Brownlow 2017

[jvalles69]

Only just thought about this, didn't we say a bunch of us would put out votes for each game to try and simulate the Brownlow voting?  Any thoughts on how we should/could do it?  I'll still do my own count, but would be cool if we could do a season long group Brownlow.  Maybe get a solid number of participants and each person puts up their 3-2-1 for each game, then average those results out for each game to come up with a group 3-2-1.  Anyone keen?

[Hawka]

Only just thought about this, didn't we say a bunch of us would put out votes for each game to try and simulate the Brownlow voting?  Any thoughts on how we should/could do it?  I'll still do my own count, but would be cool if we could do a season long group Brownlow.  Maybe get a solid number of participants and each person puts up their 3-2-1 for each game, then average those results out for each game to come up with a group 3-2-1.  Anyone keen?

My site will be doing a brownlow article every week
Im happy to post our votes here to help the average :)

[jvalles69]

Only just thought about this, didn't we say a bunch of us would put out votes for each game to try and simulate the Brownlow voting?  Any thoughts on how we should/could do it?  I'll still do my own count, but would be cool if we could do a season long group Brownlow.  Maybe get a solid number of participants and each person puts up their 3-2-1 for each game, then average those results out for each game to come up with a group 3-2-1.  Anyone keen?

My site will be doing a brownlow article every week
Im happy to post our votes here to help the average :)

Sounds good mate!  :D

[jvalles69]

So far what I've got for the round.  Bolded are locks.  Can't for the life of me work out the Pies/Dogs game though..  :-\

Round 1                   Blues vs Tigers   Dustin Martin   3   Marc Murphy   2   Kade Simpson   1 Pies vs Dogs                   Swans vs Power   Ollie Wines   3   Chad Wingard   2   Lance Franklin   1 Saints vs Demons   Nathan Jones   3   Jordan Lewis   2   Nick Riewoldt   1 Bombers vs Hawks   Dyson Heppell   3   Zach Merrett   2   Tom Mitchell   1 Suns vs Lions   Dayne Beams   3   Dayne Zorko   2   Gary Ablett   1 Kangaroos vs Eagles                   Crows vs Giants                   Dockers vs Cats

[TomK]

Pendles should be 3, whether the umps see the same since they lost is a different question.

[GoLions]

I assume Beams is a lock considering he won the BOG medal? Tbh I thought Rocky was ahead of him though, he was flowering insane.

With the Lions winning, could go Beams, Rocky, Zorko. Touk, Hall, Ablett all a chance of stealing a vote though.

For Blues vs Tigs:
Dusty obviously 3, think Prestia, Murphy, Kreuzer were the next best, but rucks never get the votes, so Murphy 2 and Prestia 1 there for me

Swans vs Port maybe JPK over Buddy for the 1 vote

Agree with Dons vs Hawks votes you have there

Pies and Dogs a tough one. Pendles clear BOG for me. Maybe JJ 2 votes, Sidey 1 vote.

[RaisyDaisy]

Pendles 3 (Pretty sure he won the medal?)

Adams and Sidey possible to get a vote. JJ best for Dogs

Reckon Gawn might get a vote too

[_wato]

Blues vs Tigers   Dustin Martin   3   Marc Murphy   2   Kade Simpson   1
Pies vs Dogs      Scott Pendlebury   3   Jason Johannisen   2   Taylor Adams   1               
Swans vs Power   Ollie Wines   3   Chad Wingard   2   Lance Franklin   1
Saints vs Demons   Nathan Jones   3   Jordan Lewis   2   Nick Riewoldt   1
Bombers vs Hawks   Dyson Heppell   3   Zach Merrett   2   Tom Mitchell   1
Suns vs Lions   Tom Rockliff  3   Dayne Zorko   2   Dayne Beams   1
Kangaroos vs Eagles                 
Crows vs Giants                 
Dockers vs Cats     

[Hawka]

3: Dustin Martin 2: Marc Murphy 1: Dion Prestia
3: Jason Johannisen 2: Scott Pendlebury 1: Lachie Hunter
3: Dyson Heppell 2: Zach Merrett 1: Tom Mitchell
3: Tom Rockliff 2: Dane Beams 1: Aaron Hall 
3: Josh Kennedy 2: Sam Mitchell 1: Andrew Gaff
3: Rory Laird 2: Rory Atkins 1: Richard Douglas
3: Mitch Duncan 2: Patrick Dangerfield 1: Nat Fyfe

Havent got around to the 2 saturday twilight games yet !

[dmac07]

Do my own count also (best get last year was Gaff to win Eagles votes at $10). Will post here, will just be about collaborting everyones votes. Sorry about the large number of lines, its a direct copy and paste.

Round 1.

Carl 89 v Rich 132
3. D.Martin
2. D.Prestia
1. M.Murphy

Coll 86 v WB 100
3. S.Pendlebury
2. J.Johannisen
1. M.Bontempelli

St.K 90 vs Melb 120
3. N.Jones
2. C.Oliver
1. N.Riewoldt


Syd 82 v PA 110
3. O.Wines
2. JP.Kennedy
1. T.Boak

Ess 116 v Haw 91
3. D.Heppell
2. Z.Merrett
1. T.Mitchell

GC 96 v Bris 98
3. T.Rockliff
2. D.Beams
1. D.Zorko

N.M 93 v WC 136
3. JJ.Kennedy
2. S.Mitchell
1. A.Gaff

Ade 147 v GWS 91
3. R.Laird
2. R.Atkins
1. C.Cameron

Fre 73 v Geel 115
3. M.Duncan
2. P.Dangerfield
1. J.Selwood

[jvalles69]

So far what I've got for the round.  Bolded are locks.  Can't for the life of me work out the Pies/Dogs game though..  :-\

Round 1                   Blues vs Tigers   Dustin Martin   3   Marc Murphy   2   Kade Simpson   1 Pies vs Dogs                   Swans vs Power   Ollie Wines   3   Chad Wingard   2   Lance Franklin   1 Saints vs Demons   Nathan Jones   3   Jordan Lewis   2   Nick Riewoldt   1 Bombers vs Hawks   Dyson Heppell   3   Zach Merrett   2   Tom Mitchell   1 Suns vs Lions   Dayne Beams   3   Dayne Zorko   2   Gary Ablett   1 Kangaroos vs Eagles                   Crows vs Giants                   Dockers vs Cats

My updated round 1.
Round 1                  
Blues vs Tigers   Dustin Martin   3   Marc Murphy   2   Kade Simpson   1
Pies vs Dogs   Jason Johanison   3   Scott Pendlebury   2   Marcus Bontempelli   1
Swans vs Power   Ollie Wines   3   Chad Wingard   2   Lance Franklin   1
Saints vs Demons   Nathan Jones   3   Jordan Lewis   2   Nick Riewoldt   1
Bombers vs Hawks   Dyson Heppell   3   Zach Merrett   2   Tom Mitchell   1
Suns vs Lions   Tom Rockliff   3   Dayne Beams   2   Dayne Zorko   1
Kangaroos vs Eagles   Josh K Kennedy   3   Sam Mitchell   2   Andrew Gaff   1
Crows vs Giants   Rory Laird   3   Rory Atkins   2   Charlie Cameron   1
Dockers vs Cats   Patrick Dangerfield   3   Mitch Duncan   2   Joel Selwood   1

[PowerBug]

Who'd have expected 2 of the 3 Rory's to be in the best 3, and neither of them to be Sloane? :o I hope we get to see a game this season where the Rory's go 3,2,1 ;D

I didn't watch it only heard some on radio but Pendles was pretty huge and clutch.

[RaisyDaisy]

Pendles was BOG by a country mile

[Bill Manspeaker]

no votes for Gawn? I'd give him 3

[dmac07]

Pendles was BOG by a country mile

Agree, it doesnt matter that they lost, 3 votes easily! An even performance from the dogs with no one standing themselves that far clear of the rest.