Is Taranto -> WHE a waste of a trade?

[Mongoose528]

Seems like a few people are contemplating this trade. Wanted to hear your thoughts.

[Torpedo10]

Yes  if you're going for leagues, no if you're going for overall. They will make the same money I think, Taranto will just take 3-4 weeks longer.

[Holz]

Yes  if you're going for leagues, no if you're going for overall. They will make the same money I think, Taranto will just take 3-4 weeks longer.

umm why yes for league but no for overall?

would have thought its the other way around. You go hard for overall

[sammy123]

i've done it. was only way i could get WHE

[Money Shot]

I already have WHE but am considering trading Taranto to one of Knight/Ainsworth/Turner/Hannan would that be a waste of a trade?

[tor01doc]

Yes  if you're going for leagues, no if you're going for overall. They will make the same money I think, Taranto will just take 3-4 weeks longer.

umm why yes for league but no for overall?

would have thought its the other way around. You go hard for overall

Agree with Lord Holz

[Shardheads]

I already have WHE but am considering trading Taranto to one of Knight/Ainsworth/Turner/Hannan would that be a waste of a trade?

YESSS

[GoLions]

Yes  if you're going for leagues, no if you're going for overall. They will make the same money I think, Taranto will just take 3-4 weeks longer.

umm why yes for league but no for overall?

would have thought its the other way around. You go hard for overall

Agree with Lord Holz

I think you fellas misinterpreted. Torp is saying yes it is a waste if going for league, no it is not a waste if going for overall ;)

[Holz]

Yes  if you're going for leagues, no if you're going for overall. They will make the same money I think, Taranto will just take 3-4 weeks longer.

umm why yes for league but no for overall?

would have thought its the other way around. You go hard for overall

probably the case,

the topic title does totally conflict with the question in the OP though,

the answer is Waste of trade regardless anyway.

Agree with Lord Holz

I think you fellas misinterpreted. Torp is saying yes it is a waste if going for league, no it is not a waste if going for overall ;)

[GoLions]

FWIW I'm not trading Taranto to WHE, would rather just pass on him

[Torpedo10]

Yes  if you're going for leagues, no if you're going for overall. They will make the same money I think, Taranto will just take 3-4 weeks longer.

umm why yes for league but no for overall?

would have thought its the other way around. You go hard for overall

Agree with Lord Holz

I think you fellas misinterpreted. Torp is saying yes it is a waste if going for league, no it is not a waste if going for overall ;)

Dave understands, I was answering the question.  :P

FTR I'm probably making this trade this week.

[fasttrack13]

I'm not sure why you'd trade taranto... He scored 75 on the weekend, albeit in a massive win, but it's still a 75... He seems to score well in wins, and with NTH-Port-Syd coming up they're all winnable games before Coniglio is available. I'd be trading Roughy/JOM etc.. before i'd be trading Taranto, i feel he an got 70's from here. Plus with McLuggage, Berry and Balic all on the bubble for round 5, if taranto doesn't perform you've got 60-160k downgrade.

[ronl]

What's not to like about Taranto?  He nearly doubled his round 1 score last week and could easily push into the 80's or higher this week.  So, yes, it could be a waste of a trade.

[WizzFizz]

taranto has proven himself to be a shower hack, low efficiency and an eh score in a 100point win,

WHE on the other hand has avged 105 in two losses.

no brainer