Outta Trades 2017

Started by sammyo7, March 22, 2017, 08:15:17 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

sammyo7

Def: Shaw, Adams, Lloyd, Touhy, Hampton, McGrath, (Otten, Vickers-ellis)

Mid: Danger, kennedy, Hanners, Fyfe, beams, D.Swallow, Powell-pepper, Barrett (Miles, hibberd, parfitt)

Ruck: Gawn, Witts, (Strnadica)

Foward: Dalhaus, Buddy, Greene, Nankervis, Mccarthy, Florent (Butler, Eddy)

$52,000 left

Any last advice, or anything i've missed

TIA

sammyo7


SilverLion

Interesting having no Sandi, given pretty much everyone has him.
Backs are solid, though I'm not sold on McGrath myself, would upgrade to Marchbank/Thurlow.
Mids are good, though risky if not all the rookies play. Would try and squeeze another prem/mid-pricer on the field somehow.
Forwards also good, though I would take a good look at any of Taranto, WHE or Turner for McCarthy, but that'd just be personal preference :)

Mongoose528

Quote from: SilverLion on March 23, 2017, 10:20:29 AM
Interesting having no Sandi, given pretty much everyone has him.
Backs are solid, though I'm not sold on McGrath myself, would upgrade to Marchbank/Thurlow.
Mids are good, though risky if not all the rookies play. Would try and squeeze another prem/mid-pricer on the field somehow.
Forwards also good, though I would take a good look at any of Taranto, WHE or Turner for McCarthy, but that'd just be personal preference :)

Agree with this. Team looks good, but I would do

McGrath -> Marchbank

McCarthy -> Taranto/SPS

As McGrath and McCarthy won't score well.

sammyo7

#4
Quote from: EazyMoney on March 23, 2017, 10:31:18 AM
Quote from: SilverLion on March 23, 2017, 10:20:29 AM
Interesting having no Sandi, given pretty much everyone has him.
Backs are solid, though I'm not sold on McGrath myself, would upgrade to Marchbank/Thurlow.
Mids are good, though risky if not all the rookies play. Would try and squeeze another prem/mid-pricer on the field somehow.
Forwards also good, though I would take a good look at any of Taranto, WHE or Turner for McCarthy, but that'd just be personal preference :)

Agree with this. Team looks good, but I would do

McGrath -> Marchbank

McCarthy -> Taranto/SPS

As McGrath and McCarthy won't score well.


Def: Shaw, Adams, Lloyd, Touhy, Hampton, Marchbank, (Otten, Vickers-ellis)

Mid: Danger, kennedy, Hanners, Fyfe, beams, D.Swallow, Powell-pepper, Barrett (Miles, hibberd, parfitt)

Ruck: Gawn, Witts, (Strnadica)

Foward: Dalhaus, Buddy, Greene, Nankervis, WHE, Florent (Butler, Eddy)

$18,000

Wouldn't mind sandi but at this stage i can't fit him in so i'm taking a punt on witts.
Taranto is good but because he is at GWS i'm not to sure on him getting a game every week
rookies might change depending on who is named
:)