NEED A FINAL RATING

Started by milnesmarvels, March 24, 2010, 12:12:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

milnesmarvels

BACKS
Bock  Hargrave  Enright  Hodge         Sheppard
    Kennely     Ladson   Water             Maguire

MIDFEILD
Dal Santo (c)  Watson  Selwood              Moles
Barlow            Martin   Shuey                  BAnner

RUCKS
Sandilands                  Warnock
Hille                             Trengrove

FORWARDS
Chapman (vc)  Reiwoldt  Okeefe  Higgins                    Rockliff
         Tippet               Waite      Hall                             Hitchcock


Reasoning for midfeilds is there is no other cash cows anywhere else and i would usually start 1 cash cow in def mid and forward istead if decided to move the def and forward ones to the mids cause thats were the talent lies and pgrade them thoughou the year to end up with a preium midfeild with a fairly good ruck hoping hille fires and a solid forward line with backs that may require a trade or two,

all thought needed, allmost there

salce

thanks for commenting on mine mate.
interesting backline you've got...bock is a good choice, not many people have opted for him but is a safe bet
sheppard i havent heard much about, maybe a macdonald, gram or obrien

waite is a risk, with the injuries and all but may pay off as carlton need him atm. love the rucks mate.

overall 8/10

marjay

looks good... no Ablett though. Yes, he will drop in price but will also pull the 100 to 120 with the occational 140+ x 2 if you have him as captin.

tomsully

backline weak. wornock cant start. mid ok? forward same as every1s. so 5/10

tnator

Love the Bockinator in the backline.  Will average 100 and hopefully play 19 games plus.  I think Gablett is a must.  (unless he goes to the goldcoast)