Brownlow 2017

[GoLions]

Kreuz was BOG by a country mile against GWS.

Ruckmen never poll as well as we expect, which is why I'm not too keen on giving them the 3 votes (or even 2 for that matter)

[Mat0369]

Watching the game at the ground though it would be hard to not give him the 3. He dominated Mummy around the ground and came up clutch countless times.

[GoLions]

Watching the game at the ground though it would be hard to not give him the 3. He dominated Mummy around the ground and came up clutch countless times.

Tbh i thought he was best on as well, i just don't think the umps will give him the 3 :p

[dmac07]

Watching the game at the ground though it would be hard to not give him the 3. He dominated Mummy around the ground and came up clutch countless times.

Tbh i thought he was best on as well, i just don't think the umps will give him the 3 :p

Ive been burnt by Ruckman before. Going back to Cox and some of his all australian years averaging 120 sc and dominating.. only to get 4 or 5 votes in the brownlow when i had him on 15+

[AaronKirk]

I need to catch up on the last 3 weeks. I will hope to do so by the end of the week.

[jvalles69]

Round 12                  
Swans vs Dogs   Kennedy   3   Heeney   2   Franklin   1
Crows vs Saints   Laird   3   Lynch   2   Ross   1
Hawks vs Suns   Ablett   3   Gunston   2   Mitchell   1
Lions vs Dockers   Beams   3   Zorko   2   Martin   1
Bombers vs Power   Merrett   3   Hooker   2   Heppell   1
Blues vs Giants   Docherty   3   Kreuzer   2   Shiel   1
Dees vs Pies   Grundy   3   Sidebottom   2   Jones   1
                  
Round 13                  
Eagles vs Cats   Mitchell   3   Dangerfield   2   Shuey   1
Roos vs Saints   Billings   3   Ross   2   Gibson   1
Tigers vs Swans   Kennedy   3   Cotchin   2   Martin   1
Power vs Lions   R. Gray   3   Zorko   2   Wines   1
Suns vs Blues   Gibbs   3   Docherty   2   Simpson   1
Dogs vs Dees   Watts   3   McDonald   2   Salem   


21 - Dusty
19 - Danger, Sloane
17 - Jelwood
15 - Titchell
14 - Merrett, Ablett

[meow meow]

Personally I thought Sinclair deserved the 3 for the Saints this week (R13) and neither of you gave him a vote so it'll be interesting to see what happens there.

[Nige]

Round 12                  
Swans vs Dogs   Kennedy   3   Heeney   2   Franklin   1
Crows vs Saints   Laird   3   Lynch   2   Ross   1
Hawks vs Suns   Ablett   3   Gunston   2   Mitchell   1
Lions vs Dockers   Beams   3   Zorko   2   Martin   1
Bombers vs Power   Merrett   3   Hooker   2   Heppell   1
Blues vs Giants   Docherty   3   Kreuzer   2   Shiel   1
Dees vs Pies   Grundy   3   Sidebottom   2   Jones   1
                  
Round 13                  
Eagles vs Cats   Mitchell   3   Dangerfield   2   Shuey   1
Roos vs Saints   Billings   3   Ross   2   Gibson   1
Tigers vs Swans   Kennedy   3   Cotchin   2   Martin   1
Power vs Lions   R. Gray   3   Zorko   2   Wines   1
Suns vs Blues   Gibbs   3   Docherty   2   Simpson   1
Dogs vs Dees   Watts   3   McDonald   2   Salem   


21 - Dusty
19 - Danger, Sloane
17 - Jelwood
15 - Titchell
14 - Merrett, Ablett

Need to know more about how Dusty gets a vote in Round 13.

[jvalles69]

Round 12                  
Swans vs Dogs   Kennedy   3   Heeney   2   Franklin   1
Crows vs Saints   Laird   3   Lynch   2   Ross   1
Hawks vs Suns   Ablett   3   Gunston   2   Mitchell   1
Lions vs Dockers   Beams   3   Zorko   2   Martin   1
Bombers vs Power   Merrett   3   Hooker   2   Heppell   1
Blues vs Giants   Docherty   3   Kreuzer   2   Shiel   1
Dees vs Pies   Grundy   3   Sidebottom   2   Jones   1
                  
Round 13                  
Eagles vs Cats   Mitchell   3   Dangerfield   2   Shuey   1
Roos vs Saints   Billings   3   Ross   2   Gibson   1
Tigers vs Swans   Kennedy   3   Cotchin   2   Martin   1
Power vs Lions   R. Gray   3   Zorko   2   Wines   1
Suns vs Blues   Gibbs   3   Docherty   2   Simpson   1
Dogs vs Dees   Watts   3   McDonald   2   Salem   


21 - Dusty
19 - Danger, Sloane
17 - Jelwood
15 - Titchell
14 - Merrett, Ablett

Need to know more about how Dusty gets a vote in Round 13.

That was the toughest game for me and I went with Dusty because Tigers were in front for the majority of the game, other Tiger who was good was Houli, but Dusty name alone will get him votes.  Could be completely wrong, but I've been doing this long enough to know if there's any doubt go with the name.

[The_Captain]

Interesting to see the wide deviations of votes. The one thing all have in common is danger close to the top with selwood, sloane and dusty all doing well. This is the first year I haven't done my own votes for a while due to the app i used to use carked it... But i think Sloane/ Danger would be front runners with Dusty/ Selwood/ Ablett trailing them. Interesting top see how many awards YEo is going high in, him and shuey probably pinching votes off each other and are probbaly on about 10-11 each i reckon.

[Big Mac]

Hibberd was probably best on for the dees dogs game, could see him getting votes too

[jvalles69]

Hibberd was probably best on for the dees dogs game, could see him getting votes too

Yeah I've seen a few other voting sites that have Hibberd on 3, thought he started off fairly slow, but started racking it up later.

One site I've see has Mitchell currently #1 for West Coast, Yeo 2nd and Shuey in 3rd.

[RaisyDaisy]

Rance or Houli for mine, not Dusty

Oddly enough, afl.com went 3 Lloyd, 2 Rance, 1 Hanners  :o

[Mat0369]

Ive been burnt by Ruckman before. Going back to Cox and some of his all australian years averaging 120 sc and dominating.. only to get 4 or 5 votes in the brownlow when i had him on 15+

Not looking at SC scores and just watching the game at the ground Kreuz was dominant. Like head and shoulders above everyone else dominant. It reminded me of that game we played Melbourne and he demolished Gawn. He had 17 touches, 3 goals and 3 votes in that game. Doc had a lot of the ball at HB and it looks good on the stat sheet, but Kreuz had the biggest influence on the game.

[dmac07]

Hibberd was probably best on for the dees dogs game, could see him getting votes too

Yeah I've seen a few other voting sites that have Hibberd on 3, thought he started off fairly slow, but started racking it up later.

One site I've see has Mitchell currently #1 for West Coast, Yeo 2nd and Shuey in 3rd.

Dees v dogs was hardest game for votes for me.

West Coast I think Yeo won't get anywhere near as many votes as other awards like the coaches where he is winning. Also think Shuey is regularly over rated for his games (blowing my own horn picked Gaff to beat him last year when a lot had Shuey top 3).

I do have Shuey in the lead after saying that though! But very even and open race. Id be tempted to get on Gaff or even Kennedy if the price is right.
9 - Shuey. 7 - Gaff, Mitchell, Yeo. 6 - Kennedy.