Player X v Player Y

[Thewizz71]

If you had to trade one this week?

Z Fisher or T Williamson?

[Hazza09]

If you had to trade one this week?

Z Fisher or T Williamson?

Williamson

[cotch9]

Neale v Merrett v Pendles

For next week

[Thewizz71]

Neale v Merrett v Pendles

For next week

Pendles.

Goldy or Stef for Steele?

[Keeper27]

Team is almost complete and have decent cover on all lines.
my question is who do i Trade out??

Fyfe (avg 88.7 in last 7 games) or Steele (avg 83.8 in last 5)

Fyfe has been poor, yes i know i should never trade out a premium ... blah blah blah... but his current scores are so far from premium.
Steele was dropped after a bad game and his TOG has been low.

I'm leaning towards Steele because i've suffered through long enough with Fyfe and so many others are in the same boat, but i cant have a Donut "premium" in the FWD line.
I'm looking at Papley... 99.1 in his last 6 with 2 tons.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Who to bring in?

Jake Lloyd: dropped to $411k and a BE of 50
Docherty: jumped to $634k but only a BE of 75. Will go higher

[batt]

@Thewizz hope you went Goldy :)

@Keeper Steele easily first to go.

@BBB Really depends how you're sitting trades wise.  If you're close to completion I think you have to jump on Dochers now. Lloyd is great value but not if that means going without Dochers.

My question is: Lloyd + $100k vs Roberton.  Saints upcoming draw has me strongly leaning towards Roberton.  I think I might be in the minority.

It would cost me an extra trade to find the cash but I'm not too fussed as the difference is 6 injury trades instead of 7.

[Blues Blues Blues]

@BBB Really depends how you're sitting trades wise.  If you're close to completion I think you have to jump on Dochers now. Lloyd is great value but not if that means going without Dochers.

My question is: Lloyd + $100k vs Roberton.  Saints upcoming draw has me strongly leaning towards Roberton.  I think I might be in the minority.

It would cost me an extra trade to find the cash but I'm not too fussed as the difference is 6 injury trades instead of 7.

Just need 2 more defenders and 1 forward - 14 trades left. Thinking of jumping on docherty, I can't handle not having him. Problem is I'll need to trade Fyfe to get him...

I'd prob go Lloyd v Roberton mate, the $100k and trade handy and I think they'll score similar.

[batt]

Just need 2 more defenders and 1 forward - 14 trades left. Thinking of jumping on docherty, I can't handle not having him. Problem is I'll need to trade Fyfe to get him...

I'd prob go Lloyd v Roberton mate, the $100k and trade handy and I think they'll score similar.

$634k is bloody pricey... but he's the second highest averaging player (holy shower) in SC so clearly worth it.

I think the people anticipating a Fyfe turnaround are thinking wishfully.  He hasn't shown the ceiling of prior seasons- and generally players will show their true ceiling the first half of the year.  120s mixed with 90s isn't going to cut it.

I've thought more about Roberton v Lloyd and switched back to Lloyd.  Think I need to let my cows graze a bit more and use that extra trade to get TJ Lynch off field in a few  weeks' time.

[quinny88]

Neale vs Merrett??

[Hazza09]

Merrett vs Zorko

&

T Mitchell vs Dusty  :-\

[jfitty]

Merrett vs Zorko

&

T Mitchell vs Dusty  :-\

Zorko and Mitchell for mine out of those two

Neale vs Merrett??

Hmm, think I'd prefer Neale. Both scoring consistently, but like Neale a bit better

[enzedder]

Heeney v Wallis v Billings

[Ingram]

Pendles Vs Merret Vs Neale

Mids: Danger, Martin, Mitchell, Selwood, Hanners, Rocky, Trelor.

[Samm79]

Heeney v Wallis v Billings

Heeney

Pendles Vs Merret Vs Neale

Mids: Danger, Martin, Mitchell, Selwood, Hanners, Rocky, Trelor.

Leaning towards Pendles, next 3 at the MCG but it's a close one. I have Zerrett, have a sale or Pendles as the last kid upgrade myself... Neale is mighty tempting and the extra $$$ may come in handy...

On that, Neale v Pendles