SuperCoach team 2017! feedback pls

Started by ZachFisher, January 15, 2017, 07:18:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ZachFisher

Feedback and advice on my team please :)
my team will change a bit before round 1 but this is a start.

Team name: THE FISH

DEF: SIMPSON, T.ADAMS, LAIRD, SCHAENBERG, HAMPTON, STEWART (HIBBERD, RYAN)
MID: DANGERFIELD, TRELOAR, MARTIN, FYFE, BEAMS, POWELL-PEPPER, MYERS, GRAHAM (FREEMAN, BALIC, FISHER)
RUCK: GOLDSTIENE, GRUNDY (STRNADICA)
FWD: DAHLAUS, MACRAE, T.LYNCH(GCS), CADDY, HEENEY, PICKETT (BOLTON, EDDY)

Ringo

Not a bad first up effort -

Just a couple of suggestions:
Not sure on Martin at this point in time but go with gut. Plenty of options at price though.
Think You are spending a bit much in forwards with both Caddy and Heeney - Would only have 1 given there will probably be quite a few fwd rooks/returning players to pick from. Would downgrade one to on of these and look at possibly another prem midfielder where points will be earned.

As I said go with gut your team and good luck for the season.

ZachFisher

Quote from: Ringo on January 15, 2017, 07:42:02 PM
Not a bad first up effort -

Just a couple of suggestions:
Not sure on Martin at this point in time but go with gut. Plenty of options at price though.
Think You are spending a bit much in forwards with both Caddy and Heeney - Would only have 1 given there will probably be quite a few fwd rooks/returning players to pick from. Would downgrade one to on of these and look at possibly another prem midfielder where points will be earned.

As I said go with gut your team and good luck for the season.

thanks for the feedback mate! I'll be looking to make a few changes, downgrading Caddy and getting in another premium mid.

Fid

Not a bad side mate.

I would also get rid of Caddy and look at a downgrade in the fwds mand grab another premo mid

pietime

Def get rid of Cuddy, Never been a fan of his. Plenty of kids like McClugguge and Ainsworth Which also gives M/F options and $$$ to upgrade one of those Midfielders. He is not in my side but Beams could be the best bargain buy of the year if stays fit.

GoLions

I actually like the Caddy pick, reckon he'll get a decent run in the mids at the Tigs, could easily be a top 10 forward. Definitely prefer him over Heeney at this stage.

Also agree with Ringo regarding Dusty, might spend a bit more time forward now with Prestia and Caddy making the move to Tigerland. (fwiw could help his scores, but it is an unknown so a bit of risk there)

Biggest thing though is you have basically said you don't want Gawn all year. Brave move :-X

Would probably downgrade 1-2 forwards, look to bring in someone like Pendles, and if possible maybe Grundy to Gawn.

meow meow

Would get rid of your M11, clearly a dud with a name like that.