Player X v Player Y

[Bully]

EVW versus McNiece

Mainly concerned about JS so please enlighten me as to whose knocking on the door.

[Judd Magic]

EVW versus McNiece

Mainly concerned about JS so please enlighten me as to whose knocking on the door.

I'd go the cheaper option in McNiece plus I think he will be a better scorer long term.

Also older too which means more mature body.

[Bully]

EVW versus McNiece

Mainly concerned about JS so please enlighten me as to whose knocking on the door.

I'd go the cheaper option in McNiece plus I think he will be a better scorer long term.

Also older too which means more mature body.

Yep, that was my thinking. 24 y/o versus 21 y/0. Can't think of anyone in line to replace him either. If Myers comes in and he retains his spot then that's the way I'll go.

[Judd Magic]

EVW versus McNiece

Mainly concerned about JS so please enlighten me as to whose knocking on the door.

I'd go the cheaper option in McNiece plus I think he will be a better scorer long term.

Also older too which means more mature body.

Yep, that was my thinking. 24 y/o versus 21 y/0. Can't think of anyone in line to replace him either. If Myers comes in and he retains his spot then that's the way I'll go.

Might even pick him up myself next week if he has a good game this week despite the price rise. 

Don't think his JS will be an issue like you said.

[brudski]

Yeo v Higgins

[Bluesalltheway]

EVW versus McNiece

Mainly concerned about JS so please enlighten me as to whose knocking on the door.

I'd go the cheaper option in McNiece plus I think he will be a better scorer long term.

Also older too which means more mature body.

Yep, that was my thinking. 24 y/o versus 21 y/0. Can't think of anyone in line to replace him either. If Myers comes in and he retains his spot then that's the way I'll go.

Might even pick him up myself next week if he has a good game this week despite the price rise. 

Don't think his JS will be an issue like you said.

EVW has a much better bye though

[TableKing]

Michael Hibberd (BE-22) v Heeney (BE - 75)

I know Hibberd has the better BE but i feel Heeney has greater potential to score. Mentioned in a previous post, Heeney will float through the midfield this season. Sydney are terrible but surely they cant continue.

Thoughts?

[GoLions]

Michael Hibberd (BE-22) v Heeney (BE - 75)

I know Hibberd has the better BE but i feel Heeney has greater potential to score. Mentioned in a previous post, Heeney will float through the midfield this season. Sydney are terrible but surely they cant continue.

Thoughts?

Well, if you want both, then grab Hibberd this week and Heeney next week (assuming you have the cash to do so).

If you just want one, I guess I'd go for Heeney as he could end up closer to top 6-10 fwds than Hibberd will with the top 6-10 defenders.

[Bully]

Yeo v Higgins

I'm biased because I have Higgins and love the way he plays. Slight injury risk however, have already been caught out with his late withdrawl. Spoke to my Eagles mate on Sunday and he won't be touching Yeo this year, reckons he'll moved around the park to suit the circumstances. This could be terribly frustrating. Higgins is also a lot cheaper, at worst he becomes a very handy F7 (and I reckon we'll all need one this year).

[dmac07]

Yeo v Higgins

I'm biased because I have Higgins and love the way he plays. Slight injury risk however, have already been caught out with his late withdrawl. Spoke to my Eagles mate on Sunday and he won't be touching Yeo this year, reckons he'll moved around the park to suit the circumstances. This could be terribly frustrating. Higgins is also a lot cheaper, at worst he becomes a very handy F7 (and I reckon we'll all need one this year).

2 good scores, 1 poor score, miss and repeat. Can score but would have to be brave.

[jfitty]

Yeo v Higgins

Tough one, I have both because I love living life on the edge.

Yeo has the ceiling, but I feel like Higgins will be more consistent over the year. Although he has had a few poor scores Missy is by far North's best kick and should see plenty of midfield time.

I'd go Higgins purely because he's cheaper, but Yeo is definitely looking solid this early in the season.

[Bully]

Yeo v Higgins

I'm biased because I have Higgins and love the way he plays. Slight injury risk however, have already been caught out with his late withdrawl. Spoke to my Eagles mate on Sunday and he won't be touching Yeo this year, reckons he'll moved around the park to suit the circumstances. This could be terribly frustrating. Higgins is also a lot cheaper, at worst he becomes a very handy F7 (and I reckon we'll all need one this year).

2 good scores, 1 poor score, miss and repeat. Can score but would have to be brave.

3 tons out of 5 is a good strike rate. Also has 2 twenty game seasons to his credit in 2014/15. For 444k is a decent bet.

[Mongoose528]

Yeo v Higgins

I'm biased because I have Higgins and love the way he plays. Slight injury risk however, have already been caught out with his late withdrawl. Spoke to my Eagles mate on Sunday and he won't be touching Yeo this year, reckons he'll moved around the park to suit the circumstances. This could be terribly frustrating. Higgins is also a lot cheaper, at worst he becomes a very handy F7 (and I reckon we'll all need one this year).

If he is on the park, he generally scores well.

2 good scores, 1 poor score, miss and repeat. Can score but would have to be brave.

3 tons out of 5 is a good strike rate. Also has 2 twenty game seasons to his credit in 2014/15. For 444k is a decent bet.

Agree with this. If he is on the field, he will score well.

[jfitty]

Shaw and Stef vs Roberton and Goldy/Grundy

Feel like option one is safer, but really want Roberton!

[Judd Magic]

Shaw and Stef vs Roberton and Goldy/Grundy

Feel like option one is safer, but really want Roberton!
[/quote

Option 1 for me.  ;)