UTG Season 2: Discussion & Banter Thread

Started by fanTCfool, March 08, 2017, 06:15:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

_wato

I reckon the only thing you can do is offer a trade in value of 12G for the card, let it be traded in as a gold for a platinum or be kept as an AOA card despite the change in gold to silver.

Or as Holz stated, a 50/50 punt on an actual GOLD collectible card in captain card or extra player.

elephants

Quote from: _wato on April 12, 2017, 06:43:42 PM
Of course you 3 agree, you're the 3 with the AOA cards still in hand.

I think it's unfair. You have over a 60% chance of gaining a gold player.

If I had of known this I would've kept my THREE AOA cards I have received in packs and then gained 3 gold players instead of trading them in for $$ to try and gain players elsewhere. We all know an AOA is practically useless this early in the year, so of course you're gonna sell to try your luck at a better team on the park.

Totally unfair imo.

Agreed, has to be a gold consumable.

GoLions

Quote from: _wato on April 12, 2017, 06:43:42 PM
Of course you 3 agree, you're the 3 with the AOA cards still in hand.

I think it's unfair. You have over a 60% chance of gaining a gold player.

If I had of known this I would've kept my THREE AOA cards I have received in packs and then gained 3 gold players instead of trading them in for $$ to try and gain players elsewhere. We all know an AOA is practically useless this early in the year, so of course you're gonna sell to try your luck at a better team on the park.

Totally unfair imo.
Yeah was thinking about this earlier. I reckon either keep, or cash in for 12g. Getting a gold player too unfair to those who already cashed theirs in. Or i guess switching for another gold consumable as well could be a good option as LS mentioned earlier, but with wato as an example, he may have wanted to do this earlier if he had the chance.

jvalles69

Yeah...I didn't realise anyone had cashed in any AOA's.  Definitely changes things then...  ???

jvalles69

Another gold consumable then or 12G's as normal? 

_wato

I reckon you should get the choice.

Trade in for 12G's.
Substitute for a 50/50 captain card extra player opportunity.
Keep the AOA card despite changing from gold to silver.
OR if you have enough trade in for a plat.

Hawka

Quote from: _wato on April 12, 2017, 08:19:15 PM
I reckon you should get the choice.

Trade in for 12G's.
Substitute for a 50/50 captain card extra player opportunity.
Keep the AOA card despite changing from gold to silver.
OR if you have enough trade in for a plat.
I am happy with that , makes things fair
will most likely use my card this week anyway if nothing changes

fanTCfool

Here are my conclusions,

All Out Attack Card
- The All Out Attack Card is not worthy of its gold rarity
- All Out Attack Card will be available in packs as a silver collectible from next week onwards

Existing All Out Attacks Cards must be...
- Used this week, or
- Sold for 12G, or
- Upgraded to a platinum with 6 other gold cards, or
- Exchanged for a different gold collectible (Captain Card or Extra Player)
Any Gold All Out Attack cards held by a user at the conclusion of this week will automatically be sold for 12G.

New Card: Spare Man
- The Spare Man Card is a silver collectible, joining All Out Attack and Home Ground Advantage
- Spare Man allows users to play one less midfielder or forward to play an extra defender
- Will be available in packs as a silver collectible from next week onwards

The Utility (3-3-1-3-1 Format)
- Is a great idea
- Will not be a permanent addition to UTG Season 2
- Is almost certain to be a permanent addition to UTG Season 3
- Will be used for Rounds 11, 12 and 13 this season

I think that covers everything!

Holz, JV, BM and Hawka will now be required to act on their All Out Attack Card.
If exchanging for a new gold collectible, please do so in the Exchanges thread.

jvalles69

Out of interest, what are the ratio's of each position?  Seems fairly hard to pick up defenders!

GoLions

Quote from: jvalles69 on April 19, 2017, 12:49:51 PM
Out of interest, what are the ratio's of each position?  Seems fairly hard to pick up defenders!
I would imagine it's just got to do with how many are available in each position (i.e. rucks much much harder to get). So if there's 300 mids and 250 defenders, mids are slightly easier to get. But for the most part, just luck of the draw :P

Holz

Quote from: GoLions on April 19, 2017, 01:02:02 PM
Quote from: jvalles69 on April 19, 2017, 12:49:51 PM
Out of interest, what are the ratio's of each position?  Seems fairly hard to pick up defenders!
I would imagine it's just got to do with how many are available in each position (i.e. rucks much much harder to get). So if there's 300 mids and 250 defenders, mids are slightly easier to get. But for the most part, just luck of the draw :P

Alex Rance, Jack Martin, Luke McDonald, Tom Stewart

But have only picked up 2 playing mids.


TomK

Quote from: Holz on April 19, 2017, 01:29:57 PM
Quote from: GoLions on April 19, 2017, 01:02:02 PM
Quote from: jvalles69 on April 19, 2017, 12:49:51 PM
Out of interest, what are the ratio's of each position?  Seems fairly hard to pick up defenders!
I would imagine it's just got to do with how many are available in each position (i.e. rucks much much harder to get). So if there's 300 mids and 250 defenders, mids are slightly easier to get. But for the most part, just luck of the draw :P

Alex Rance, Jack Martin, Luke McDonald, Tom Stewart

But have only picked up 2 playing mids.
Like GL said, just the luck of the draw.

Each specific player, regardless of position, would have the same chance of being packed as any other player within their rarity tier, at least I think that's how it works.

fanTCfool

Each position was staggered with similar ratios between Plat, Gold, Silver and Bronze, so there's no positional bias other than the simple fact that there are more listed midfielders than there are defenders, and the luck of the draw of course.

elephants

Stacked with back and struggling for mids! Thank Christ for Rich and Swallows upswing!

GoLions

So we going 3-4-1-3 next week? I'm gonna need another mid :-X