Round 5 Trades

Thunderbolts · April 18, 2017, 07:58:51 AM

Who's on the chopping block this week?

for those who kept Barrett - will he be back this week or a goner from your side?

Dave085 · April 18, 2017, 01:10:31 PM

Matera in and a rookie worth max 170 for Powell-Pepper and one of Hampton/Houston/Marchbank.

The_Captain · April 18, 2017, 07:54:57 PM

Not sure about these week.

Roughead looking to be gone. Just a matter if i go him to ANB, or Fisher from Carlton.

If ANB, then Nankervis will become Spencer to generate some cash. If fisher comes in then Nank can become Stefan Martin.

Not sure what ANB is going to do over next few weeks..

WhatMate · April 18, 2017, 08:43:19 PM

Quote from: The_Captain on April 18, 2017, 07:54:57 PM
Not sure about these week.

Roughead looking to be gone. Just a matter if i go him to ANB, or Fisher from Carlton.

If ANB, then Nankervis will become Spencer to generate some cash. If fisher comes in then Nank can become Stefan Martin.

Not sure what ANB is going to do over next few weeks..

Glad, i got Neal-Bullin in week two now :)

How sold are you on Spencer's scoring potential? first game back and got 77 which included to goals to boost his score, although he did have 3FA so that couldve been 86.

Im in a similar position, ive got Nank in the rucks, but not sure what guys to go for this week. I think I need to chase Balic this week, so that's trade 1 through Roughead or Pickett. Second trade is between Nank -> Spencer or Stewart -> Williamson.

Now that I've wrote it out I think ive worked it out myself ;D iit is probably worth more money waiting another week on Spencer as Nank should still make me some money where as Stewart might even lose money this week whilst Williamson is guranteed cash

Mat0369 · April 18, 2017, 08:46:49 PM

Powell-Pepper>Fisher
Pickett>Balic

DBRiMatt · April 18, 2017, 09:54:41 PM

Quote

How sold are you on Spencer's scoring potential? first game back and got 77 which included to goals to boost his score, although he did have 3FA so that couldve been 86.

Spencer was against Sandilands though... he only got 15 HO to Sandis 53. Sandi would be one of the hardest ruckmen to go agianst as an inexperienced rucker, so he should get more than 15HO in future games. You would want more than 11 disposals though. I feel like 75-80 will be his weekly score.

Rusty00 · April 18, 2017, 10:00:46 PM

Want to trade Rough up to a mid premium. Hampton would be the best one to trade to achieve that but not a fan of the def rookies on offer (already have Williamson). In 2 weeks time I could probably do it because Hampton should gain mid status. Might have to cool my jets a bit and make some small ball trades.

The_Captain · April 18, 2017, 11:14:17 PM

Quote from: DBRiMatt on April 18, 2017, 09:54:41 PM
Quote

How sold are you on Spencer's scoring potential? first game back and got 77 which included to goals to boost his score, although he did have 3FA so that couldve been 86.

Spencer was against Sandilands though... he only got 15 HO to Sandis 53. Sandi would be one of the hardest ruckmen to go agianst as an inexperienced rucker, so he should get more than 15HO in future games. You would want more than 11 disposals though. I feel like 75-80 will be his weekly score.

Yeah i think 77 is a great score against Sandi.. Even if he can get 70 a week id take that... it nets me 130k and hes gonna score the same as Nank anyway... Both shower, but rucking solo theyll get 70 odd each week.

Dave085 · April 18, 2017, 11:18:11 PM

Nankervis hasn't set the world on fire with hit outs either. Will be interesting to see how they go head to head... Im holding on to Nankervis this week and will re-assess after this round...

The_Captain · April 18, 2017, 11:23:02 PM

Quote from: Dave085 on April 18, 2017, 11:18:11 PM
Nankervis hasn't set the world on fire with hit outs either. Will be interesting to see how they go head to head... Im holding on to Nankervis this week and will re-assess after this round...

Nanks break even is about 35 extra than Spencers, so if they score the same Spencer will be making more cash. Nank was on 40 5 minutes into 2nd quarter on weekend... Finished half time on 38... How the flower does that happen. I reckon Spencer will win way more hit outs this week. 35-40... Expecting a total of 75 but will be happy.

Colliwobblers · April 18, 2017, 11:42:15 PM

tentatively traded

c mills to williamson and b eddy to balic

teams a mess at present as far as rooks go, and mills had to go, he'll average a hundred for the rest of the season but a month of him is enough for me.

leaves me 250k in the bank and badly need a mid upgrade next week.

WhatMate · April 18, 2017, 11:54:30 PM

Quote from: The_Captain on April 18, 2017, 11:23:02 PM
Quote from: Dave085 on April 18, 2017, 11:18:11 PM
Nankervis hasn't set the world on fire with hit outs either. Will be interesting to see how they go head to head... Im holding on to Nankervis this week and will re-assess after this round...

Nanks break even is about 35 extra than Spencers, so if they score the same Spencer will be making more cash. Nank was on 40 5 minutes into 2nd quarter on weekend... Finished half time on 38... How the flower does that happen. I reckon Spencer will win way more hit outs this week. 35-40... Expecting a total of 75 but will be happy.

Yeh if i had the luxury id probably drop nank this week for spencer, but ive gotta bring in williamson and balic (for stewart and roughy/pickett). I think those two will make more this week that Spencer and either/or

Rusty00 · April 19, 2017, 02:41:24 PM

Already have Balic, so Fisher is the only "rookie" that interests me. Fisher looks like he's a good prospect, but it pains me to have to pay over $200k for him :-\

You guys have got me thinking about Nank to Spencer though. Would seem likely to average similar and can pocket some money from the trade. Could then trade Rough to Lloyd who looks likely to be a Top 6-8 defender this year. Would mean I'd probably have to miss Fisher given he'd have another price rise.

Huttabito · April 19, 2017, 02:54:56 PM

Hope EVW gets the call up.

Hampton -> EVW
Berry -> Balic
Bank $214k

Hopefully next week I can turn SPP into Z.Merrett with one other cash grab.

The_Captain · April 19, 2017, 03:10:15 PM

Yeah i dont have Williamson in defence and still have that spud Stewart sitting there. However i have Hampton on pine making good $$ still. Willamsons 47 on the weekend worried me, he could be very similar to Stewarts scoring. The positive about Nank to Spencer is it nets 130k and the same scoring output. Whereas Stewart to williamson nets you 6k, and Williamson may make another 70 or 80k and wont do it quick scoring 40s.

Also have picket i could trade. But Picket JS is decent and a low break even this week. Still 100% unsure what to do. If fisher was 60k cheaper it be an easy option.