Player X v Player Y

[tor01doc]

Cotchin vs Murphy vs Parker vs Beams vs Gibbs vs Sloane

Please help!

Personally wouldn't want either Murphy or Cotchin in my team.

Sloane is too vulnerable to tags.

Parker not on fire but maybe with JPK out could go better.

Gibbs is solid but plays for Carlton.

Beams is a gun and worth the risk IMO.

[Huttabito]

Neale worth the extra $70k over Beams for durability sake? Neale does leave me with a couple of hundred bucks though.

[tor01doc]

Neale worth the extra $70k over Beams for durability sake? Neale does leave me with a couple of hundred bucks though.

Depends whether the $70K can be used elsewhere. If so, then save coin.

I would gamble on Beams at this price though.

[whynot102]

Beams or Shiel

[Gandalf123]

Beams or Shiel

Beams

[n185]

Kruzer vs Ryder vs Gawn


I'm convinced that Kruzer will score the most against Essendon but Ryder also been good what do u all think?

Gawn is just Gawn

[smashbox]

Neale vs Kelly vs Oliver

[tommy10]

Gawn vs Stef?

[TomK]

Kruzer vs Ryder vs Gawn


I'm convinced that Kruzer will score the most against Essendon but Ryder also been good what do u all think?

Gawn is just Gawn

Honestly couldn't go wrong with any of them, Kruez under the concussion cloud makes me a bit nervous though, but I like Gawn just cause of his potential and him getting all his midfield back.

Neale vs Kelly vs Oliver

Neale

Gawn vs Stef?

Gawn

[Marstar]

Billings Vs NRoo? maybe this was the more appropriate thread to ask  :-[

[enzedder]

Neale vs Fyfe

Fyfe mate. His premo scoring is back and is a far better player than Neale

Neale will finish in the top 8 mids for the year, very harsh assessment.

Harsh but true.

[enzedder]

Billings Vs NRoo? maybe this was the more appropriate thread to ask  :-[

Billings for mine.

[jfitty]

Here's one for my draft league, need to pick two from:

Sam Reid, Jamie Elliott, Jake Carlisle & Tom Phillips

Leaning towards Reid and Elliott...

[tkringle]

Start Newman or Shaw?

[Ringo]

With GWS playing Melbourne tempted to go Shaw.