Suggestions please

[bindas123]

Hi All

Here's the team at the moment:

Backs:            H.Shaw - T.Adams - R.Laird - C.Marchbank - Hampton - M Scharenberg   
                     (A.Otten   T,Stewart)

Mids:             P.Dangerfield - S.Pendlebury - J.Kennedy - N.Fyfe - D.Beams - J.O'Meara - D.Swallow - J.Clayton
                     (S.Powell-Pepper - J.Pickett - N.Freeman) 

Rucks:           M.Gawn - Sandilands
                    (L.Strnadica)

Forwards:      L.Dahlhaus - Macrae - T.Greene - Nankervis - T.Miles - D.Houston   
                    (T.Smith - B.Eddy)

Key Questions -
Do I go Nankervis or Roughy ?
Sandi pick ..do I get cash from another position and upgrade to Ryder ?
Pendles or Treloar ?

Thanks!

[PureSwag]

1. Tough one IMO i think Nark with the only ruck thats going to play at the tigers he will score alot and with Rough his playing with a stacked Hawks forward line

2. Tough one it's your choice if you want to take the risk no ryder but if you want to stay safe no ryder

3. Pendles any day of the week his the better option end of story.

[Money Shot]

Nank should score 80-85 where as rough will probably average 5 or so less than that in my opinion and I think he will be rested at stages throughout the season.

It's probably more of a risk to go with Ryder than it is Sandi as you'll need to upgrade Ryder where as Sandi could be a keeper.

Pendles is the safer option.

[fasttrack13]

Nank + Rough... scratch sandilands

[ants]

1. i would go both!
2.sandi without a doubt! silly question
3. depenlebury
your backline is identical to mine - sharenberg

[bindas123]

Nank should score 80-85 where as rough will probably average 5 or so less than that in my opinion and I think he will be rested at stages throughout the season.

It's probably more of a risk to go with Ryder than it is Sandi as you'll need to upgrade Ryder where as Sandi could be a keeper.

Pendles is the safer option.

Thanks mate.. Pendle's injury that kept him out this weekend is a worry for me... but I suppose his record speaks for itself.
Thanks on the Sandi point.. that's made my mind clear on the selection. 

[bindas123]

Nank + Rough... scratch sandilands

What is Nank goes down or suspended for a week or two ?

[bindas123]

1. i would go both!
2.sandi without a doubt! silly question
3. depenlebury
your backline is identical to mine - sharenberg

Thanks mate.. gives me a bit more confidence in my backline then..... Have you also got Macrae ?