Poll: Marchbank v McGrath

[Samsturmfels]

^

[RaisyDaisy]

Marchbank

McGrath will get rested eventually

[crowls]

Marchbank

McGrath will get rested eventually

Yes he will, question is will he make his money before getting rested?

[GoLions]

Marchbank

McGrath will get rested eventually

Yes he will, question is will he make his money before getting rested?

If McGrath gets rested for a single game like every 6-7 weeks, then doesn't really make a difference tbh. You play someone like Stewart that week and McGrath takes a week longer than other rookies to max out, so you don't have to trade everyone out in the same week :p

[JBs-Hawks]

Both!

But if you didn't start either you give yourself another week to have a look at both.

[Samsturmfels]

Both!

But if you didn't start either you give yourself another week to have a look at both.

Even if your faced with fielding hampton, hibberd and srewart?

[JBs-Hawks]

Both!

But if you didn't start either you give yourself another week to have a look at both.

Even if your faced with fielding hampton, hibberd and srewart?

Yes!

[King_Robbo]

Yeah - no point trading this week...
McGrath is an interesting one, gun young player and had a night out Vs the hawks although the bombers had A LOT of ball in that game so I think that is about his ceiling..
Marchbank is an intercept marking beast but his disposal efficiency is pretty average - I was surprised he scored 97 last week...
Either way - hold this week and evaluate

[enzedder]

Would wait a week but if you need to get one I'd get Marchbank