Player X v Player Y

[LaHug]

Means I can have Taranto

[WhatMate]

Means I can have Taranto

Yeh, I think id go Mitchell then.

[WhatMate]

GHS or DSwallow..

Anyone know where to find scores of GHS when unsubbed? I know that has affected past scores and it looks as if he has locked in a role, deffs a better pick than SPP, just not sure if he would be just as good as Swallow. Almost tossing up if i need to restructure my side to fit them both in


Edit:
Rockliff, Swallow, Barrett (m2, m7, m8)
Or
Mitchell, Swallow, GHS  (m2, m7, m8)

[Crustynuts]

Should I:
Keep Miles donut and take Butler's 72
or
Trade Miles to Houston or Weideman (at least they might make some cash) and play either of them or Eddy on field?

[LaHug]

Rockliff, Swallow, Barrett (m2, m7, m8)
Or
Mitchell, Swallow, GHS  (m2, m7, m8)

Can you go Mitchell, Swallow, Barrett and use the cash elsewhere?

Should I:
Keep Miles donut and take Butler's 72
or
Trade Miles to Houston or Weideman (at least they might make some cash) and play either of them or Eddy on field?

Don't keep Miles. Cash generation is much more important than 72 points.

[WhatMate]

Rockliff, Swallow, Barrett (m2, m7, m8)
Or
Mitchell, Swallow, GHS  (m2, m7, m8)

Can you go Mitchell, Swallow, Barrett and use the cash elsewhere?

I can, not sure if there is anywhere else that I would like to use the cash though. Barrett would move to the bench in place of Hibberd who would move to defense in this option.

Should I:
Keep Miles donut and take Butler's 72
or
Trade Miles to Houston or Weideman (at least they might make some cash) and play either of them or Eddy on field?

Don't keep Miles. Cash generation is much more important than 72 points.

Agree with this.

[LaHug]

Rockliff, Swallow, Barrett (m2, m7, m8)
Or
Mitchell, Swallow, GHS  (m2, m7, m8)

Can you go Mitchell, Swallow, Barrett and use the cash elsewhere?

I can, not sure if there is anywhere else that I would like to use the cash though. Barrett would move to the bench in place of Hibberd who would move to defense in this option.

Hmm, tough one then. I don't see why Rocky would score much more than Mitchell (if any more) early on and Mitchell's obviously cheaper. But, if you can't use the cash elsewhere, probably option one.

[LaHug]

Houston vs Simpkin vs Florent vs Bowes vs Turner?
($10k short on Taranto)

[WhatMate]

Rockliff, Swallow, Barrett (m2, m7, m8)
Or
Mitchell, Swallow, GHS  (m2, m7, m8)

Can you go Mitchell, Swallow, Barrett and use the cash elsewhere?

I can, not sure if there is anywhere else that I would like to use the cash though. Barrett would move to the bench in place of Hibberd who would move to defense in this option.

Hmm, tough one then. I don't see why Rocky would score much more than Mitchell (if any more) early on and Mitchell's obviously cheaper. But, if you can't use the cash elsewhere, probably option one.

Hmm yeh im in a tough predicament, GHS starting on the ball and his pre season form is what's turning me on.

[LaHug]

Rockliff, Swallow, Barrett (m2, m7, m8)
Or
Mitchell, Swallow, GHS  (m2, m7, m8)

Can you go Mitchell, Swallow, Barrett and use the cash elsewhere?

I can, not sure if there is anywhere else that I would like to use the cash though. Barrett would move to the bench in place of Hibberd who would move to defense in this option.

Hmm, tough one then. I don't see why Rocky would score much more than Mitchell (if any more) early on and Mitchell's obviously cheaper. But, if you can't use the cash elsewhere, probably option one.

Hmm yeh im in a tough predicament, GHS starting on the ball and his pre season form is what's turning me on.

If you honestly think GHS will be great, get him over Barrett. I think Mitchell and Rocky almost come out a wash. Barrett obviously got more money to make though if they'll be about even.

[WhatMate]

Houston vs Simpkin vs Florent vs Bowes vs Turner?
($10k short on Taranto)

I generally prefer the cheaper rookies, so I would be leaning towards Houston. How much more points could you see the other guys scoring at that extra 60-90k?

[LaHug]

Houston vs Simpkin vs Florent vs Bowes vs Turner?
($10k short on Taranto)

I generally prefer the cheaper rookies, so I would be leaning towards Houston. How much more points could you see the other guys scoring at that extra 60-90k?

Not many. It's more of a job security concern with Houston.

[WhatMate]

Houston vs Simpkin vs Florent vs Bowes vs Turner?
($10k short on Taranto)

I generally prefer the cheaper rookies, so I would be leaning towards Houston. How much more points could you see the other guys scoring at that extra 60-90k?

Not many. It's more of a job security concern with Houston.

It's hard really, depends how many other risky players you have in your team really and if he is worth the risk. Remember two trades each round so could be easy to correct in three weeks time..

[WhatMate]

Need to start one of Barrett, Pickett, Eddy and Butler. Based on performances so far I can probably narrow it down to Barrett and Butler.

Edit: thinking about it probably Butler, historically west coast havent been as good on the road and with richmonds current run of form I can hope that Butler snags a couple

[Jukes]

Need to start one of Barrett, Pickett, Eddy and Butler. Based on performances so far I can probably narrow it down to Barrett and Butler.

Edit: thinking about it probably Butler, historically west coast havent been as good on the road and with richmonds current run of form I can hope that Butler snags a couple

Yeah you got it mate, I'd go with Butler too (and am doing so this week)