Adams or Treloar

[Mark]

Who is the better pick

[JBs-Hawks]

Well Adams is a defender....

[Mark]

DPP

[enzedder]

Based on consistency games played...Treloar.
Treloar
2012 WS 18
2013 WS 20
2014 WS 20
2015 WS 21 
2016 CO 22
2017 CO 5
Adams
2012 WS 15
2013 WS 16
2014 CO 12
2015 CO 18
2016 CO 14
2017 CO 5
Not that I'm wanting Adams (who I don't have and is averaging 108) to get hurt or injured. May he play all 22 and play permanently in a fwd pocket rotating off the bench. :P

[jfitty]

Adam Treloar

[quinny88]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

[GoLions]

Adams should easily be a top 6 defender (if not the #1 defender) as long as he remains fit.

Treloar is extremely unlikely to be a top 6 mid (probably not top 10 either).

Treloar a good chance of outscoring Adams, but unless you plan on keeping Adams in your mids all season, Adams is the better choice.

[Fid]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

This

Adams and Laird are the two top defenders whilst Treloar is in the M7/8 category

[djbics]

Adams should easily be a top 6 defender (if not the #1 defender) as long as he remains fit.

Treloar is extremely unlikely to be a top 6 mid (probably not top 10 either).

Treloar a good chance of outscoring Adams, but unless you plan on keeping Adams in your mids all season, Adams is the better choice.

Yep, agreed.  If was just a straight head to head for the mid position, I'd be voting Treloar.  But the DPP ability to move Adams into defence means that he is more valuable imo

[dottman]

Adams (injury free) by miles, ur risk to take but he'll be in my side soon.

[tor01doc]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both

[Judd Magic]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both

[HappyDEZ]

Based on consistency games played...Treloar.
Treloar
2012 WS 18
2013 WS 20
2014 WS 20
2015 WS 21 
2016 CO 22
2017 CO 5
Adams
2012 WS 15
2013 WS 16
2014 CO 12
2015 CO 18
2016 CO 14
2017 CO 5
Not that I'm wanting Adams (who I don't have and is averaging 108) to get hurt or injured. May he play all 22 and play permanently in a fwd pocket rotating off the bench. :P

There were some alarm bells for Adams last week. Missed at least one training session & played the bulk of the Anzac game in the F50. Almost certainly had a niggle of some sort.

[crowls]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both

[Fid]

Adams is a must have for defence but Treloar isn't a must have for the mids.

FWIW I started with both