Player X v Player Y

Started by _wato, January 06, 2017, 12:29:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

tkringle

Quote from: whynot102 on July 28, 2017, 04:57:32 PM
Start Nank or Lynch this week

Screwed either way i reckon, which is why i'm trading so i don't have to start either..

- Nank has Soldo competing for ruck time
- Lynch has Rance

If i had to, I would go Nank

BLBBLB

Dusty or Tich? Rocky needs to go

enzedder

95 v Greenwood
95 in the bank yeah.

SilverLion

Quote from: BLBBLB on July 28, 2017, 08:00:08 PM
Dusty or Tich? Rocky needs to go
Would've gone Titch personally.

Quote from: enzedder on July 30, 2017, 06:32:09 AM
95 v Greenwood
95 in the bank yeah.
Definitely the 95.

67 vs. Greenwood?

Figured got not much to lose so will probably roll with Greenwood.


no eye deer

Quote from: SilverLion on July 30, 2017, 10:32:23 AM
Quote from: BLBBLB on July 28, 2017, 08:00:08 PM
Dusty or Tich? Rocky needs to go
Would've gone Titch personally.

Quote from: enzedder on July 30, 2017, 06:32:09 AM
95 v Greenwood
95 in the bank yeah.
Definitely the 95.

67 vs. Greenwood?

Figured got not much to lose so will probably roll with Greenwood.

Yeah mate, Greenwood over 67 is a no brainer.

BLBBLB

Quote from: BLBBLB on July 28, 2017, 08:00:08 PM
Dusty or Tich? Rocky needs to go

Missed lockout, then downgraded him to Young with a double upgrade coming this week (both Titch and Dusty). Very happy to have dodged his 66

smashbox

Can't carry JPK anymore been spudding it up.

Kelly vs Neale?

GoSaints3

Quote from: smashbox on July 31, 2017, 07:59:16 PM
Can't carry JPK anymore been spudding it up.

Kelly vs Neale?

Lucky if JPK is your biggest issue. That aside i would go kelly

no eye deer

Quote from: no eye deer on July 30, 2017, 12:05:07 PM
Quote from: SilverLion on July 30, 2017, 10:32:23 AM
Quote from: BLBBLB on July 28, 2017, 08:00:08 PM
Dusty or Tich? Rocky needs to go
Would've gone Titch personally.

Quote from: enzedder on July 30, 2017, 06:32:09 AM
95 v Greenwood
95 in the bank yeah.
Definitely the 95.

67 vs. Greenwood?

Figured got not much to lose so will probably roll with Greenwood.

Yeah mate, Greenwood over 67 is a no brainer.

Sorry about that! Put the mocca on him there.

Blues Blues Blues

Need a midfielder. Was hoping to get Dusty but now due to having to deal with Witts I'm short.

If I finally flower off Shaw, and play either Ryan or Schaz each week, I can afford $585.9k.
If I get rid of Greenwood instead, I can afford $549.7k.

There are a lot of options, but I've narrowed to the following:

If trade Shaw
- M Crouch ($585.7k): in great form
- Oliver ($554.7k): gun who keeps firing
- Kelly ($554.6k): having a great year, but GWS fading?

If trade either Shaw or Greenwood
- Zerrett ($544.7k):up and down but can go big
- Neale ($534.4k: can go huge and has some home games
- Beams ($463.7k): bloody cheap and scoring well

Help me pick pleas!

ivolve

Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on August 01, 2017, 09:59:37 PM
Need a midfielder. Was hoping to get Dusty but now due to having to deal with Witts I'm short.

If I finally flower off Shaw, and play either Ryan or Schaz each week, I can afford $585.9k.
If I get rid of Greenwood instead, I can afford $549.7k.

There are a lot of options, but I've narrowed to the following:

If trade Shaw
- M Crouch ($585.7k): in great form
- Oliver ($554.7k): gun who keeps firing
- Kelly ($554.6k): having a great year, but GWS fading?

If trade either Shaw or Greenwood
- Zerrett ($544.7k):up and down but can go big
- Neale ($534.4k: can go huge and has some home games
- Beams ($463.7k): bloody cheap and scoring well

Help me pick pleas!

I have Neale who has been a star all year, but really trying to get M.Crouch into my side this week or next. I'd go Greenwood to Crouch as Shaw is still more reliable than Shaz/Ryan.

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: ivolve on August 02, 2017, 12:21:40 AM
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on August 01, 2017, 09:59:37 PM
Need a midfielder. Was hoping to get Dusty but now due to having to deal with Witts I'm short.

If I finally flower off Shaw, and play either Ryan or Schaz each week, I can afford $585.9k.
If I get rid of Greenwood instead, I can afford $549.7k.

There are a lot of options, but I've narrowed to the following:

If trade Shaw
- M Crouch ($585.7k): in great form
- Oliver ($554.7k): gun who keeps firing
- Kelly ($554.6k): having a great year, but GWS fading?

If trade either Shaw or Greenwood
- Zerrett ($544.7k):up and down but can go big
- Neale ($534.4k: can go huge and has some home games
- Beams ($463.7k): bloody cheap and scoring well

Help me pick pleas!

I have Neale who has been a star all year, but really trying to get M.Crouch into my side this week or next. I'd go Greenwood to Crouch as Shaw is still more reliable than Shaz/Ryan.

Can't afford Crouch mate if I trade Greenwood. Only afford $549.7k. 

Seriously considering playing Ryan or Schaz moving forward - they look solid and better than flowering Shaw

shaker

Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on August 01, 2017, 09:59:37 PM
Need a midfielder. Was hoping to get Dusty but now due to having to deal with Witts I'm short.

If I finally flower off Shaw, and play either Ryan or Schaz each week, I can afford $585.9k.
If I get rid of Greenwood instead, I can afford $549.7k.

There are a lot of options, but I've narrowed to the following:

If trade Shaw
- M Crouch ($585.7k): in great form
- Oliver ($554.7k): gun who keeps firing
- Kelly ($554.6k): having a great year, but GWS fading?

If trade either Shaw or Greenwood
- Zerrett ($544.7k):up and down but can go big
- Neale ($534.4k: can go huge and has some home games
- Beams ($463.7k): bloody cheap and scoring well

Help me pick pleas!
I think Beams is your man cheap scoring good 3 games in Brissie got him for Sloane a couple of weeks ago myself , if you will still have trades left next week $$ cash in the bank is the important thing deciding who to flick

enzedder

Quote from: shaker on August 02, 2017, 10:41:32 AM
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on August 01, 2017, 09:59:37 PM
Need a midfielder. Was hoping to get Dusty but now due to having to deal with Witts I'm short.

If I finally flower off Shaw, and play either Ryan or Schaz each week, I can afford $585.9k.
If I get rid of Greenwood instead, I can afford $549.7k.

There are a lot of options, but I've narrowed to the following:

If trade Shaw
- M Crouch ($585.7k): in great form
- Oliver ($554.7k): gun who keeps firing
- Kelly ($554.6k): having a great year, but GWS fading?

If trade either Shaw or Greenwood
- Zerrett ($544.7k):up and down but can go big
- Neale ($534.4k: can go huge and has some home games
- Beams ($463.7k): bloody cheap and scoring well

Help me pick pleas!
I think Beams is your man cheap scoring good 3 games in Brissie got him for Sloane a couple of weeks ago myself , if you will still have trades left next week $$ cash in the bank is the important thing deciding who to flick
Beams is my man. Can't be anyone else's man.
He's worth it at the price... worth it if you add on another 100k IMO.... only worry is his shoulder. Apparently he hurt it again towards the end of this week's game but Lion's staff reckon he'll be right to play.

Who to play Ryan v Shaw as D6 ? (played Shaw all year but in light of Ryan posting a monster score and missing out on it this past weekend I'm contemplating putting my $576,500 season beginning premium as D7)

Mark

TMitch or Dusty ?

Ryder or Kruz or Gawn ?

Thanks in advance