Player X v Player Y

[Judd Magic]

Trade out Treloar or Beams?
Treloar- $525k
              96 average
              163 BE

Beams- $477k
              96 average.
              113 BE.

Looking at the stats, you would say Treloar has to go.
I suppose it comes down to how long Beams will be out and do we trust Treloar to improve?

Even if Beams was out for 10 weeks I'd still trade out Troll Trelolar.  8)

So glad to finally flower him off this week. Should have done it ages ago like I had planned to.  ::)

[no eye deer]

Trade out Treloar or Beams?
Treloar- $525k
              96 average
              163 BE

Beams- $477k
              96 average.
              113 BE.

Looking at the stats, you would say Treloar has to go.
I suppose it comes down to how long Beams will be out and do we trust Treloar to improve?

Even if Beams was out for 10 weeks I'd still trade out Troll Trelolar.  8)

So glad to finally flower him off this week. Should have done it ages ago like I had planned to.  ::)

Haha! I was expecting something like this from you JM! You've been posting everywhere about how happy you are to trade him out. Trying to convince yourself?.

Don't get me wrong, I've got the showers big time with him, like all of us. BUT, I'm going to have to hold him. Still could turn it around. Money/rookies for upgrades will be very hard to find this year it seems. A trade saved hopefully. Or he bleeds more cash and kills me. So be it.

Beams is injury prone and calves can drag on for ever. Hasn't shown he can attain his past form.

Time to be conservative. One trade only this week. Beams to Bont. Leaves my mids as Danger, Pendles, Rocky, Bont, Fyfe, Hanners, Treloar and SPP.

[GoLions]

Trade out Treloar or Beams?
Treloar- $525k
              96 average
              163 BE

Beams- $477k
              96 average.
              113 BE.

Looking at the stats, you would say Treloar has to go.
I suppose it comes down to how long Beams will be out and do we trust Treloar to improve?

Even if Beams was out for 10 weeks I'd still trade out Troll Trelolar.  8)

So glad to finally flower him off this week. Should have done it ages ago like I had planned to.  ::)

Haha! I was expecting something like this from you JM! You've been posting everywhere about how happy you are to trade him out. Trying to convince yourself?.

Don't get me wrong, I've got the showers big time with him, like all of us. BUT, I'm going to have to hold him. Still could turn it around. Money/rookies for upgrades will be very hard to find this year it seems. A trade saved hopefully. Or he bleeds more cash and kills me. So be it.

Beams is injury prone and calves can drag on for ever. Hasn't shown he can attain his past form.

Time to be conservative. One trade only this week. Beams to Bont. Leaves my mids as Danger, Pendles, Rocky, Bont, Fyfe, Hanners, Treloar and SPP.

Who injured their calf?

[Jay]

Dusty or ZMerrett?

[no eye deer]

Trade out Treloar or Beams?
Treloar- $525k
              96 average
              163 BE

Beams- $477k
              96 average.
              113 BE.

Looking at the stats, you would say Treloar has to go.
I suppose it comes down to how long Beams will be out and do we trust Treloar to improve?

Even if Beams was out for 10 weeks I'd still trade out Troll Trelolar.  8)

So glad to finally flower him off this week. Should have done it ages ago like I had planned to.  ::)

Haha! I was expecting something like this from you JM! You've been posting everywhere about how happy you are to trade him out. Trying to convince yourself?.

Don't get me wrong, I've got the showers big time with him, like all of us. BUT, I'm going to have to hold him. Still could turn it around. Money/rookies for upgrades will be very hard to find this year it seems. A trade saved hopefully. Or he bleeds more cash and kills me. So be it.

Beams is injury prone and calves can drag on for ever. Hasn't shown he can attain his past form.

Time to be conservative. One trade only this week. Beams to Bont. Leaves my mids as Danger, Pendles, Rocky, Bont, Fyfe, Hanners, Treloar and SPP.

Who injured their calf?

Sorry, my bad. Quad. Stand by my argument though.

[GoLions]

Trade out Treloar or Beams?
Treloar- $525k
              96 average
              163 BE

Beams- $477k
              96 average.
              113 BE.

Looking at the stats, you would say Treloar has to go.
I suppose it comes down to how long Beams will be out and do we trust Treloar to improve?

Even if Beams was out for 10 weeks I'd still trade out Troll Trelolar.  8)

So glad to finally flower him off this week. Should have done it ages ago like I had planned to.  ::)

Haha! I was expecting something like this from you JM! You've been posting everywhere about how happy you are to trade him out. Trying to convince yourself?.

Don't get me wrong, I've got the showers big time with him, like all of us. BUT, I'm going to have to hold him. Still could turn it around. Money/rookies for upgrades will be very hard to find this year it seems. A trade saved hopefully. Or he bleeds more cash and kills me. So be it.

Beams is injury prone and calves can drag on for ever. Hasn't shown he can attain his past form.

Time to be conservative. One trade only this week. Beams to Bont. Leaves my mids as Danger, Pendles, Rocky, Bont, Fyfe, Hanners, Treloar and SPP.

Who injured their calf?

Sorry, my bad. Quad. Stand by my argument though.

Looking like playing next week fwiw. And was averaging like 105ish iirc before getting injured. I'm holding myself, but can understand why people would trade :P

[no eye deer]

Trade out Treloar or Beams?
Treloar- $525k
              96 average
              163 BE

Beams- $477k
              96 average.
              113 BE.

Looking at the stats, you would say Treloar has to go.
I suppose it comes down to how long Beams will be out and do we trust Treloar to improve?

Even if Beams was out for 10 weeks I'd still trade out Troll Trelolar.  8)

So glad to finally flower him off this week. Should have done it ages ago like I had planned to.  ::)

Haha! I was expecting something like this from you JM! You've been posting everywhere about how happy you are to trade him out. Trying to convince yourself?.

Don't get me wrong, I've got the showers big time with him, like all of us. BUT, I'm going to have to hold him. Still could turn it around. Money/rookies for upgrades will be very hard to find this year it seems. A trade saved hopefully. Or he bleeds more cash and kills me. So be it.

Beams is injury prone and calves can drag on for ever. Hasn't shown he can attain his past form.

Time to be conservative. One trade only this week. Beams to Bont. Leaves my mids as Danger, Pendles, Rocky, Bont, Fyfe, Hanners, Treloar and SPP.

Who injured their calf?

Sorry, my bad. Quad. Stand by my argument though.

Looking like playing next week fwiw. And was averaging like 105ish iirc before getting injured. I'm holding myself, but can understand why people would trade :P

Yeah, his last game dropped his average. Haven't  heard anything new about next week, only that the Lions would reevaluate his injury after two weeks. But I'll take your word for it GL. You would know more than me.

Hmm, not sure Beams will be a keeper, but Treloar could. This is doing my head in!

[Maca24]

Heath Shaw vs Zac Williams

[Huttabito]

Heath Shaw vs Zac Williams

Zac

[Judd Magic]

Trade out Treloar or Beams?
Treloar- $525k
              96 average
              163 BE

Beams- $477k
              96 average.
              113 BE.

Looking at the stats, you would say Treloar has to go.
I suppose it comes down to how long Beams will be out and do we trust Treloar to improve?

Even if Beams was out for 10 weeks I'd still trade out Troll Trelolar.  8)

So glad to finally flower him off this week. Should have done it ages ago like I had planned to.  ::)

Haha! I was expecting something like this from you JM! You've been posting everywhere about how happy you are to trade him out. Trying to convince yourself?.

Don't get me wrong, I've got the showers big time with him, like all of us. BUT, I'm going to have to hold him. Still could turn it around. Money/rookies for upgrades will be very hard to find this year it seems. A trade saved hopefully. Or he bleeds more cash and kills me. So be it.

Beams is injury prone and calves can drag on for ever. Hasn't shown he can attain his past form.

Time to be conservative. One trade only this week. Beams to Bont. Leaves my mids as Danger, Pendles, Rocky, Bont, Fyfe, Hanners, Treloar and SPP.

Treloars cost me cash league wins mate so that's why I am even more furious with him.  >:(

The old me would have traded him out 4 weeks ago so I'm amazed that I have held onto him for this long.  ;D

[no eye deer]

Trade out Treloar or Beams?
Treloar- $525k
              96 average
              163 BE

Beams- $477k
              96 average.
              113 BE.

Looking at the stats, you would say Treloar has to go.
I suppose it comes down to how long Beams will be out and do we trust Treloar to improve?

Even if Beams was out for 10 weeks I'd still trade out Troll Trelolar.  8)

So glad to finally flower him off this week. Should have done it ages ago like I had planned to.  ::)

Haha! I was expecting something like this from you JM! You've been posting everywhere about how happy you are to trade him out. Trying to convince yourself?.

Don't get me wrong, I've got the showers big time with him, like all of us. BUT, I'm going to have to hold him. Still could turn it around. Money/rookies for upgrades will be very hard to find this year it seems. A trade saved hopefully. Or he bleeds more cash and kills me. So be it.

Beams is injury prone and calves can drag on for ever. Hasn't shown he can attain his past form.

Time to be conservative. One trade only this week. Beams to Bont. Leaves my mids as Danger, Pendles, Rocky, Bont, Fyfe, Hanners, Treloar and SPP.

Treloars cost me cash league wins mate so that's why I am even more furious with him.  >:(

The old me would have traded him out 4 weeks ago so I'm amazed that I have held onto him for this long.  ;D

I might just ditch them both, gray Bont and Yeo and be done with it!

[Mongoose528]

Treloar -> Yeo vs Holding

[GCSkiwi]

Treloar -> Yeo vs Holding

I feel like that trade doesn't make sense as a sideways option. You're going from someone who's proven but out of form, to someone who's unproven but in good form. Sure at some point you have to make a call based on current form, and Yeo is looking appealing as a fwd option, but as a sideways trade for Treloar I think not, even if you plan to shift him fwd later. If you trade treloar, you go to a proven, in form gun.

If it's Yeo vs hold, I say hold.

[Rusty00]

Who to start?

Barrett v Fisher v Parsons?

(Can't loophole) :(

[tor01doc]

Treloar -> Yeo vs Holding

If you believe in the Yeo (i.e. top 6 - 8 fwd) then this is the week to get him. Such a low BE. For a lot of teams I have seen a pretty good bye round too. DPP will help over the other bye rounds.

I will hold Treloar as I can get Yeo by trading Otten (who will probably lose money this week) and Houston who is out the next 2 weeks minimum.