Second edition - All Stars

[_wato]

Swallow down and Bob up would be good if enough mid rookies pop up

Looks good!

Exactly. SPP on field, Swallow downgrade and then Bob to Prem defender.

Prem Defender (95) + SPP (75) v Bob (80) + Swallow (90)

Gain a keeper and more cash generation.

[Bully]

Swallow down and Bob up would be good if enough mid rookies pop up

Looks good!

Exactly. SPP on field, Swallow downgrade and then Bob to Prem defender.

Prem Defender (95) + SPP (75) v Bob (80) + Swallow (90)

Gain a keeper and more cash generation.

Not sure if SPP can average 75, not a noted possession gatherer.

[Ringo]

Would not worry too much about Murphy when you look at Dogs draw.  Know projected scores are guess work but predicted average for first 10 Rounds is 103.1.  Even if drops to say 95 you would still take it.  He is priced at 72 so fair scope for price rise.

[_wato]

Would not worry too much about Murphy when you look at Dogs draw.  Know projected scores are guess work but predicted average for first 10 Rounds is 103.1.  Even if drops to say 95 you would still take it.  He is priced at 72 so fair scope for price rise.

It's the fact that I don't genuinely see him as a keeper. I've been pretty much against him all pre season.
Cool if he plays all the way until his bye to sideways trade him but I don't see it happening. Will only play 16-18 games.

So i need to find a way to not hurt the structure too much and upgrade him.. Don't know what use downgrading him would be as it means i miss out on Swallow or JOM in the midfield (as I'd have spare cash to upgrade them and dunno where else I'd spend that $$$$

so many decisions !!!!!

[_wato]

Just went Swallow -> Taranto, Murphy -> Howe

[GoLions]

Just went Swallow -> Taranto, Murphy -> Howe

I like it (providing Taranto plays ofc)

[eaglesman]

Just went Swallow -> Taranto, Murphy -> Howe

I like it (providing Taranto plays ofc)

Mate I don't like Murphy whatsoever but change that back to what you had originally and juggle things around to get Murphy to someone else.

Just my opinion

[GoLions]

Just went Swallow -> Taranto, Murphy -> Howe

I like it (providing Taranto plays ofc)

Mate I don't like Murphy whatsoever but change that back to what you had originally and juggle things around to get Murphy to someone else.

Just my opinion

Not a fan of Howe? Could push a 100avg this season i reckon, prefer him to Adams atm

[_wato]

Just went Swallow -> Taranto, Murphy -> Howe

I like it (providing Taranto plays ofc)

Mate I don't like Murphy whatsoever but change that back to what you had originally and juggle things around to get Murphy to someone else.

Just my opinion

Not a fan of Howe? Could push a 100avg this season i reckon, prefer him to Adams atm

That is my only issue with Howe. Him, Adams and Laird all with the same bye.
And I would choose Adams over him any day of the week. Also worried that I'll have too many Pies boys. Currently have 3 and will probably get Treloar/Pendles (whichever I don't start with) later on on the year as my 4th.
Also seriously considering not starting Pendles but I'll chicken. I just can't find the funds anywhere right now to do what I want.

[eaglesman]

Just went Swallow -> Taranto, Murphy -> Howe

I like it (providing Taranto plays ofc)

Mate I don't like Murphy whatsoever but change that back to what you had originally and juggle things around to get Murphy to someone else.

Just my opinion

Not a fan of Howe? Could push a 100avg this season i reckon, prefer him to Adams atm

That is my only issue with Howe. Him, Adams and Laird all with the same bye.
And I would choose Adams over him any day of the week. Also worried that I'll have too many Pies boys. Currently have 3 and will probably get Treloar/Pendles (whichever I don't start with) later on on the year as my 4th.
Also seriously considering not starting Pendles but I'll chicken. I just can't find the funds anywhere right now to do what I want.

It's not that I don't like howe I just think there are better safer options at that upper price level.

As much as I love taranto(massive fan already the way he shrugged that big hit from Franklin and got back into it,WOW), you can't pick him over the security of swallow even with the price difference. I'm fine with picking Taranto in another position but downgrading swallow is not the answer given job security differences imo.

Yup downgrade pendles before swallow in this instance imo

[enzedder]

Swallow down and Bob up would be good if enough mid rookies pop up

Looks good!

Bob down and Swallow if you could... something could pop up... On second thoughts forget about Bob... Swallow looks a good pick.
Actually looks a really strong team. Same mids as me bar one. I have Bont, not Jelwood.
Strong fwds and backs.
Is Sandi a must? Maybe he is but if I bring him in I have a problem about what to do with 250-300k.

[_wato]

I've just moved Swallow out of the team and brought JOM to M8.

Super super strong mids now.

[Grufflez]

Swallow down and Bob up would be good if enough mid rookies pop up

Looks good!

Exactly. SPP on field, Swallow downgrade and then Bob to Prem defender.

Prem Defender (95) + SPP (75) v Bob (80) + Swallow (90)

Gain a keeper and more cash generation.

Not sure if SPP can average 75, not a noted possession gatherer.

I agree, don't think SPP will be the stud some are hoping for SC wise.

[_wato]

DEF: Adams, Laird, Howe, Marchbank, EVW, Hampton (Stewart, Otten)
MID: Dangerfield, Rockliff, Treloar, Fyfe, Watson, Beams, O'Meara, Swallow (SPP, Hibberd, Pickett)
RUC: Sandilands, Witts (Strnadica)
FWD: N Riewoldt, Dahlhaus, Higgins, Roughead, Nankervis, Taranto (Houston, Eddy)

$30k in the bank. Reasonably happy with this team. Any improvements?

[Huttabito]

Love it Wato.

SandiWitts gives a lot of wiggling room to p*ss off these poor rookies.