Player X v Player Y

Started by _wato, January 06, 2017, 12:29:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

TomK

Bench Nank or TJ for Greenwoods 103?

Take Lairds 83 or field Shaw?

Bluesalltheway

Quote from: TomK on July 22, 2017, 01:19:06 AM
Bench Nank or TJ for Greenwoods 103?

Take Lairds 83 or field Shaw?

I'd probably bench Lynch, can't see him getting much supply without Ablett and Lyons.

And I'd field Shaw.  Has gone above 83 5 of his last 6 games.

Rusty00

Still can't decide whether to bring in Fyfe or Bont this week. Fyfe seems like one of those traps where he's played a couple of good games, jump back on, then he spuds :-\

ivolve

Bringing in Kruz for Nank. locked. 8)

Greenwood to which final forward:

1: Ryder
2: Heeney
3: Hold

Already have Macrae, Dahl, Yeo, Higgins, Buddy.
6 trades going into this week.

Cheers

shaker

Quote from: ivolve on July 26, 2017, 12:08:34 AM
Bringing in Kruz for Nank. locked. 8)

Greenwood to which final forward:

1: Ryder
2: Heeney
3: Hold

Already have Macrae, Dahl, Yeo, Higgins, Buddy.
6 trades going into this week.

Cheers
I would go Ryder especially if it gives you ruck cover and he has been in good form lately peeling off 5 out of 6 tons in last 6 games

Thewizz71

Hurley or Roberton. Trading Newman to one of them.
Thinking Hurley.

MC

Quote from: Thewizz71 on July 26, 2017, 01:02:58 PM
Hurley or Roberton. Trading Newman to one of them.
Thinking Hurley.

Hurley the better pick, though saving 100k on Roberton might prove a more profound difference if you're forced to trade in the coming weeks. Depends completely on your trade situation

Gandalf123

Cotchin v Sloane v Adams for rocky

Rusty00

Fyfe v Beams?

Beams gives me a good chunk of cash so I hopefully won't need to waste a trade on a downgrade to give me cash for any fix-ups needed - I'm looking at you Rocky >:(

But can I trust him to stay fit though?

Hazza09

1 trade left & 241k

Have Pendles.....

1. Pendles - Mitchell (leaves me treadless and 120k)
2. Mountofrd - Selwood (Keep Pendles)
3. Hold

Whats worse? Being left tradeless with a whole lot of cash or a Pendles on the bench for most likely the remainder of the year?  :-\

jfitty

Quote from: Hazza09 on July 28, 2017, 11:22:39 AM
1 trade left & 241k

Have Pendles.....

1. Pendles - Mitchell (leaves me treadless and 120k)
2. Mountofrd - Selwood (Keep Pendles)
3. Hold

Whats worse? Being left tradeless with a whole lot of cash or a Pendles on the bench for most likely the remainder of the year?  :-\

If you don't trade Pendles, who would you have to field?

I'd be inclined to (sadly) use your last trade and grab Mitchell.. Good chance to get a top 3 SC player in.

Quote from: Rusty00 on July 27, 2017, 10:12:57 PM
Fyfe v Beams?

Beams gives me a good chunk of cash so I hopefully won't need to waste a trade on a downgrade to give me cash for any fix-ups needed - I'm looking at you Rocky >:(

But can I trust him to stay fit though?

I reckon the cash saved getting Beams makes him worthwhile - can see them both averaging around the same for the rest of the year.

tkringle


Hazza09

QuoteIf you don't trade Pendles, who would you have to field?

I'd be inclined to (sadly) use your last trade and grab Mitchell.. Good chance to get a top 3 SC player in.

I have Zorko aswell, so this week id have Adams swung into M7 to cover Zorko and id have to play Mountford as M8 to cover Pendles.

I can go Mountford - Selwood and when Zorkp returns Adams goes back into defence and i have Pendlebury sitting on my bench as a M9  >:(

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: tkringle on July 28, 2017, 12:42:28 PM
Kreuz vs Gawn + ~$130K?

My dilemma too. Grab the best on the eve of SC finals or go for a value buy?

I really want to get people's thoughts on this. I didn't see his knock to his calf and I know there was doubt about him even playing this week. Should we be worried he may get managed in lead up to finals? Or will they play him as they need to win to stay in?

I feel this trade choice could be defining. If Gawn fires the extra cash will be so valuable. But if he falls...

whynot102

Start Nank or Lynch this week