Player X v Player Y

[Samsturmfels]

Butler vs Parfitt vs WHE vs Black

pick 2 for the fwds

not exactly sure what your asking. To trade? To field?

if asking who to field id pick both Butler and WHE because they have both been reliable to score over 50 and have the potential to score high. Meanwhile Parfitt normally scores in the 50s and Black has only played one game

[Samsturmfels]

who should i get?   Hibberd v Greene v Yeo v a player under 503k

thanks in advance

[fanTCfool]

Zorko vs Martin vs Pendles vs Neale vs Hanners

If you want a premium right now, Zorko > Martin > Hanners. If not wait for Pendles man, BE of 187.

Hanners vs Treloar?

I'd take Treloar, Hanners doesn't look like having the sort of performance that Treloar did on Tuesday. Beast.

Here's one of my own,
Keep Pickett (Trade Taranto) and get Sloane vs Keep Taranto (Trade Pickett) and get Tom Mitchell?

Get Sloane. He is a top 3 or 4 mid, if you can get him in, you do it :)

Crazy to pay that much for Sloane. He did this a few seasons back and then tanked. Will probably end up being 110-115.

Hung on to Taranto, looks like it has gone well with a quarter to play  :)

[GoLions]

Pick 2 to start on the field (One in MID, One in FWD)

Balic (FWD/MID) v Parfitt (FWD/MID) v SPP (MID) v Fisher (MID)

Parfitt and SPP

[tommy10]

Balic and Jelwood vs Buddy and SPP?
Getting Jelwood means I will have 7 mid premos incl Beams and JOM at M8, but does weaken fwd line and play Balic/Parfitt and Butler at F5 & F6. Then get Black next week and either EVW/McNeice/Mexican.

Or is it better to get Buddy this week and Balic but means playing SPP. Thoughts?

[smashbox]

Balic this week Vs Black next week

[cityfolk_east]

What is everyone's take on Blake Hardwick (FWD - $123k) from Hawthorn?
on the bubble this week with two scores of mid 60s so far.

Balic seems to be the #1 target this week not sure why there is nearly no talk of Hardwick at all, is his JS wobbly?

[miamis_finest]

Eddy or Pickett to Balic

Or hold the trade and downgrade one of them next week for a safer rookie?

[Gigantor]

Eddy or Pickett to Balic

Or hold the trade and downgrade one of them next week for a safer rookie?

Who are the safer rookies?

[djbics]

Eddy or Pickett to Balic

Or hold the trade and downgrade one of them next week for a safer rookie?

Who are the safer rookies?

lol, yeah I wouldn't mind knowing that too

[miamis_finest]

Eddy or Pickett to Balic

Or hold the trade and downgrade one of them next week for a safer rookie?

Who are the safer rookies?

Aaron Black if he plays well this week (think that would give him another 3 weeks if he kicked 2-3 goals this weekend, EVW etc.

[miamis_finest]

Eddy or Pickett to Balic

Or hold the trade and downgrade one of them next week for a safer rookie?

Who are the safer rookies?

lol, yeah I wouldn't mind knowing that too

Anyway would you trade Pickett or Eddy out for Balic? Thanks.

[djbics]

Eddy or Pickett to Balic

Or hold the trade and downgrade one of them next week for a safer rookie?

Who are the safer rookies?

lol, yeah I wouldn't mind knowing that too

Anyway would you trade Pickett or Eddy out for Balic? Thanks.

I'm trading Eddy, yes he has more money to make over Pickett but I cant see him getting back into Ports side, Pickett's DPP gives you more flexibility to move him around irregardless of whether he plays.

FWIW I think they both need to go soon anyway

[miamis_finest]

Eddy or Pickett to Balic

Or hold the trade and downgrade one of them next week for a safer rookie?

Who are the safer rookies?

lol, yeah I wouldn't mind knowing that too

Anyway would you trade Pickett or Eddy out for Balic? Thanks.

I'm trading Eddy, yes he has more money to make over Pickett but I cant see him getting back into Ports side, Pickett's DPP gives you more flexibility to move him around irregardless of whether he plays.

FWIW I think they both need to go soon anyway

Appreciate it bud, and yeah Pickett stinks. Plenty of opportunities and can't get over 50.

[Mongoose528]

Dusty + 70k v Jelwood