Brownlow 2017

[dmac07]

I'd say there's only five players that can win (his time last year Rd 6,  said the top 8 will not change and it didn't)

in order with no one else challenging

Rory Laird
Dustin Martin
Paddy Dangerflog
Nat Fyfe
Robbie Gray

Nobody else can win Charlie!

Guys that can challenge those for top 3.
Bont
Murphy
Wines
Tom Mitchell
Treloar
Selwood
Dayne Beams
Luke SHuey

You must mean Rory Sloane not Rory Laird..? Id say Bont and Selwood can win it also.

[GoLions]

Haha yeah surely teabs meant Sloaney! :P

[jvalles69]

I'd say there's only five players that can win (his time last year Rd 6,  said the top 8 will not change and it didn't)

in order with no one else challenging

Rory Laird
Dustin Martin
Paddy Dangerflog
Nat Fyfe
Robbie Gray

Nobody else can win Charlie!

Guys that can challenge those for top 3.
Bont
Murphy
Wines
Tom Mitchell
Treloar
Selwood
Dayne Beams
Luke SHuey

You must mean Rory Sloane not Rory Laird..? Id say Bont and Selwood can win it also.

Disagree with your list, don't think Gray or Fyfe will be up there once their teams come back to earth.   Gray has to kick a bag for him to get votes cos he's not getting much mid time.

If we're calling a top 5 at this stage to be there at the end then: Danger, Sloane, Jelwood, Bontempelli and Dusty.

[jvalles69]

Giants vs Dogs was tough...Bont, Greene, Dahl, Williams, Shaw, Mumford, Smith, Haynes, Daniel, Macrae, Cameron all possibilities of polling to be honest!  Does Greene get votes if he's reported?  Macrae got loads of free kicks and sometimes that helps me determine whether they get votes...

3 - Bont
2 - Greene
1 - ?

???

[Torpedo10]

Giants vs Dogs was tough...Bont, Greene, Dahl, Williams, Shaw, Mumford, Smith, Haynes, Daniel, Macrae, Cameron all possibilities of polling to be honest!  Does Greene get votes if he's reported?  Macrae got loads of free kicks and sometimes that helps me determine whether they get votes...

3 - Bont
2 - Greene
1 - ?

???

Wouldn't surprise me if Cameron got the final vote

[jvalles69]

Giants vs Dogs was tough...Bont, Greene, Dahl, Williams, Shaw, Mumford, Smith, Haynes, Daniel, Macrae, Cameron all possibilities of polling to be honest!  Does Greene get votes if he's reported?  Macrae got loads of free kicks and sometimes that helps me determine whether they get votes...

3 - Bont
2 - Greene
1 - ?

???

Wouldn't surprise me if Cameron got the final vote

Thats what I'm leaning towards...1st two prob correct yeah?

[kilbluff1985]

probably Shaw imo

[jvalles69]

probably Shaw imo

Possibly, but I thought he butchered it a fair bit.  Thought guy like Williams, Wilson and Haynes were all better, he just racked up cheap touches like he usually does.

[dmac07]

probably Shaw imo

Possibly, but I thought he butchered it a fair bit.  Thought guy like Williams, Wilson and Haynes were all better, he just racked up cheap touches like he usually does.

Shaw, Macrae, Williams and Haynes were the ones I considered. Easy goals for Cameron this week which dont look as good, thought Patton was the better forward. Between Haymes and Williams, I went Haynes, lots of eye catching intercepts and marks

[meow meow]

3 time Gary

[jvalles69]

probably Shaw imo

Possibly, but I thought he butchered it a fair bit.  Thought guy like Williams, Wilson and Haynes were all better, he just racked up cheap touches like he usually does.

Shaw, Macrae, Williams and Haynes were the ones I considered. Easy goals for Cameron this week which dont look as good, thought Patton was the better forward. Between Haymes and Williams, I went Haynes, lots of eye catching intercepts and marks

Agree, but you've also got to take into account "known" names and previous polling, which is why Cameron or Shaw get the vote for me.

[jvalles69]

Sloane building a nice lead...

[_wato]

Sloane bog again

13 votes now imo

[jvalles69]

Sloane bog again

13 votes now imo

Yep thereabouts, I've got him on 14 and Danger next on 9.

[dmac07]

probably Shaw imo

Possibly, but I thought he butchered it a fair bit.  Thought guy like Williams, Wilson and Haynes were all better, he just racked up cheap touches like he usually does.

Shaw, Macrae, Williams and Haynes were the ones I considered. Easy goals for Cameron this week which dont look as good, thought Patton was the better forward. Between Haymes and Williams, I went Haynes, lots of eye catching intercepts and marks

Agree, but you've also got to take into account "known" names and previous polling, which is why Cameron or Shaw get the vote for me.

Shaw is a completely wowful vote getter though, even in his very best games, and Cameron not much better by memory though not as sure.