Player X v Player Y

[Rusty00]

Let's try and get some discussion on the AF boards as well.

Maybe a three-way can kick things off

Thurlow + Goldy + Macrae; or
Marchbank + Gawn + Macrae; or
Marchbank + Goldy + NRoo

[jvalles69]

Let's try and get some discussion on the AF boards as well.

Maybe a three-way can kick things off

Thurlow + Goldy + Macrae; or
Marchbank + Gawn + Macrae; or
Marchbank + Goldy + NRoo

Tough, but I'd lean towards the 1st option.  Would prefer thurlow + Gawn + Dahl if you can swing it.

[Rusty00]

Let's try and get some discussion on the AF boards as well.

Maybe a three-way can kick things off

Thurlow + Goldy + Macrae; or
Marchbank + Gawn + Macrae; or
Marchbank + Goldy + NRoo

Tough, but I'd lean towards the 1st option.  Would prefer thurlow + Gawn + Dahl if you can swing it.

I could afford that option. At this stage prefer Macrae to Dahl in AF/DT though.

Round 1 teams may determine the Gawn/Goldy choice depending on if Spencer or Preuss are named to play.

[GoLions]

Marchbank Gawn Macrae imo

[WhatMate]

I'll add  :)


Laird, Mills, Nankervis + 156k
Vs
Loyd, Hibberd, Miller + 104k
Vs
Laird, Mills, Miller +28k




Hibberd vs Mills

[Sweet Chilli]

Let's try and get some discussion on the AF boards as well.

Maybe a three-way can kick things off

Thurlow + Goldy + Macrae; or
Marchbank + Gawn + Macrae; or
Marchbank + Goldy + NRoo

I think option 2. Though I'm concerned that both Marchbank and Thurlow may not score much more than a $150k player. However, their JS should be much higher.

[Sweet Chilli]

I'll add  :)


Laird, Mills, Nankervis + 156k
Vs
Loyd, Hibberd, Miller + 104k
Vs
Laird, Mills, Miller +28k




Hibberd vs Mills

I'd take Laird, Mills and Nank plus $$. Higher points output and price increase too with Nank compared to your other combos.

Mills over Hibberd. Mills is not injured. Will get time in the midfield and roam across half back for points.

[Rusty00]

I'll add  :)


Laird, Mills, Nankervis + 156k
Vs
Loyd, Hibberd, Miller + 104k
Vs
Laird, Mills, Miller +28k




Hibberd vs Mills

I'd take Laird, Mills and Nank plus $$. Higher points output and price increase too with Nank compared to your other combos.

Mills over Hibberd. Mills is not injured. Will get time in the midfield and roam across half back for points.

Yep agree, first one for me.

[pommyadam]

Mills over Hibberd. Mills is not injured. Will get time in the midfield and roam across half back for points.

tbh Hibberd looks like 2017's Sheridan/Lonergan

Dees look reasonable this season, and Hibberd isn't really getting involved
I know that he's only played one game since he got banned, but the absense from JLT4 (due to injury) is the death knell for him in my side

[Football Factory]

Let's try and get some discussion on the AF boards as well.

Maybe a three-way can kick things off

Thurlow + Goldy + Macrae; or
Marchbank + Gawn + Macrae; or
Marchbank + Goldy + NRoo

No2 for me

[Football Factory]

I'll add  :)


Laird, Mills, Nankervis + 156k
Vs
Loyd, Hibberd, Miller + 104k
Vs
Laird, Mills, Miller +28k

No1 for me, although I am not sure if Mills will become a keeper, and I cant see him making a lot of cash, easy upgrade to a premo though.

[WhatMate]

Heppell or Beams

Have had Heppell since the beginning but recently changed him to Beams. Seems as if there will be too many guys taking points off Heppell and he is possibly lacking fitness, Beams seems to be a more reliable option bar injury.

[Thunderbolts]

Heppell or Beams

Have had Heppell since the beginning but recently changed him to Beams. Seems as if there will be too many guys taking points off Heppell and he is possibly lacking fitness, Beams seems to be a more reliable option bar injury.

Beams - I know both have had long periods off for different reasons but Beams looks better and settled.

[Koop]

Hall + Pickett or Barlow + Florent?

[pommyadam]

Hall + Pickett or Barlow + Florent?

Barlow and Florent

I don't care what they say about Pickett, playing as a crumber in the Carlton forward line is NOT conducive to DT scoring