Jake Lloyd

[Blues Blues Blues]

Spending the extra cash and grabbing Docherty instead. Probably grab Lloyd next week.

[GoLions]

PB finally changed it to 'Lloyd' :')

[tor01doc]

PB finally changed it to 'Lloyd' :')

Now we can relax

[Johnahawk]

I voted Yay, but have changed my mind to a Nay.

Can't justify trading Newman to him atm while both their recent averages and BE's are so similar. Maybe next week

[Hoggyz_a_legend]

Z Jones to Lloyd for me. Was already on the cards before he got given a week off.

Docherty is too expensive, and will need 3 trades for me to bring in unless he does a Lloyd and gets injured in the first few minutes.

[kosduras]

i have two choices this week, go newman to lloyd or scooter to lloyd but he stays benched? is it worth culling newman for lloyd considering
1. they are scoring the same
2. the have low BE
3. newman has the higher ceiling but lloyd more consistant?

[RaisyDaisy]

Newman to Lloyd is a waste of a trade IMO

Just keep going with Newman until he gives you a reason not to

[tor01doc]

Newman to Lloyd is a waste of a trade IMO

Just keep going with Newman until he gives you a reason not to

Agree

[kosduras]

Newman to Lloyd is a waste of a trade IMO

Just keep going with Newman until he gives you a reason not to

Agree

cheers guys

[petefisker]

Z Jones to Lloyd for me. Was already on the cards before he got given a week off.

Docherty is too expensive, and will need 3 trades for me to bring in unless he does a Lloyd and gets injured in the first few minutes.

I can't justify wasting the trade, for Jones to Lloyd. Luxury trade. When your going for league, have cover and not many trades, think I value a trade higher than the 7-12 extra points from Lloyd.
Currently have Docherty, Adam's, Laird, Hibberd, Jones, Newman.

[batt]

Z Jones to Lloyd for me. Was already on the cards before he got given a week off.

Docherty is too expensive, and will need 3 trades for me to bring in unless he does a Lloyd and gets injured in the first few minutes.

I can't justify wasting the trade, for Jones to Lloyd. Luxury trade. When your going for league, have cover and not many trades, think I value a trade higher than the 7-12 extra points from Lloyd.
Currently have Docherty, Adam's, Laird, Hibberd, Jones, Newman.

It's worth it IMO.  Lloyd could average 15 ppg more based on recent form.  Jones out this week adds an extra 30ish points in Lloyd's favour probably.  So overall you're looking at the very least 150 points in total gained = approx $150k which is bang on the value of a trade at this time of year.  Add the difference in the price difference between them and you're at a minimum $160k.

[Bully]

Newman to Lloyd is a waste of a trade IMO

Just keep going with Newman until he gives you a reason not to

Lloyd will never be this cheap again. Happens every year, Vlastuin was a certain keeper, Cripps was a certain keeper, Tyson was a certain keeper, I could go on but you get the idea. Very happy to go head to head with Newman.

[AaronKirk]

Newman to Lloyd is a waste of a trade IMO

Just keep going with Newman until he gives you a reason not to

Lloyd will never be this cheap again. Happens every year, Vlastuin was a certain keeper, Cripps was a certain keeper, Tyson was a certain keeper, I could go on but you get the idea. Very happy to go head to head with Newman.

Agree with this. Newman if you have him should be a D7 not a D6. If you can't go one of your bench to Lloyd in 1 trade I would have no hesitation making that trade

I do not have Newman so maybe I am biased in that view.

As much as I do not like the idea of 4 premos from the same team I have brought him in for Marchbank this week.