Main Menu

The Cull

Started by bigstrawbs1983, April 25, 2017, 12:11:08 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

bigstrawbs1983

Thoughts on which order the standard rooks/cheapies should be culled ?

I have Marchbank,Otten,Hampton and Stewart down back
SPP, Pickett,Swallow and Barrett mid
Houston, WHE,Butler and Parfitt up front. 

I have JOM as well but he is prob becoming Hanners this week.

Parsons seems a logical in for one of those lads next week assuming he is named.

Does anyone have the BEs for these players ?


shaker

For me SPP this week then Marchbank and Butler will be about cooked the following week to hard to tell anyone else pending on scoring for me

Judd Magic

SPP> Fisher or Balic
WHE > Macrae

That's what I'll be doing this week as I think both those rookies are pretty much cooked.

Unless WHE scores over 100 of course.  ;D

Peter

Checking your plans for R11 bye - that will help determine the order of cull.

sidvicious

#4
Quote from: Peter on April 25, 2017, 02:59:15 PM
Checking your plans for R11 bye - that will help determine the order of cull.
Yes must remember the byes
the byes highlighted on fanplanner are not correct

HappyDEZ

Quote from: bigstrawbs1983 on April 25, 2017, 12:11:08 PM
Thoughts on which order the standard rooks/cheapies should be culled ?

I have Marchbank,Otten,Hampton and Stewart down back
SPP, Pickett,Swallow and Barrett mid
Houston, WHE,Butler and Parfitt up front. 

I have JOM as well but he is prob becoming Hanners this week.

Parsons seems a logical in for one of those lads next week assuming he is named.

Does anyone have the BEs for these players ?
March 34
Ott 3
Hamp 12
Stew -11
SPP 41
Pick 19
D Swall 94
Barr -24
Houst 15
WHE 70
Butl 30
Parf 39
JOM 58
Pars -59

GoLions

SPS will have to go with that 100+ score out of his rolling average. Tbh I wouldn't be surprised if he chucked up another few decent scores though, just keeps making those 2 or so clangers a game that bring his score down.

Turner also looks like he'll have to go for me.

kosduras

my big dilemma is parfitt! he doesnt have the highest BE for a rookie, has shown that he can score well and drop that BE instantly

but right now i have to decide between houstan, butler ,parfitt and WHE to cull to get buddy in this week and he seems to be the

weakest of the bunch,

thoughts?????



bkimm32

Quote from: kosduras on April 27, 2017, 11:20:01 AM
my big dilemma is parfitt! he doesnt have the highest BE for a rookie, has shown that he can score well and drop that BE instantly

but right now i have to decide between houstan, butler ,parfitt and WHE to cull to get buddy in this week and he seems to be the

weakest of the bunch,

thoughts?????
I don't have Butler so can't comment on him, but if I had to choose between Houston, Parf and WHE getting the chop, it would be Parfitt.

In saying that, he's sticking around for me a little longer.