Carn 2017 team

[Carn]

Docherty Shaw Marchbank Hampton Vicker-Wills Stewart (Otten Hibberd)
Danger Pendles Selwood Treloar Fyfe Beams O'Mera D.Swallow (PP Barret Pickett)
Gawn Sandi (Strnadica)
Dahl Macrae Roughy Nankervis Taranto Eddy (Parfitt Houston)

Not enough starting premos?
Rip into it lads! Rookies?

[Mat0369]

This is almost the same as my team. The backline is exactly the same. The overall differences are Hanners instead of Treloar, Goldy instead of Gawn, Witts at R3 and I've gone with Hoskin-Elliot and Turner in the forward line instead of Nank and Houston.

I'm personally not a fan of Nank, I think if you want ruck cover you're better off taking a stab at Witts/Preuss/Cameron at R3. Otherwise it looks really good.

[greco272]

Are you worried about your backline?

Very weak imo.

[Carn]

Very worried. An suggestions on how to fix thuoy, thurlow and down an uber premo?

[greco272]

Hard to say... you could lose one of Beams, O'Mera or Swallow and upgrade in the backline.

Or even drop out a premium mid for a back but other then that the team is pretty solid.

[Carn]

So to strenghten DEF:
Marchbank>Tuohy
O'Mera>Atley

Better balance?

Docherty Shaw Tuohy Hampton Vicker-Wills Hibberd (Otten Stewart)
Danger Pendles Selwood Treloar Fyfe Beams D.Swallow Atley (PP Barret Pickett)
Gawn Sandi (Strnadica)
Dahl Macrae Roughy Nankervis Taranto Eddy (Parfitt Houston)

[Bully]

Don't think Atley will be selected.

[Carn]

Fox, wigg,... who else is a decent shout?

[Bully]

Fox, wigg,... who else is a decent shout?

Wigg no, Fox 50/50. Barrett a good shot if he gets promoted.

[Carn]

Some more tinkering:

Docherty Shaw Adams Hampton Vicker-Wills Hibberd (Otten Stewart)
Danger Pendles Selwood Treloar Fyfe Beams O'Mera PP (Miles Barret Pickett)
Gawn Sandi (Strnadica)
Dahl Macrae Roughy WHE Taranto Eddy (Parfitt Butler)

Better balance?

[Ringo]

Only Issue no back up for Sandi if he goes down in early Rounds, If you could swing WHE to Nank would do that as both would score similar imo.

Apart from that issue no other real issues canm not all have the same team.

[Carn]

Cheers for advice ringo. Been trying to get Nank in but would have to do the following to make it happen:
Gawn>Goldy
Selwood>Bont
Docherty>Laird
WHE>Nank

Might work?

[Bully]

Cheers for advice ringo. Been trying to get Nank in but would have to do the following to make it happen:
Gawn>Goldy
Selwood>Bont
Docherty>Laird
WHE>Nank

Might work?

Those changes are pretty reasonable.

[Ringo]

Agree those changes are reasonable.

[Carn]

Agree those changes are reasonable.

Reasonable but I do feel like I am giving up on the guys that have shown they can get uber scores: Gawn, Doc, Selwood. Each of those trades is step down just to get nank.