Rockliff vs Treloar

[Samsturmfels]

Treloar cause i dont want a player who will miss 5 games during the season

[Goosey]

Voted Treloar, this year am going against my usual standard preferences which recenty haven't paid off, can't hurt to try something different right?!

[smashbox]

Rocky is risky due to the Fagan factor. Not sure how he's going to use Rocky.

[Grufflez]

Rocky is risky due to the Fagan factor. Not sure how he's going to use Rocky.

This^ New Coach trying to formulate a decent game plan and i read training reports that Rocky didn't look completely comfortable with the new play style, enough for me to sit back and watch.

Rockliff has long been know as an accumulator rather than a really damaging playing with the footy in hand something a new coach will be well aware of and bloody keen to change.

Don't expect a 120-130 season.

[Mongoose528]

Rocky is risky due to the Fagan factor. Not sure how he's going to use Rocky.

This^ New Coach trying to formulate a decent game plan and i read training reports that Rocky didn't look completely comfortable with the new play style, enough for me to sit back and watch.

Rockliff has long been know as an accumulator rather than a really damaging playing with the footy in hand something a new coach will be well aware of and bloody keen to change.

Don't expect a 120-130 season.

What do you think will be a realistic score?

[Grufflez]

Rocky is risky due to the Fagan factor. Not sure how he's going to use Rocky.

This^ New Coach trying to formulate a decent game plan and i read training reports that Rocky didn't look completely comfortable with the new play style, enough for me to sit back and watch.

Rockliff has long been know as an accumulator rather than a really damaging playing with the footy in hand something a new coach will be well aware of and bloody keen to change.

Don't expect a 120-130 season.

What do you think will be a realistic score?

I would play it safe and expect something in the 110-118 range then factor in a few missed games, each game missed means he needs to average even more vs a historically durable player like Hannebury/Selwood.

20+ games at 115 or better would be a win but with his historically good scoring post byes i'll assess after R11 whether to bring him in or not.

[MontyJnr]

Rocky is risky due to the Fagan factor. Not sure how he's going to use Rocky.

This^ New Coach trying to formulate a decent game plan and i read training reports that Rocky didn't look completely comfortable with the new play style, enough for me to sit back and watch.

Rockliff has long been know as an accumulator rather than a really damaging playing with the footy in hand something a new coach will be well aware of and bloody keen to change.

Don't expect a 120-130 season.

Great reasoning. New coach factor + injury risk is enough for me to classify Rocky as an upgrade target.

Thanks for your help everyone else who contributed :)

[LordSneeze]

Treloar,

With the injury risks that need to be taken in some other positions id prefer to just take the durable player here.

[Mongoose528]

I know it's way too early in the season, but I'm gutted I didn't choose Rocky.

[Torpedo10]

Yep.

It was a coin toss, and for those of us who chose Treloar it came up the wrong way.

[Judd Magic]

Trading Treloar out as soon as lockout opens!

Can't stand him flowering butchering the ball every damn week!  >:(

[RaisyDaisy]

Rocky seems to have a rare skill of being able to go absolutely massive when they're getting belted

Never see any one else go so huge in beltings

[tommy10]

Happy I have Rocky but soo disappointed in Treloar. Never again in SC unless he improves his DE. Thinking about a straight swap to Murph....or use JOM downgrade and upgrade to Pendles.

[Judd Magic]

Happy I have Rocky but soo disappointed in Treloar. Never again in SC unless he improves his DE. Thinking about a straight swap to Murph....or use JOM downgrade and upgrade to Pendles.

We will both trade out Treloar and then he will miraculously fix up his clangers and efficiency while scoring 130 + every week.  ::)

[GoLions]

;)