Quick Poll - Tom Williamson

[Mongoose528]

Is Hibberd -> Williamson a waste of a trade? 

:)

[GoLions]

Nah, pull the trigger. Most people traded Hibberd to Newman, no point having him on the bench making zero cash. Williamson looks good so far :)

[Torpedo10]

Give me back my vent thread.  :P

But seriously, I'm considering this trade.

[Ringo]

I have done it - Needed the emergency coverage as holding Newmann

[LordSneeze]

I was going to go Taranto to Balic, But instead I will go Taranto to Williamson
Leave Balic for next week if he comes back in.

[Mongoose528]

Give me back my vent thread.  :P

But seriously, I'm considering this trade.

I think I need one for myself because I rant way too much :P

[Holz]

Is Hibberd -> Williamson a waste of a trade? 

:)

Dont love it.

Would rather wait for EVW.

Big wraps on him.

[TomK]

Is Hibberd -> Williamson a waste of a trade? 

:)

Dont love it.

Would rather wait for EVW.

Big wraps on him.

By the time EVW is on the bubble, Hampton/Marchbank/Otten could all be ready to cull so no point keeping Hibberd for that trade, may as well pick up Williamson for him now while the others are still making money.

[Holz]

Is Hibberd -> Williamson a waste of a trade? 

:)

Dont love it.

Would rather wait for EVW.

Big wraps on him.

By the time EVW is on the bubble, Hampton/Marchbank/Otten could all be ready to cull so no point keeping Hibberd for that trade, may as well pick up Williamson for him now while the others are still making money.

not if williamson turns out to be not a good pick.

havent been super impressed, could easily play score 40 then get dropped.

he has the good score in his first game so that will drop of his price change forumula after this price rise. only a -52 so if he goes 45 then he makes around 30-35k. Then if poor again another 20-25k then his price stops moving.

Fisher Parson Balic EVW Black im liking the look of more over the next two weeks.

We dont need another Pickett or even worse Eddy.

[GoLions]

Is Hibberd -> Williamson a waste of a trade? 

:)

Dont love it.

Would rather wait for EVW.

Big wraps on him.

By the time EVW is on the bubble, Hampton/Marchbank/Otten could all be ready to cull so no point keeping Hibberd for that trade, may as well pick up Williamson for him now while the others are still making money.

not if williamson turns out to be not a good pick.

havent been super impressed, could easily play score 40 then get dropped.

he has the good score in his first game so that will drop of his price change forumula after this price rise. only a -52 so if he goes 45 then he makes around 30-35k. Then if poor again another 20-25k then his price stops moving.

Fisher Parson Balic EVW Black im liking the look of more over the next two weeks.

We dont need another Pickett or even worse Eddy.

You can say that about literally any rookie though. What if he scores 70 and ends up going up in price by 150k over the next 4 weeks?

Fisher has only played 1 game, but odds are everyone will be on him next week.

Parsons just got suspended for 2 weeks.

Balic was horrible in his first game and could be horrible when he eventually comes back.

EVW hasn't even played a game yet.

Black hasn't played a game yet either, and is no certainty to play this weekend (unless I've missed something).

If Balic comes back in 2 weeks, then you'll have Balic, Parsons, EVW, and possibly Black all on the bubble in the 1 week. IMO if you're carrying Hibberd, then getting Williamson this week is a good decision.

[Holz]

Is Hibberd -> Williamson a waste of a trade? 

:)

Dont love it.

Would rather wait for EVW.

Big wraps on him.

By the time EVW is on the bubble, Hampton/Marchbank/Otten could all be ready to cull so no point keeping Hibberd for that trade, may as well pick up Williamson for him now while the others are still making money.

not if williamson turns out to be not a good pick.

havent been super impressed, could easily play score 40 then get dropped.

he has the good score in his first game so that will drop of his price change forumula after this price rise. only a -52 so if he goes 45 then he makes around 30-35k. Then if poor again another 20-25k then his price stops moving.

Fisher Parson Balic EVW Black im liking the look of more over the next two weeks.

We dont need another Pickett or even worse Eddy.

You can say that about literally any rookie though. What if he scores 70 and ends up going up in price by 150k over the next 4 weeks?

Fisher has only played 1 game, but odds are everyone will be on him next week.

Parsons just got suspended for 2 weeks.

Balic was horrible in his first game and could be horrible when he eventually comes back.

EVW hasn't even played a game yet.

Black hasn't played a game yet either, and is no certainty to play this weekend (unless I've missed something).

If Balic comes back in 2 weeks, then you'll have Balic, Parsons, EVW, and possibly Black all on the bubble in the 1 week. IMO if you're carrying Hibberd, then getting Williamson this week is a good decision.

you can im just personally not a fan of Williamson thats why im not getting him.

Parsons i rate and i know geelong do as he would have play round 1 if not injured. 1 year in the system.

Balic - 1 year in the system big ball winner in the WAFL.

EVW - 2 years in the system, been very good in the VFL

Black - 4-5 years in the system?

Fisher - i like but will cool if he goes poor in game 2.

im actually liking Hibberd for the loophole.

[GoLions]

Is Hibberd -> Williamson a waste of a trade? 

:)

Dont love it.

Would rather wait for EVW.

Big wraps on him.

By the time EVW is on the bubble, Hampton/Marchbank/Otten could all be ready to cull so no point keeping Hibberd for that trade, may as well pick up Williamson for him now while the others are still making money.

not if williamson turns out to be not a good pick.

havent been super impressed, could easily play score 40 then get dropped.

he has the good score in his first game so that will drop of his price change forumula after this price rise. only a -52 so if he goes 45 then he makes around 30-35k. Then if poor again another 20-25k then his price stops moving.

Fisher Parson Balic EVW Black im liking the look of more over the next two weeks.

We dont need another Pickett or even worse Eddy.

You can say that about literally any rookie though. What if he scores 70 and ends up going up in price by 150k over the next 4 weeks?

Fisher has only played 1 game, but odds are everyone will be on him next week.

Parsons just got suspended for 2 weeks.

Balic was horrible in his first game and could be horrible when he eventually comes back.

EVW hasn't even played a game yet.

Black hasn't played a game yet either, and is no certainty to play this weekend (unless I've missed something).

If Balic comes back in 2 weeks, then you'll have Balic, Parsons, EVW, and possibly Black all on the bubble in the 1 week. IMO if you're carrying Hibberd, then getting Williamson this week is a good decision.

you can im just personally not a fan of Williamson thats why im not getting him.

Parsons i rate and i know geelong do as he would have play round 1 if not injured. 1 year in the system.

Balic - 1 year in the system big ball winner in the WAFL.

EVW - 2 years in the system, been very good in the VFL

Black - 4-5 years in the system?

Fisher - i like but will cool if he goes poor in game 2.

im actually liking Hibberd for the loophole.

FWIW I won't be getting Williamson, as I'm not keen on trading Marchbank, Hampton, Stewart, or Newman for him. But he looks like making a bit of cash, and I wouldn't be too fussed on having Hibberd for the loophole when rookies are getting injured/suspended/dropped left, right, and centre :P

[RaisyDaisy]

Yeah I don't think Williamson is a bad pick, but he is just someone I am personally passing on

As for Hibberd, I reckon I will end up keeping him for a long time. Really handy to for loopholing and being able to switch trade players between def and mid

Should eventually get a game too, but that's just a bonus. Can sit at M11 all year for all I care

[frenzy]

Yeah I don't think Williamson is a bad pick, but he is just someone I am personally passing on

As for Hibberd, I reckon I will end up keeping him for a long time. Really handy to for loopholing and being able to switch trade players between def and mid

Should eventually get a game too, but that's just a bonus. Can sit at M11 all year for all I care

+1       now my floating donut at M11

[tor01doc]

9x9  8)