Player X v Player Y

[Senior]

Greene and Swallow

vs

Neale and Hoskin-Elliott

[Sweet Chilli]

Greene and Swallow

[chief007]

Heath Shaw or Taylor adams

[WhatMate]

Greene and Swallow

vs

Neale and Hoskin-Elliott

Greene and Swallow

Heath Shaw or Taylor adams

Adams

[Rusty00]

Heath Shaw or Taylor adams

Adams

M Murphy vs Billings vs Oliver

[WhatMate]

M Murphy vs Billings vs Oliver

Awkward price range for me, personally wouldnt go with any of the players  :P Id stay away from Oliver, I think he'll be inconsistent as only second year and he still needs time to develop as a footballer, potential there in the future for sure. Murphy is more popular picked out of Billings and himself and rightfully so due to being able to average 100+ in the past and even if he reaches 95+ average he'll fetch you 100k (although same for Billings). Remember Billings was a #3 draft pick so we know potential is there, and coming into his 4th year he could really start to hit his strides. For me it's between Billings and Murphy, youve got one person who is coming towards the end of his career and one that is on the way up.



Martin or Grundy

[pommyadam]

Martin or Grundy

Grundy

you know what you're getting with him (ie not a 2nd ruckmen ready to kill his scoring)

[WhatMate]

Martin or Grundy

Grundy

you know what you're getting with him (ie not a 2nd ruckmen ready to kill his scoring)

Sorry, shouldve refined that. How about without Archie playing?

[Thunderbolts]

Martin or Grundy

Grundy

you know what you're getting with him (ie not a 2nd ruckmen ready to kill his scoring)

Sorry, shouldve refined that. How about without Archie playing?

Martin def if he is solo'ing

[Jukes]

I actually need help tbh

Jack Steele, Jobe Watson, and Todd Goldstein
vs
Isaac Smith, Andrew Gaff, and Jarryd Roughead

[Thunderbolts]

I actually need help tbh

Jack Steele, Jobe Watson, and Todd Goldstein
vs
Isaac Smith, Andrew Gaff, and Jarryd Roughead

I'd say Steele, Watson and Goldy

[Rusty00]

Laird + Swallow vs Thurlow + Parker/Hanners/JPK/TMitchell/Steven/etc

Laird or Thurlow would be my D3

[LaHug]

Laird + Swallow vs Thurlow + Parker/Hanners/JPK/TMitchell/Steven/etc

Laird or Thurlow would be my D3

Laird & Swallow for sure



T. Mitchell & cash enough for better rookies vs. Rockliff and scrape the barrel

[Crustynuts]

I'd go Mitchell and a good Rookie.  Clarkson didn't get him in to do a Longmire on him.  Scores will be pretty close, maybe not the Rocky 180s but 110+ each week.  Rocky has started to get injured more and more each year.

[WhatMate]

Depends what rookies, I'm not a fan of splashing out heaps of cash on too many rookies