INJURED PLAYERS DISCUSSION THREAD 2017

Started by LF, January 31, 2017, 05:09:12 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Rusty00

Quote from: Mat0369 on June 16, 2017, 05:51:17 PM
Not really, Thompson and Salem have both gotten a week for driving the elbow into a opponent's head while they were on the ground. It's actually consistent. If it's judged the same way he will get a week.
Didn't Alex Rance do something similar last year as well?

jvalles69

Quote from: Mat0369 on June 16, 2017, 05:51:17 PM
Not really, Thompson and Salem have both gotten a week for driving the elbow into a opponent's head while they were on the ground. It's actually consistent. If it's judged the same way he will get a week.

For sure, he could've just fallen into Mitchell's back, but he decided to lift the arm to make contact, and no way that was an instinctive break my fall elbow, he knew what he was doing.  Mitchell might have a career in the UFC after that though!  ;D

Mat0369

I think so. Those elbows to the head have been pretty much an automatic week. The only thing that saves him is they claim he slipped since everyone lost their feet all game and the downgrade it to unintentional

shaker

#783
Quote from: Mat0369 on June 16, 2017, 05:58:00 PM
I think so. Those elbows to the head have been pretty much an automatic week. The only thing that saves him is they claim he slipped since everyone lost their feet all game and the downgrade it to unintentional
Even though he slipped it still looks intentional and I have him a week for sure and Dusty is not a worry trained well

P.S. Just saw the sideways view of the Selwood report and it is way less damning than the earlier rear view I saw not so sure how it will go now.

Mat0369

Jon Ralph reckons both Mitchell and Selwood will get fines. Not that he knows what's going on. Sellers reckons Selwood might be in a bit of trouble.

Grufflez

Can't see how Jelly doesn't get a week.
Shuey should get time too but probably won't because Danger was unaffected.

crowls

#786
Quote from: fanTCfool on June 16, 2017, 02:13:56 AM
I feel vindicated for avoiding Scooter  :P
avoided both selwoods until this week.  Joel was considered but did bont.     Then in juggling options around (harbrow parked, evw out, steele dropped) and could not afford Doch upgrade did mcgrath to SSelwood and fyfe to JSelwood to give me 16 prem and 19 playing.    SC Gods are laughing themselves to death as I plummet down the ladder.

Nige

Confirmed broken leg for Michael Barlow, same one he broke in his debut season. Absolutely heartbreaking.

Toga


no eye deer

Quote from: Nige on June 18, 2017, 01:34:29 AM
Confirmed broken leg for Michael Barlow, same one he broke in his debut season. Absolutely heartbreaking.


Shattered to hear that. He did so well to come back from the first break in his debut season, when he was on track for a Brownlow.

RoughRed

Quote from: no eye deer on June 18, 2017, 02:09:51 PM
Quote from: Nige on June 18, 2017, 01:34:29 AM
Confirmed broken leg for Michael Barlow, same one he broke in his debut season. Absolutely heartbreaking.


Shattered to hear that. He did so well to come back from the first break in his debut season, when he was on track for a Brownlow.

That is shocking result. Probably career ending now given his age. Barlow is such a testament to grit and determination and making the most of what you have!

I wish him well

PowerBug

BREAKING: @GWSGIANTS star Josh Kelly & Jacob Hopper both injured at training yesterday. Neither ruled out of R14 yet, awaiting scans.
Leader of the King Karl Amon fan club
Coach of WXV side Rio De Janeiro Jaguars
2023 SC: Rank 126

jvalles69

The opposite of injured... Simon Goodwin has said Gawn will return next week against West Coast.

Mat0369


LordSneeze

Quite a lot of snippets in the injury wrapup this week. A few are fantasy relevant.

Nakia Cockatoo - Hamstring
Scott Selwood - Hamstring
Lin Jong - ACL
Nathan Jones â€" Quad
Jack Watts â€" Hamstring Tightness
Jayden Hunt - Shoulder 
Neville Jetta - Ankle
Jackson Nelson â€" Hamstring
Jared Polec - Hamstring
Michael Barlow - Broken Leg
Matt Priddis â€" Strapped Thigh
Jarrad Waite - Concussion
Dylan Grimes â€" Ankle
Josh Kelly - Unknown
Jacob Hopper - Unknown
Jake Barrett  - unknown
Nick Robertson â€" Unknown
Tom Rockliff - Groin
Kamdyn McIntosh - hamstring tightness
Toby Nankervis - corked calf
Luke Dunstan - shin
Robbie Tarrant â€" Cheekbone & Hamstring tightness
Koby Stevens - Arm
Adam Saad - Sore