Polson or Fisher

[shaker]

Ok you Blues and footy experts which one of these guys are likely to get a good run of games for what I can see Fisher is a skinny little bugger who got 12 possies and a goal with good D/E which gave him an ok score in his first game and Polson was one of the best on ground with 30 possies and a goal in the 2's and has a bigger body
I have to pick one of these guys this week any info would be great ?

[RaisyDaisy]

If you have to pick one, then it has to be Fisher

Suicide picking a guy who hasn't even played yet

[GoLions]

If you have to pick one, then it has to be Fisher

Suicide picking a guy who hasn't even played yet

Yep ^

Also, Polson* :P (he's not as bad as poison surely)

[shaker]

If you have to pick one, then it has to be Fisher

Suicide picking a guy who hasn't even played yet

Yep ^

Also, Polson* :P (he's not as bad as poison surely)

Haha and I have just got new glasses to  ;D

[nas]

If you have to pick one, then it has to be Fisher

Suicide picking a guy who hasn't even played yet

Yep ^

Also, Polson* :P (he's not as bad as poison surely)

Haha and I have just got new glasses to  ;D

Shoulda went to SpecSavers!!

[shaker]

If you have to pick one, then it has to be Fisher

Suicide picking a guy who hasn't even played yet

Yep ^

Also, Polson* :P (he's not as bad as poison surely)

Haha and I have just got new glasses to  ;D

Shoulda went to SpecSavers!!

I did mate maybe should have cleaned them more often  :P

[jvalles69]

What's with ppl jumping on rooks before they're on the bubble?! We've seen how thats gone so far, Newman looked like being safe as houses and now  he's out!  I won't be bringing any rooks in until they are named for they're 3rd game.

[shaker]

What's with ppl jumping on rooks before they're on the bubble?! We've seen how thats gone so far, Newman looked like being safe as houses and now  he's out!  I won't be bringing any rooks in until they are named for they're 3rd game.

The reason is my FWD rookies are not generating cash Eddy not playing Pickett making flower all and Taranto managed unless I get one of these guys in a double trade things will stay the same for another week or 2

[jvalles69]

What's with ppl jumping on rooks before they're on the bubble?! We've seen how thats gone so far, Newman looked like being safe as houses and now  he's out!  I won't be bringing any rooks in until they are named for they're 3rd game.

The reason is my FWD rookies are not generating cash Eddy not playing Pickett making flower all and Taranto managed unless I get one of these guys in a double trade things will stay the same for another week or 2

I've got Picket and Eddy too, problematic yeah, I had Florent but offloaded him early to another rook who was making money.

[batt]

What's with ppl jumping on rooks before they're on the bubble?! We've seen how thats gone so far, Newman looked like being safe as houses and now  he's out!  I won't be bringing any rooks in until they are named for they're 3rd game.

I brought in Newman a week early, got the 100 on field, most people got him a week later and missed out on that score.

I'm going early on Fisher because:
a) Knightmare's draft summary of him is very appetising.
b) He's going to get games
c) He's playing in the line which is less exposed to risk (3 bench spots in the mids, 1 of which is DPP.  Plenty of options if it doesn't work out as planned)

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm going early on Fisher because:
a) Knightmare's draft summary of him is very appetising.
b) He's going to get games
c) He's playing in the line which is less exposed to risk (3 bench spots in the mids, 1 of which is DPP.  Plenty of options if it doesn't work out as planned)

All good reasons to pick him next week, but still no reason to go a week early

[batt]

I'm going early on Fisher because:
a) Knightmare's draft summary of him is very appetising.
b) He's going to get games
c) He's playing in the line which is less exposed to risk (3 bench spots in the mids, 1 of which is DPP.  Plenty of options if it doesn't work out as planned)

All good reasons to pick him next week, but still no reason to go a week early

Lol, yeah I kinda overlooked that.  I need to go early because I want to get Rocky in and would rather have Adams swung back into defense than bring in Williamson.  I've only spent 1 trade so I feel like I can push the accelerator a little.

[jvalles69]

I get it, just that there's no coming back if these guys you bring in early get dumped after 2-3 games!

[igotworms]

Have watched a bit of both of these guys. Fisher in my opinion, but I would hold until next week. No greater test for the young blokes than playing Port at home on a friday night. Will sort the men from the boys...... wait..... half of Carlton are only kids!!
Fisher played senior footy at 15 and in the WAFL seniors last year where he averaged 20 disposals.
Polson was looking set for big things, but a shoulder injury ruined his final TAC cup year. SOS watched him tear Jack Silvagni' side apart the year prior, kicking 4 in a quarter and has had his eye on him for some time apparently.
Both are quick and have great skills, but Fisher having played senior footy (albeit WAFL) puts him ahead for mine.

[TurtlesTerriers]

I could be way wrong. Am thinking of 1 trade this week going taranto to fisher.. Risky but that gives be 2 trades next week if Roughead, shaw or swallow go terrible (again). I have pocketed the cash and it's ready for an upgrade in the next 2 weeks. SPP is the next to go but a little more to squeeze from him