bench or up forward.

In relation to the op I would go Adams. Top 3 defender v Treloar top 15 mid. What's more valuable to you. Adams also has DPP so another tick for him. Injury is a worry but he looks more settled this year already.