Player X v Player Y

[crowls]

Normally you would take Selwood over Oliver.    However there is nothing in Oliver's performances to indicate this is not his normal state of affairs.   Same as Bont last year (Oliver if anything is even more consistent).   Do you think he wont perform like this next year.


OTH Selwood known for strong back to season, proven long term performer.   For me it is down to byes and price at time of trade.   

[Hazza09]

Normally you would take Selwood over Oliver.    However there is nothing in Oliver's performances to indicate this is not his normal state of affairs.   Same as Bont last year (Oliver if anything is even more consistent).   Do you think he wont perform like this next year.


OTH Selwood known for strong back to season, proven long term performer.   For me it is down to byes and price at time of trade.   

Which means? Selwood?  8)

[Gigantor]

Donut
v
Durdin
v
Non Bubble fwd rookie
v
Risky fwd pick <427k  Pedo/Petracca/Burton/Hawkins

[PowerBug]

Donut
v
Durdin
v
Non Bubble fwd rookie
v
Risky fwd pick <427k  Pedo/Petracca/Burton/Hawkins

That's a real pickle. I'm going to suggest donut because the others aren't as good long term :-\

[shaker]

Balic > Stewart and Otten > Hibberd and no donut in FWD's or
SPP > Myers and Hampton > JJ or Howe or Rance with a donut in the FWD's ?

[PICCOLLO]

Bolton vs Greenwood

Risky business

[mzunguman]

Hurley V Williams V Rance (Good bye)

[jfitty]

Bolton vs Greenwood

Risky business

Greenwood if you need one of these fellas. DPP, mature and cheap so ticks all the boxes (good luck!).

Hurley V Williams V Rance (Good bye)

I really like Hurley, but go Rance if it suits your byes better.

[Hazza09]

Butler & Swallow - Stefan Martin (Via Nankervis)  & Bolton or Greenwood?  :-\

Or

Butler & Swallow - Dusty & Bolton or Greenwood?

:'(

[plumdog millionaire]

Butler & Swallow - Stefan Martin (Via Nankervis)  & Bolton or Greenwood?  :-\

Or

Butler & Swallow - Dusty & Bolton or Greenwood?

:'(

First one and Greenwood.

Assuming Swallow is M8 and Butler F6 then:

-SMartin allows you to move your F5 to F6 but you're left with a weaker M9, which you can always loophole.
-DMartin allows M7 to M8 but F7 to F6. You'll probably have weak FWD coverage with Eddy (If you have him) and Greenwood/Bolton + can't swing Nank as he's already in FWD's.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Cripps v Zerret?

Cripps $543k with BE of 62. 3 tonnes in a row including the biggy v Saints. I think he's hitting his straps.
Zerret $560k with BE of 60. Proven ball winner

[tkringle]

Cripps v Zerret?

Cripps $543k with BE of 62. 3 tonnes in a row including the biggy v Saints. I think he's hitting his straps.
Zerret $560k with BE of 60. Proven ball winner

Cripps

[GoLions]

Cripps v Zerret?

Cripps $543k with BE of 62. 3 tonnes in a row including the biggy v Saints. I think he's hitting his straps.
Zerret $560k with BE of 60. Proven ball winner

Cripps

Zerrett :P

[HappyDEZ]

SPP - Dusty/Zorko

or

Swallow - Oliver/Selwood

Swallow to Jelwood I reckon. Safer pick than Oliver/Zorko for sure, probably safer than Dusty, and I think SPP is a safer option to keep in the team...

Safer pick?  :o

Oliver is averaging 114, has only had 1 score under 100 and scored 142 last week.

Think he is safer than Selwood atm....

I would think Oilver was the safest pick at the moment, but i have a sneaky feeling Zorko might step up with Rockliff out.
Is it to late to go with Oliver? is he a top 8/9 mid for the remainder of the season, that is the question.

Selwood is a champion and his run over the next 3 weeks ( all at Skilled stadium under lights ) is something i think has to be considered.

Has a huge B/E though  :-\

Jelwood is just as likely to take that BE at Skilled as an insult and have a fair crack at it. I too would love him this week but the BE does hurt. Guess the question I'm asking of myself is "Am I happy paying $548k for him?"

I paid $612 3 weeks back. Not happy  :D.

[GVSKiwi]

Heeney v Koby Stevens