Player X v Player Y

Started by _wato, January 06, 2017, 12:29:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

HoleMeal

T Lynch v Buddy v J Cameron

crowls

Quote from: HoleMeal on April 27, 2017, 06:30:38 PM
T Lynch v Buddy v J Cameron
Lynch>Buddy>Cameron.     same order

GoLions

Quote from: HoleMeal on April 27, 2017, 06:30:38 PM
T Lynch v Buddy v J Cameron
Buddy because Lynch has the bye coming up. Cameron has been great but I can't see him keeping this scoring up for much longer.

bkimm32

Wines vs Hannebery. Take into account Hannerberys bye round sucks for my team.

mzunguman

Quote from: bkimm32 on April 28, 2017, 08:27:36 AM
Wines vs Hannebery. Take into account Hannerberys bye round sucks for my team.

I like as a POD... Still want more from hanners and as you said his bye round isn't great.. give wines a go

Which combo
1) Roughy + Franklin/Yeo OR
2) Parfitt + Selwood/Rocky/Bont

bkimm32

Quote from: mzunguman on April 28, 2017, 08:52:04 AM
Quote from: bkimm32 on April 28, 2017, 08:27:36 AM
Wines vs Hannebery. Take into account Hannerberys bye round sucks for my team.

I like as a POD... Still want more from hanners and as you said his bye round isn't great.. give wines a go

Which combo
1) Roughy + Franklin/Yeo OR
2) Parfitt + Selwood/Rocky/Bont
So many people keep telling me to bring Wines in after his bye, I'd rather get him before it. That gives me enough points before he sits the week and a rookie or dpp covers, then he can go ham while all the other bye rounds are on.

I like the second combo better. More consistent and less injury prone. Probably Selwood.

crowls

Couple of trades again this week.


SPS to one of Macrae or Simpson/Shaw via DPPs.     Figure Macrae because more options down back for fallen prems.   Simmo, Shaw, Rance,  plus Montagna, Howe, LLoyd.  Macrae will outscore Simmo.
Pickett to Balic/Fisher.    Leaning towards Balic for DPP.     




enzedder

Quote from: bkimm32 on April 28, 2017, 08:27:36 AM
Wines vs Hannebery. Take into account Hannerberys bye round sucks for my team.
Either. Lingy said in commentary half way through the Carl game something like only 5 players to the beginning of the round had so many possessions and kicked so many goals....company was elite...Danger, Bont...etc and Wines was one. Kind of gives me the showers because I started him in 2016 expecting something like this but was served up score after score around 85 with lots of butchered ball.
Hanners is cheap as chips and is a great buy. Champion Data love him and if he scores 17/22 100+ scores as he has in receny years then you're laughing as he has nearly had his quota of non 100s already.

enzedder

Quote from: crowls on April 28, 2017, 10:25:08 AM
Couple of trades again this week.


SPS to one of Macrae or Simpson/Shaw via DPPs.     Figure Macrae because more options down back for fallen prems.   Simmo, Shaw, Rance,  plus Montagna, Howe, LLoyd.  Macrae will outscore Simmo.
Pickett to Balic/Fisher.    Leaning towards Balic for DPP.   
Good logic. My reasons exactly for trading in Macrae this week over Simpson who I initially wanted. Balic for DPP gives him the edge.

crowls

Quote from: enzedder on April 28, 2017, 10:39:53 AM
Quote from: crowls on April 28, 2017, 10:25:08 AM
Couple of trades again this week.


SPS to one of Macrae or Simpson/Shaw via DPPs.     Figure Macrae because more options down back for fallen prems.   Simmo, Shaw, Rance,  plus Montagna, Howe, LLoyd.  Macrae will outscore Simmo.
Pickett to Balic/Fisher.    Leaning towards Balic for DPP.   
Good logic. My reasons exactly for trading in Macrae this week over Simpson who I initially wanted. Balic for DPP gives him the edge.
only downside NZ is cannot catch up doing the same as everybody else.   Just need a shark move somewhere.   Other years have caught the Martin/Gawn mid year ruck train.      Just have to wait until the byes and see what outliers I can find.     Need Missy, Steele, Stef, to have a couple of great weeks.

enzedder

Quote from: crowls on April 28, 2017, 10:58:56 AM
Quote from: enzedder on April 28, 2017, 10:39:53 AM
Quote from: crowls on April 28, 2017, 10:25:08 AM
Couple of trades again this week.


SPS to one of Macrae or Simpson/Shaw via DPPs.     Figure Macrae because more options down back for fallen prems.   Simmo, Shaw, Rance,  plus Montagna, Howe, LLoyd.  Macrae will outscore Simmo.
Pickett to Balic/Fisher.    Leaning towards Balic for DPP.   
Good logic. My reasons exactly for trading in Macrae this week over Simpson who I initially wanted. Balic for DPP gives him the edge.
only downside NZ is cannot catch up doing the same as everybody else.   Just need a shark move somewhere.   Other years have caught the Martin/Gawn mid year ruck train.      Just have to wait until the byes and see what outliers I can find.     Need Missy, Steele, Stef, to have a couple of great weeks.
I'm all for Missy going bang.
The outliers will be there, it's just a case of picking the right ones.
Roberton at 1% ownership has been a beauty for me.
Miller and Higgins at 5% haven't been so kind as I didn't start with them.
Macrae at 20% isn't exactly popular yet, so he may give you a small leg up in the coming weeks before "everyone" has him.

crowls

Quote from: enzedder on April 28, 2017, 11:20:26 AM
Quote from: crowls on April 28, 2017, 10:58:56 AM
Quote from: enzedder on April 28, 2017, 10:39:53 AM
Quote from: crowls on April 28, 2017, 10:25:08 AM
Couple of trades again this week.


SPS to one of Macrae or Simpson/Shaw via DPPs.     Figure Macrae because more options down back for fallen prems.   Simmo, Shaw, Rance,  plus Montagna, Howe, LLoyd.  Macrae will outscore Simmo.
Pickett to Balic/Fisher.    Leaning towards Balic for DPP.   
Good logic. My reasons exactly for trading in Macrae this week over Simpson who I initially wanted. Balic for DPP gives him the edge.
only downside NZ is cannot catch up doing the same as everybody else.   Just need a shark move somewhere.   Other years have caught the Martin/Gawn mid year ruck train.      Just have to wait until the byes and see what outliers I can find.     Need Missy, Steele, Stef, to have a couple of great weeks.
I'm all for Missy going bang.
The outliers will be there, it's just a case of picking the right ones.
Roberton at 1% ownership has been a beauty for me.
Miller and Higgins at 5% haven't been so kind as I didn't start with them.
Macrae at 20% isn't exactly popular yet, so he may give you a small leg up in the coming weeks before "everyone" has him.
Taken a close look at Roberton/Lloyd as def options.    More inclined to risk them than jump on Heater or Simmo at the moment.    Also been keen on Lynch all preseason but his round 9 bye put me off.   Will be a fwd upgrade for me soon.   appreciate the feedback NZ thanks.[/size]

My Chumps

Gotta trade out one for Balic, who will it be?

Pickett v Florent v Eddy v Barrett

GoLions

Quote from: My Chumps on April 28, 2017, 01:22:19 PM
Gotta trade out one for Balic, who will it be?

Pickett v Florent v Eddy v Barrett
Florent I reckon

crowls

Quote from: GoLions on April 28, 2017, 01:24:57 PM
Quote from: My Chumps on April 28, 2017, 01:22:19 PM
Gotta trade out one for Balic, who will it be?

Pickett v Florent v Eddy v Barrett
Florent I reckon
or Pickett.    Eddy and Barret both have -ve BE and could generate cash if they come in.