How many Blues are too many?

[Frankfaust]

I've got 5 (including MMurphy). More on the way - as soon as tonight if I get itchy finger.


Too many?

[igotworms]

I have Marchbank, Docherty, Murphy and Pickett. I'll be bringing in Fisher next week if he gets named. The good thing about Carlton from a fantasy perspective is that they have shown that they are willing to play the recruits. Also, some of the GWS recycled players that have suffered from injury in the past are finally finding some form and are injury free. The beauty of a rebuild is that not many people expect them to win, so getting that experience in to the younger players is easier to do than in say a team on the up whos supporters expect them to win.
Williamson, Fisher, and Polson all rookies to watch. (Williamson on the bubble this round)
Mark my words, Fisher will be a jet!!

Oh...... in answer to your question, as long as they are performing or making you money and fit your team structure, who cares how many. Obviously you will need to upgrade the rookies prior and keep your eye on the bye rounds. I have Docherty, so am staying away from Simpson. Likewise with Murphy, plenty of other midfielders on offer that are equal to or better than Gibbs from a scoring point of view. Cripps still looks underdone, but think I will back him in next year to jump up to that elite bracket.

[Mat0369]

8

[sidvicious]

is getting Fisher over Williamson this week wrong ?

[crowls]

ONE

[enzedder]

Whatever the number is you can afford to add 5 more if brown paper bags are involved.

Seriously though it doesn't matter if you have the right ones... Docherty, Simpson, MM as premos... Cripps maybe not this year.
Marchbank, SPS, Fisher, Williamson, Macreadie and Pickett okay as rookies but probably don't want them all.
Think Mat0369 was right 8. 8)

[Colliwobblers]

ONE

hehe this ^

but i have marchbank,murphy,fisher,picket

had kruze

and did take fisher over williamson this week....

[tommy10]

Just the two Marchbank and Pickett. Not going after Murphy so hoping he doesn't kill it  :P

[HappyDEZ]

I think it maybe more about how many keepers can you have from one team & even that may not matter. Keepers Carlton. MM hoping (if you have him) Cripps (ditto) Kade & Doc. Coll & Doggies spring to mind. They both have 4-5 keepers. All up I am not sure it matters. Especially not rookies. I didn't start & didn't get Marchbank...costly.

[LordSneeze]

Rookies vs prems is the difference. Really think about each player seperately.

[Frankfaust]

Thanks for responses. I picked up Fisher, because I wanted to use money out of Roughy sale.


This round is rubbish so far. At least one Blue too many - Picket. He's out of his depth and needs a spell in the Magoos, I think.